Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
14 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Not a bad read...and not a great read, March 9, 2002
I was disappointed by this book. Over the last few months, I've been reading the latest literary offerings by political pundits. I saved Bill Press' for last, because I thought it would be my favorite. I liked the angle--an exploration of spin and its influence in every area of our lives. But with the book read, I'm not sure if I learned anything new. Before I get to my major concerns, a few things I liked about the book:
1. It's a fast read. Press writes with clarity and conciseness, a skill not to be downplayed. Especially in political punditry, this is a significant attribute.
2. Chock full of fun examples and anecdotes. Press knows that a good story is always appropriate as support for a point. He doesn't shy away from using them throughout. Excellent historical and contemporary anecdotes.
But...
1. This is a shallow book. The arguments are not unique, the explanations are superficial. There are many ways to communicate the message "nearly everything is spin," and Press covers most of them, consistently repeating and rephrasing this theme.
2. I was let down that Press did not provide a clear conceptualization of what spin really is. As a result, we're left with this broad, abstract notion, and it's not powerful enough to bind the book together.
This was a disappointing read. It's likely I was expecting too much--however, coming to expect a well-written book of political analysis with strong argumentation really doesn't seem to be an overly high expectation.
|
|
|
9 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fun, hilarious, solid and actually bipartisan!!!!, February 28, 2002
OK, so Bill Press lost his dayjob, as co-host of CNN's Crossfire (he is now a "contributor"). But not only will we likely still see him on the tube...but he has a great back-up day-job: as an author. Spin This! has to be one of the funniest, yet most painstakingly researched, books I have ever read. From "spins" dating back to Bibical times, to politics, to show biz, to male-female relationships, SPIN THIS laughingly explores (and exposes) it ALL. Whether you're a Democrat, Republican, Liberal, Conservative...or WHATEVER...you're going to find stuff that you'll LOVE in this book. Even if you don't know anything about politics it is not ALL about political spin. And there's this bonus: Bill Press is actually a screamingly funny and highly talented writer. And that ain't spin. If you think you're going to get a diatribe from him, think again. You really don't. And if you love Bill Press' views and expect him to let Democrats or liberals off the hook, think again, too. In reality, he sits back and explores SPECIFIC "spins" in all walks of life -- and comments on them with laugh-out-loud wisecracks. Still not convinced that this one-of-a-kind book (it is funny but it also can serve as a GREAT reference book due to the truly solid research reflected on each page)can appeal to EVERYONE? Then consider his Spin Hall of Fame where he lets famous commentators of all persuasions profile THEIR idea of the most outrageous spins. To name a few: Robert Novak (on Al Gore), Kate O'Beirne (Hillary Clinton), Cal Thomas (Satan), Al Franken (Karl Rove), and one of his CNN replacements, Paul Begala on GWB. Clearly his colleagues on the right and left had a lot of fun with this project, too. Painstakingly researched -- and painstakingly hilarious. Gift it to those who agree and disagree with you!
|
|
|
8 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Good couch read, January 26, 2002
Bill Press's latest spin on spin will not only open your eyes but give you a good idea about the nature of politics, as well as other fields such as media, law, and advertising. Press calls it something between the truth and a lie. It all depends on when and how you use it. Press is slightly left of center but gives a fairly even handed jab to all sides. Giving Clinton his due as the master of spin, followed closely by Bush (in politics). A quote from the book about what makes news;"In his masterful biography of Hearst, David Nasaw explains the famous publisher's guiding principal: "News is not a phenomenon that exists in the real world, waiting to be discovered...An event becomes news only when journalists and the editors decide to record it. More often than not, what determines whether an occurrence is noteworthy or not is the ease with which it can be plotted and narrated so that readers will want to read about it." Thus spin feeds the beast of corporate-driven journalists." I'll leave you with one example of spin from the book: Spin: "I'm just an average American who found herself in a situation not of her own making." --Linda Tripp Translation: I'm going to get a book deal and I'll rat on my friend to do it. Recommended
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|