Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Get Lost, May 26, 2009
While it is true that the average [American] viewer will not appreciate this film, the reason is not because there isn't much to think about (as one reviewer complains). On the contrary, this film doesn't provide cheap entertainment but rather tasks the viewer with having to think more than the usual mindless cinema that Westerners are accustomed to; the real problem is that this film doesn't entertain Americans in the way that they expect to be entertained by films: by easy, mindless, and gratuitous themes such as sex, violence, melodrama, comedy, etc.
Contrary to what one reviewer has said about the film having no emotional scenes, this film has some of the most emotionally intense and poignant scenes I've ever witnessed in a film, and like a majestic lake whose surface is placid, there exists beneath the surface of this film depths far greater than what the senses can penetrate. There is more to this story than what the film depicts, and that helplessness that you feel as a viewer also helps you to relate to the emotions of the main character, which are the highlight of this film.
Anyone who can't appreciate this film needs to come to terms with their own humanity. Humanity is the only thing that makes this film worth watching, and if this film doesn't show anything that you can relate to, turn off the computer, turn off your cell phone, step outside, and go for a walk. Get lost somewhere and find yourself.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Haunting and mysterious, January 11, 2009
A haunting and mysterious film that begs to be watched more than once. The movie deals with a childless couple on a pilgrimage to a saint's shrine, who spend some time in a remote village devoid of adult males after their car breaks down. The woman ends up taking over the village's one room school while the teacher ( the only resident adult male in the village )goes off to help her husband repair the car, and the interaction between her and the children is priceless.
The first time I watched this, I would have rated it 3 stars like the other reviewer. But every time I watch it I like it more. ( It has the same subtle power as The Band's Visit). The location is almost otherworldly, and the events hover between the real and the absurd in a way very specific to Iranian cinema (Blackboards, Secret Ballot, Marooned in Iraq, Turtles Can Fly, Iron Island et al.)
In the end, I find the film magical and compelling. I lent it to several friends, all of whom watched it more than once for the same reasons...
|
|
|
2.0 out of 5 stars
Not much going on here! Nothing to grab hold of, April 11, 2009
My gut feeling is that the average viewer will not appreciate this film, mainly because it doesn't require much to think about. There isn't heavy drama, no emotional scenes, nothing beneath the surface to ponder, just plain not much here. The scenery is quite a visual for the big screen with its giant rocks and sand.
It may be a struggle to read the subtitles, as the words are light in color often against the color of sand/rocks. This proves to be a challenging read. The Special Features includes a director's statement and biographies, but no commentary. The film runs about 90 minutes.
A photographer and his wife, are stranded in the Iranian desert because the vehicle has broke down. The woman is childless and arrives at a limited school for children whose father's work a great distance. The surrogate/father to the children is also the mechanic who repairs the broken down vehicle. The woman soon replaces the mechanic/teacher. The children become attached. Pass this one.
Try a humorous Iranian film about getting the vote out Secret Ballot.....Rizzo
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|