Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
69 of 87 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Much better than they say, November 13, 2005
They are the critics, especially those writing reviews collected online. Part of this is that they want Jennifer Aniston to be cast, as usual, as the wholesome girl next door.
The critics saw all the surprises ahead of time. I really didn't and I enjoyed them. (If you figured out the twists in A Beautiful Mind, you can guess this, too.)
Another possible reason for the tepid reviews is that it is an upsetting movie with several horrific scenes of violence. No doubt about it, it simply isn't a likable movie; if you were to take your kids --dont!-- they'd have nightmares.
Financial advisor Lucinda Harris (Jennifer Aniston) and ad guy Charlie Schine (Clive Owen) have an illict affair after a chance meeting on a commuter train. But it doesn't go smoothly and soon they are victims of an extortion plot.
As usual, the advertising agency scenes are off the mark. What is a "commercial executive?" Even though we see Charlie at work what exactly does he do? (Even What Women Want -- a much better film -- went wrong here.) Even worse, there is no there there to the financial advisor scenes. So both characters' jobs are Hollywood hooey.
Both the main chracters are in a complete bind between family conflicts -- Charlie has a sick child -- high-pressure jobs, their shared secret, and their shared victimhood.
As in all the Hitchcock films, the victims can't go the police. (Remember how threatening the police officer is to Marion Crane -- Janet Leigh -- in Psycho?)
Surely this is no Hitchcock masterpiece, but it is an entertaining and twisty thriller.
The screenwriter Stuart Beattie also wrote the far better Collateral. Maybe the more you liked Collateral, the less you will like Derailed?
Even with two well-known stars, there is zero anticipatory buzz about this movie. We all know Jennifer Aniston from Friends on TV, but Mr. Owen has been in many excellent films: Sin City, Closer, The Bourne Identity, Gosford Park, Croupier.
Rappers RZA and Xzibit are well-cast supporting players. Vincent Cassel captures the essence of the chameleon-like villain. You want to throttle him throughout the picture.
Did the studio that released this picture have little faith in it? The marketing budget and the short marketing time frame -- a few weeks in advance, not months -- suggest that's true. Maybe their dismissive attitude was conveyed to the critics.
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Best Suspense Drama I've Seen In Years, March 17, 2006
I just got done watching this film. I was pleasantly surprised at the range of emotions this film pulled out of me. I really felt for the characters. Jennifer Aniston is a very gritty, meaty role. Clive Owens, always brings a great intensity into any role ... he chose a great role here. I loved seeing him as this character. He really drew you in. I also have to say, I loved seein' Rza, one of my favorite rappers acting and doin' a damn good job of it. All in all I have to say this has got to be the best suspense drama I have seen in a while. *I work in a video shop* I would highly recommed this film.
|
|
|
24 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Intense Thriller in the Hitchcock Tradition , June 18, 2006
This movie is a little difficult to watch because of all the violence the viewer is exposed to---rape, torture, and mind numbing bloodshed---but in its own way, this is an entertaining thriller.
It begins as an adulterous love/lust story when Lucinda Harris (Jennifer Aniston) and Charles Schine (Clive Owen) meet on a Chicago commuter train. Charles is bored with life, saddled with a very sick daughter, and having a difficult time at work. He is thrilled that someone as beautiful as Lucinda could be interested in him and before long the two are headed to a hotel. Just as they are about to consummate their relationship, a thug (Vincent Cassel) bursts into the room, robs and beats Charles and rapes Lucinda repeatedly. Ashamed, shaken, and badly hurt, Charles is shocked when the villain not only calls him and demands blackmail money but also shows up at his home. Charles pays the blackmail but enough is not enough. The villain, sensing Charles' weakness and inability to fight back, increases his demands.
There are twists and turns that will keep the viewer on the edge of his seat. I won't, of course, reveal what happens, but the first twist is not the last and this story will not let you relax. It's terribly violent, unnerving from start to finish, but worth seeing. Clive Owen is sympathetic as the embattled victim and Jennifer Aniston proves once and for all she's not Rachel Green anymore.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|