Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Lacus Clyne Lip Syncs to Someone Else's Singing Voice in the English Dub, August 2, 2006
One of my favorite moments is when Lacus Clyne sings the song "Fields of Hope" as Junius 7 falls. Deeply moving. Written, composed and arranged by Yuki Kajiura, and sung by Lacus Clyne's Japanese voice actor Rie Tanaka, the original Japanese version of "Fields of Hope" is great. Unfortunately, no credits are provided for the English dubbed version of "Fields of Hope." Lacus's English singing voice sounds much closer to Lacus's English speaking voice in Gundam Seed Destiny than it does in Gundam Seed. But, to be frank, Lacus Clyne's English voice actor, Chantal Strand, is a terrible singer. I have heard her sing and that is DEFINITELY NOT Chantal Strand singing as Lacus Clyne. Another English voice actor, Jillian Michaels is generally recognized as Lacus's singing voice in Gundam Seed. But it does not sound like Jillian Michaels is the person singing "Fields of Hope" in Gundam Seed Destiny either. Bandai Entertainment and The Ocean Group should state who Lacus Clyne's singing voice in the English dub is or are. An alternative is to sing live and prove one is the real singer of a song - something which Milli Vanilli failed to do in their infamous fake singing scandal over a decade and a half ago.
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Drastic Measures and Stakes Being Raised, August 9, 2008
Well first off this is definetly the DVD for Athrun Zala fans. His character ultimately takes center stage for all five episodes. More characters from the original Gundam Seed pop up and virtually everything done at the end of the original Gundam Seed Series wound up being for nothing.
The first episode was by far the most action packed, making it the best. The new main character Shinn Asuka takes a backseat while two old faces take center stage. Yzak who is now a ZAFT commander and Dearka who was demoted for joining the Archangel during the last war. Along with Athrun the three of them pretty much fight off the Coordinator terrorists and the three Earth Forces pilots who stole the new Gundams. Athrun and Cagalli may have helped prevent Genesis from being fired on the Earth, but in the end it didn't mean a thing because the earth really gets it bad. It was a very big moment in the series, but considering the direction the series takes towards the end one could wonder whether they made a mistake having something as drastic as this happen so early in the series.
We are given the distinct impression that Athrun and Cagalli have dubbed themselves peacekeepers. If that's the case both of them really made some stupid decisions. Cagalli had no intention of telling the other members of the Orb government that Coordinator terrorists were responsible. So she really came off looking untrusting like a true politician when they found out. Athrun goes to the Plants to talk with Chairman Durandal because he's worried about what the Plants will do and he feels guilty about his father's actions. If Athrun was so concerned about the Plants then maybe he shouldn't have left them to begin with. Being former Chairman Zala's son he could've helped influence and inspire the Plants in a different direction. So you can't help but sympathize with Durandal when we're introduced to Meer Campbell, a double of Lacus Clyne doing just that. Besides Durandal isn't the one that needs to be spoken to about not starting a war, he's obligated to instruct ZAFT to fight back if the Earth Forces attack. What else can he do? A new Gundam is introduced and it has Athrun's name on it.
Kira Yamato, Lacus Clyne, Murrue Ramius and Andrew Waltfeld who are now all living in Orb each make appearances in this volume, although it's not made clear yet what there purpose will be in Gundam Seed Destiny. Murrue Ramius is now going by a different name like Athrun, no doubt in an effort to hide from the Earth Forces who she betrayed. Andrew Waltfeld has been kicking back and just keeping tabs on the relations between the earth and the Plants. The two people fans have been dieing to see, Kira and Lacus have been living with Reverend Malchio and helping take care of his orphans on a small island.
One of the best scenes is where Shinn Asuka comes face to face with Kira at the memorial where his family was killed. This volume is just as exciting as the first one so I highly recommend it.
|
|
|
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Keeps Getting Better!!!, June 14, 2006
For those of us who love Seed, this is a great disk! Be careful reading this, it may cause nail biting while you wait for the mailman!!! We see Junius-7's final hours, which causes alot of conflict for Athrun, Cagalli, and Shinn. Of course, we also see some old friends returning (check out the leader of the ground crew that's helping fix the Miranda), and of course, when he has a problem, who does Athrun turn to? (Hint - His name starts with a K...) But, who is that pink-haired girl that Athrun runs into in the Plants??? I know you're yelling at the TV - Hey,isn't she supposed to be in Orb with his best friend?! Is it REALLY Lacus? (check the hair ornament out, if you haven't already) I am eagerly awaiting the next disk, which will see the return of some more old friends, as well as possibly the biggest wedding crasher ever!!!
|
|
|
|