Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
9 of 9 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
First Impressions, February 11, 2007
I bought this album yesterday, so it hasn't had a chance to grow on me, but I can offer a few impressions.
First of all, longtime fans should be warned that this is the least melodic thing Sondre Lerche has ever done. The music is angular and energetic, at times downright raucous, and the wistful pop hooks of Two-Way Monologue are nowhere to be found. Instead, we have rapid, unpredictable melodies that twist and turn through a variety of blue notes and key changes. Some bits are catchy, while others (on first listen at least) are just hard to follow. These songs are clearly the product of an agile and highly trained musical mind, and I find them fascinating on an intellectual level. Emotionally, however, they seem somewhat barren: too much logic, not enough feeling. Again, I have not given the songs a chance to grow on me, so it's entirely possible that the emotion is there and I'm missing it. And to be fair, there are a few numbers here that immediately struck me as pretty, specifically Tragic Mirror, John Let Me Go, and Happy Birthday Girl. Hence, I'm giving this album the benefit of the doubt and not four but five stars - really four and a half, but I decided to round up because of my general esteem for the artist and because I'm the only reviewer so far. Plus, I have a feeling I will start to like it better. Most of my favorite albums struck me this way at first.
I recommend Phantom Punch highly if you are a musician or songwriter, or if you just really love Sondre Lerche. His voice and lyrical personality are as quirky and likeable on this album as they have ever been. However, there is no doubt that this is less accessible than his previous work; even the jazz of Duper Sessions, I think, does more to draw in the casual listener. You should only buy this album if you have a certain amount of patience; that said, I hope you do have the patience, because I think you'll find it's worth it.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Sondre All Grown Up, March 9, 2007
Sondre Lerche's fourth LP release is a refreshing departure from his earlier work: it's more frenetic and upbeat, experimenting with Latin American-flavored twists and yet still maintaining a definitively "indie rock" label, more so than the sweet-sounding pop melodies of Two Way Monologue and Faces Down (and obviously more so than the jazzy Duper Sessions). There is a revitalizing energy to Phantom Punch that assures the listener that Sondre refuses to box himself into any one category, always experimenting with different types of music without losing that distinctive and wholly original appeal.
"Airport Taxi Reception," "The Tape," "Phantom Punch," and "Face the Blood" are the songs that will get fans tapping their feet and heads along with some truly ear-catching hooks and Franz Ferdinand-inspired riffs. "Say It All," "Tragic Mirror," "Well Well Well," and "After All" are more representative of classic Sondre, and yet there is an air of maturity there that has replaced the sweet but naively innocent impression of earlier albums.
Hardcore fans will recognize the third incarnation of former B-Side "John, Let Me Go" that has cropped up on several EPs over the years in both acoustic and electric form. This time, it's even more pumped up, with a longer, more energized bridge that incorporates some great harmonica work.
Suffice to say, if you're a Sondre fan, you will adore this album as always. If you're new to Sondre, this album is far more mainstream-geared than any prior album and is an excellent introduction into the the ouvre of this phenomenally talented singer and songwriter.
|
|
|
1 of 1 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Phantom Punch, February 20, 2007
Sondre's fourth album "Phantom Punch" is just that: punchy. It's way more upbeat and frenetic and LOUD than his previous work. It's especially LOUDER than the superb Duper Sessions, which I absolutely loved.
His softer singer/songwriter style that was on display in his first two albums still shines through on a few tracks. Thankfully, his very distinct voice is there throughout.
But, be warned, this is a bit of a departure from his previous efforts. That said, it's still way better than 90% of the other CD's you could be buying. I'm not a fan of the louder Sondre, but it grows on me with each repeat listening. He's still a superb, relatively unknown, artist.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|