Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
32 of 35 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Very funny, very good short story, September 18, 2005
I just finished the Time Traveler's Wife and was looking around amazon and found this short.
I usually don't pay good money for 1.5 thousand digital words, but I loved Audrey's book, so I thought I'd risk the $[very low price deleted by moderator] since it was a low price. And, it was worth every penny.
This is a funny short story, and I didn't find Time Traveler's Wife funny. But, I think that if you liked the book, you'll love this.
|
|
|
13 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not worth your 49 cents, December 24, 2005
I love the Time Traveler's Wife, but sadly enough "Jakob Wywialowski and the Angels" does not live up to the standard Niffenegger set when with her debut novel. I hardly found the story cute or funny, instead it felt like it was trying to be. But all writing has merit and even if this story is just an exercise, I am sure it was a valuable one for her. And if this story had been made freely available, (on a blog perhaps) I probably would be less criticial. But for half the price of an iTunes music download, I was expecting something a bit more substantial.
|
|
|
4 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Every great idea begins with a spark..., July 4, 2006
...though I'll second some of the thoughts of author Niffenegger's previous reviewers and merely say that perhaps Audrey could have let this one play out a little longer?
I mean, my thinking here is that it's the start of something much more substantial, perhaps even more literary? As in, this isn't the last time we're all going to hear about the likes of Mr. Jakob Wywialowski (I, for one, would love to know who you've modelled this character after, Dear Author)?
Jakob, by the way, seems like the consummate old man cutie -- the grandfather we all want to have.
However, seven pages *is* a bit on the scant side, oui oui? Though I'm the first one to admit one doesn't need to write like Tolstoy to make a literary point, it's a bit on the lower end of the spectrum. Not "bad" lower end but more like "you've left me wanting a whole lot more" lower end. With the foreknowledge that this were to expand into a graphic novel, I mightn't be as indisposed to it, but...
...back to my original point.
Surprisingly, folks, ANGELS is a tight little read. Like its length or niente, you're going to feel something.
Sentences flow cleverly and well. Ms. Niffenegger's vocabulary choice falls into the "nice and easy" spectrum.
ANGELS is, for the most part, a "feelgood" piece, and I think this author is at all times aware of the direction things are headed in the marketplace: people are demanding shorter, more inspirational, reads; ones they can polish off within a short subway/bus ride into work (or leaving work, as the case may be).
Once the technology for this sort of thing becomes widely available, previous readers who've expressed skepticism with the shortness of Niffenegger's tale here may be more accepting of stories of ANGELS' curt length more readily.
Well, perhaps that's just one person's opinion...
In summary: in a world oftentimes gone to the squirrels, sometimes it's just nice to read about something on a groovy upbeat tip.
-- ADM in Prague
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
by Audrey Niffenegger
by Audrey Niffenegger
by Audrey Niffenegger
by Keith Donohue
by Audrey Niffenegger
