Brahms: Piano Concerto No. 2; Piano Sonata No. 1 [ORIGINAL RECORDING REMASTERED]

Robert La Marchina (Performer), Robert LaMarchina (Performer), Johannes Brahms (Composer), Erich Leinsdorf (Conductor), Chicago Symphony Orchestra (Orchestra), Sviatoslav Richter (Performer)

Product Details

• Performer: Robert La Marchina, Robert LaMarchina, Sviatoslav Richter
• Orchestra: Chicago Symphony Orchestra
• Conductor: Erich Leinsdorf
• Composer: Johannes Brahms
• Audio CD (July 13, 2004)
• SPARS Code: ADD
• Number of Discs: 1
• Format: Original recording remastered
• Label: RCA
• ASIN: B0002DD5U2
• In-Print Editions: MP3 Download
• Average Customer Review: 4.4 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (7 customer reviews)
• Amazon.com Sales Rank: #129,514 in Music (See Bestsellers in Music)

  Popular in this category: (What's this?)

  #26 in

  Music > Classical > Featured Performers, A-Z > ( R ) > Richter, Sviatoslav

• This is item 26 in The Red Seal Classics Library Series.

Editorial Reviews

Amazon.com

Two supreme masterpieces of the piano literature played by a supreme master of the instrument--could there be a more felicitous combination? Brahms wrote his first sonata in 1853, his second concerto almost 30 years later; Richter recorded the concerto in 1960 on his first American tour, the sonata almost 30 years later live at a barn in Germany. The sonata is so formidable technically and musically that it is performed very rarely; the concerto, one of Brahms's greatest mature works, has become a beloved staple of the repertoire. Richter, a well-hidden Soviet treasure until the end of the Cold War, became an instant sensation in the West, and this recording proves again that his playing was unique. It combined seemingly incompatible qualities: his tone had the transparent lucidity of fine lace, with impeccably articulated passage-work and perfectly balanced voicing both in contrapuntal lines and chords, yet it also had an infinite range of colors and inflections; sonorous and sustained, as if he were caressing rather than striking the keys, it was never harsh and could go from massive power to an elfin, gossamer delicacy. His mental and emotional concentration were riveting: he could spin long, arching phrases, build up tension and intensity, and maintain a sense of structure and coherence; his transitions and mood changes were poised and organic. His Brahms interpretation is monumental: classically austere, yet romantically free and ardent, it enters into the youthful, heroic tempestuousness of the sonata and the wistful, dreamy melancholy and profound inwardness of the concerto; the slow movements are pure magic. From the first notes of the very expansive, other-worldly opening of the concerto we know that we are about to embark on an extraordinary experience. The orchestra matches the pianist's every mood and expression and sounds rich and glorious; the prominent horn and cello solos are wonderful. --Edith Eisler

Customer Reviews

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

38 of 39 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars The ultimate musical experience., January 1, 2005

By	Howard Gardner Stevenson (Seattle, USA) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

This is the greatest recording, or performance, of any piece of music I have heard in my 60 years of life. To begin with, the music is beyond comprehension in its greatness. But, Richter and Leinsdorf and the CSO connected in a once-in-a-lifetime partnership that occurred only by accident (Reiner's illness).
Richter played this ideally, giving Brahms' passionate soul and classical mind equal weight. He didn't dawdle like many recent pianists do. He brought Russian passion to the score, but held on to the Germanic depth of feeling and substance. I give great credit to Leinsdorf, a normally underwhelming conductor. He seized the romantic impulses in the music and plunged ahead with full force, not afraid to let the brass have their say along with the deep strings, creating a richness of sound unequaled in any other version of this work that I've heard.
This performance is ideal for people who see this work as essentially symphonic, rather than a vehicle for solo showiness. Richter complies with an interpretation both powerful and fleet of foot ( a rare combination), without losing the many subtleties in the score. In other words, he performed it the way people tended to in the 1880s, rather than the 1980s, when every note was separated and examined under a microscope. The pianist and conductor see this as one piece of music, not thousands of notes collected together.
The new remastering is, well, masterful. The original recording was impressive sonically, especially in the midrange, and the new 24 bit remastering brings this out magnificently (and quietly), perfectly complementing the performances of Richter, Leinsdorf, and the CSO.
This is not a performance for everyone. If you like your Brahms interpretted as if he were Mozart, or Tchaikovsky, this will either be too powerful or too fast for your taste. If you like your Brahms to continue on the path that Beethoven opened up, this is nonpareil in every respect.
Near the end of his life (30 years after the fact), Richter disavowed this performance. He complained that Leinsdorf pushed the pace too quickly. This is not the first case of a great artist (the greatest pianist we have on record, in my opinion), revising his early ideals as age caught up to him. Artists have often shown throughout the centuries, that they are not the best critics. I think that history will prove Richter's, and Leinsdorf's, initial instincts correct, as I have thought and felt since my first hearing of this amazing record in 1961.

9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars A commanding soloist, now in better sound, November 10, 2005

By	Santa Fe listener - See all my reviews (TOP 100 REVIEWER)

Amazon Verified Purchase

This famous recording of the Brahms Second with Richter used to be unrivaled and still stands at the top of the field. Richter possesses so much power and authority, yet can be so restrained and mysterious when he wants, that no one quite challenges him. In memory he barnstormed more than he actually does here; Pollini and Barenboim are almost as virtuosic. Even after forty years, however, there are moments when no one can phrase like him--Richter seems to think in paragraphs, not single passages--and he remains the only pianist who makes you believe this incredibly challenging work is easy to play. (At 44 min. this is also one of the fastest Brahms Seconds on CD.)

The weakness of this recording is two-fold. The recorded sound is a bit brittle and thin (now coniserably improved in RCA's current remastering). Richter isn't given the gorgeous sonority one hears from Pollini on DG with Abbado (particulary their 1995 remake in digital sound). And Leinsdorf, if better than his usual literal self, at times seems to impede what Richter wants to do. They open the first movement in different worlds, but after that, Leinsdorf manages to gather enough momentum to keep up with his soloist. One wonders how unleashed Richter would have been if the shceduled conductor (I think it was Reiner) hadn't bowed out.

Those two drawbacks aside, this superb CD will never go out of print. As you listen to Richter so totally dominate the closing pages, you feel glad about that--every future improvement in sound will make the performance more alive. The coupling is his equally acclaimed performance of Brahms's youthful First Sonata, in all its rambling glory.

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars Swift and Sensuous, August 5, 2007

By	Moldyoldie (Motown, USA) - See all my reviews

Amazon Verified Purchase

This is a budget-priced reissue and remastering of what I've read was long the dominant recording of what's come to be one of my favorite piano concertos. Russian pianist Richter recorded this in 1960 during his first American tour; he recorded the early sonata almost thirty years later in Germany.

Richter's performance of the concerto definitely sounds fleeter than what I'm used to; this seemed like it was over in no time! I had to check his timing of the first movement against that of the other two recordings I have: Richter/Leinsdorf 16:43, Gilels/Jochum 18:22, Cliburn/Reiner 17:49. Total time: Richter/Leinsdorf 46:46, Gilels/Jochum 51:44, Cliburn/Reiner 48:21. In any case, Richter's pianism is alternatingly brawny and delicate with fine phrasing and judgement of shifting dynamics. The meltingly beautiful andante third movement is also played somewhat swiftly, but Richter's quiet, introspective probing in conjunction with the cello solo from the orchestra is a paragon of pianistic poetry, though it didn't make my dry eyes well up as Gilels' did. The recorded sound is just fine, but could never be mistaken for a modern recording.