Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
51 of 58 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Storm Before The Calm, October 11, 2006
Well, its mostly a happy, festive storm (the Paganini) and a sometimes melancholy, but sometimes tense calm (the Spohr).
My limitations in reviewing this: I am a guitarist and have a much deeper background in rock/pop/alt./indie than classical. My classical vocabulary is limited. But I have amassed quite a classical collection over the past year.
My biases in reviewing this: I think Hilary Hahn could walk on water if she tried. But while I love her Beethoven and Brahms, I am not as drawn to her Elgar or Barber. So I think I can be fair.
The Paganini seems written to show off as many of the violinist's skills as possible, and Hilary takes full advantage of the opportunity. There are plenty of trills, runs that move over large ranges of notes and lots of double stops, all played effortlessly, flawlessly and with emotion. Especially astounding is a section at the end of the first movement which involves runs that are played with a sliding effect, instead of punctuated. The piece as a whole really is festive (think cymbal crashes), with intermittent slower passages but always a joy. I do not think it will ever move me as much as the Beethoven or Brahms, but it is a different kind of composition.
As if Hilary heard the "bravos" after the Paganini, the Spohr provides the perfect encore. As if to acknowledge that we all need a rest, the Spohr is about half the length of the Paganini, and much less showy -- but dramatic and thoroughly satisfying. The perfect calm after the perfect storm!
Thanks Hilary!
|
|
|
17 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Paganini and Spohr would smile and shake hands, November 19, 2006
This is a very substantial album. Hilary Hahn, like always, never stops to amaze. The Paganini concerto is perfectly played, her intentions fulfilled. Her approach and performance for this piece are definitely different than any other violinists'. The technical highlights are skillfully controlled, the operatic qualities successfully emphasized. The Spohr concerto is just as beautiful as it can get. It stands out as solidly as any other well-known concertos. Hahn made an extremely smart decision to pair the two concertos in the album. The histories of the pieces and composers are very well studied and considered.
Hilary Hahn's technique shines very pleasantly. Every note is clear and equally considered. The orchestra and conductor did quite a good job. The tempi are very nice.
This, I would say, is one of the best classical CDs in 2006. Another Grammy for Hilary Hahn is very possible.
|
|
|
23 of 27 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Hahn = Opera Singer?, October 26, 2006
I have been a fan of Hilary Hahn's for some time now, and each new release is a true pleasure. Her playing certainly is music at its greatest - the technical mastery, the musicality, the way she lets the music be its own entity. Indeed, one gets the impression even from this recording of one of the showiest violin pieces ever written that it's not about her at all. Hahn offers her motivation for pairing these concertos in her program notes, aptly titled "The Violin as Voice." The Paganini and Spohr concerti both possess dramatic vocal qualities, and Hahn demonstrates this to perfection in a masterful recording that cannot be ignored.
Vocal qualities aside, the Paganini and Spohr are spectacular, each in its own way. The Paganini does not fail in being a thrilling showpiece - indeed, the orchestra and soloist become a breathtaking sort of circus act, with the violinist as the featured performer. Never have I heard a more exhilarating display. The Spohr, a lesser known work, was written in the style of an opera scene and possesses a darker demeanor. Hahn champions the work quite nicely, and ably demonstrates why it deserves to be placed beside the Paganini.
The recording is stunningly beautiful, and all the more stunning because Hahn's technique is so sure that one forgets about it and can focus on the music itself. One complaint - the recording technology is not quite capable of capturing Hahn's sound in all its glory. After hearing her live, it's hard to go back to the recordings! There's nothing like it.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|