Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
13 of 14 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Not to be Missed, February 15, 2007
"PAPER DOLLS"
Not to be Missed
Amos Lassen and Cinema Pride
"Paper Dolls" (Strand Releasing) is simply fantastic. I don't usually start a review with words of praise but in this case I have to do so. I sat and was enthralled by the movie--maybe because it is a first class film, maybe it is because it is an Israeli film and I am an Israeli citizen. At any rate this is one you do not want to miss. The message for diversity is so strong and so powerful and the movie is so well done that I wanted to jump up and yell "Bravo" when it was over. What makes it even more amazing is that it is true.
A group of Philippine men immigrated to Israel to work as caregivers during the day and as drag queens by night. Their lives are not glamorous--caregivers take a lot of abuse. They go to a section of Tel Aviv, known as B'nei Brak to work with the elderly, some of whom are very Orthodox Jews (the most religious kind). These Filipinos are bound together by being members of a group known as "Paper Dolls", a troupe of transvestites who perform nightly at Filipino clubs. During the day they are men and take care of their clients including bathing and feeding them as well as taking them for walks. At night they haul out the satin, sequins, and feather and become the Paper Dolls.
Their "trans" lives are secret to most of their employers but there are some that do know and the trannies, in that case, are "adopted" into their families. If they want to stay in Israel, it is very important to have a family that supports them. If they lose their jobs they also lose their work visas and face the threat of deportation. Their legality as workers depends entirely upon their employers.
It seems that the situation in Israel is much more lenient than the situation in their own country and what the underlying message of the movie portrays is a portrait of outsiders who seek acceptance and freedom in a country whose laws are based on the ancient writings of the Five Books of Moses. Prejudice is evident (as we all saw when World Pride that was to be held in Jerusalem was cancelled at the last minute this year). Even the large gay community of Tel Aviv (which has become a stronghold for gay men) does not want to accept them. Even though the guys who are Paper Dolls enjoy the liberalism of the country, legally they are outsiders. The documentary concentrates on and explores the immigrant worker in Western culture as well as deals with those who have been cast out of society because of gender issues. All the guys want is to be accepted. The members of the troupe are incredible guys full of love for their clients and full of live for their audiences. This situation is not unique to them as it is similar all over the world. Immigrant workers are not dealt with in the best of circumstances and the director, Tomer Heyman, uses the Paper Dolls, as an example of the way such workers are treated.
The movie has so much to say about so many issues. It is a joy to watch the walls coming down between the religious and the gay and to see that a little understanding goes a long way. Everything about the movie is right on the nose. The acting is great, the cinematography is brilliant (Israel looks beautiful), the direction is near perfection and overall, "Paper Dolls" is an enjoyable, exhilarating and awareness raising film that should not be missed. When I lived in Israel the policy toward gay men had just begun to change for the better. The country is wide open now and Israel is on her way to becoming a gay capital. It is movies like this that affirm our zest for living, give us hope for tomorrow and allow us to be thankful for what we have. Don't miss "Paper Dolls".
|
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
There's a distraction here., August 18, 2009
The Paper Dolls usually perform for Filipino audiences. When they performed for a mainstream Israeli one, they were overshadowed by the hot, muscle-bound, naked dancer on stage. This is similar to a huge problem in this work.
The director in the film is often seen here. He is hot, hot, hot! Even the Paper Dolls acknowledge it. He has that Jeremy Piven or Eric Bana type of hotness. So it's hard to focus on the main subjects when his beauty upstages them.
The director seems like a nice, progressive guy. Still, he needs to be modeling or in a blue movie or working with Zeb Atlas or something. His pulchritude was distracting.
|
|
|
3 of 5 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
an ok documentary on transvestites in Israel, June 22, 2007
*Paper Dolls* is about a Filipino transvestite troupe living in Israel. These Filipino transvestite are caregivers by day and performers by night. Actually, throughout the week, they take care of elderly Jewish men. On their nights off, they perform as Paper Dolls in various places.
I thought it was a wonderful documentary with an interesting angle about Filipino transvestites living in Israel and take care of elderly Jewish men. Some of these Jewish men are not aware of the other lives of these transvestites. The others are and simply do not care. All they care is that they're treated well and looked after. These Filipinos have no problem doing their day jobs because they believe it is part of their own culture to take care of the elders.
This documentary focuses on several issues: immigration, religion, homosexuality, night life and of course, politics. While life may seem to be better for these transvestite Filipinos in Israel, they are aware that they're just strangers in a strange land. Soon, they must think of their future and unfortunately, it isn't Israel.
While I thought it was an interesting documentary, I felt that their performances as Paper Dolls wasn't really up to par or at least mesmerizing. Even the people who saw their show felt they were amateurish. I've seen plenty of drag shows and the good ones are able to knock the socks off of you. This troupe didn't. So, to watch this, set your expectations low.
|
|
|
|
DVD ~ Transgender women
DVD ~ Ari Folman
DVD ~ Lior Ashkenazi
DVD ~ Trine Dryholm. David Dencik.
DVD ~ Tanner Cohen
on 
