Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
17 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Should be crunched under my car tires, September 22, 2007
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
Installation proceeded uneventfully, requiring no more time than expected, although it did require a reboot, which I found a little surprising for this sort of application. The interface, while a little confusing to start with, did not take much time to figure out: 'Add Movie' to a 'Compilation', select the target configuration and 'Save As' that configuration.
That, however, is about all of the good news. Sure I figured out how to do the conversion process, but then I had to figure out just what I could convert. After trying a large random selection of DVDs from my 500+ disk collection, from early black and whites to current releases to documentaries to TV shows, I drew a complete 0% that I could convert. Wanting to at least have converted something when I wrote this review, I chose a 256Mb mpg file of my wife's graduation (about 5-10 minutes elapsed play time). Conversion time on my 2GHz AMD 64 system required just shy of 10 minutes. Running at normal priority effectively locked up my system as Crunch hogged 99% of the processor, in background priority it left me able to write this review while I reran the conversion. The resulting file was playable on my iPod with reasonable resolution and Crunched to 32Mb.
So what is the bottom line? If all that you are looking for is a tool to convert your home movies to watchable format on your iPod or similar device, Crunch, while a little slow in my opinion, will do the job. If, however, you are looking for a way to backup your DVD library or even make some of the movies available for portable devices, this is not the tool for you. Given what it can do, I have to conclude that Crunch is either over priced or under featured.
[I have to agree with another reviewer that AoA DVD Ripper does indeed seem to be a fine choice for those interested in backing up their DVD collection.]
P-)
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Home Movies on iPod - YES, Easy to Use - YES, Shrek for the Road Trip - NO, September 26, 2007
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
When I saw this product it looked perfect for what I was hoping to do. I was hoping to get my wife a Video iPod and load some home movies of the kids as well as couple of our kid's DVD's so they could watch them on long drives. There are plenty of kludgy shareware options out there, but I was looking for drag and drop simplicity.
What I got was most of what I was expecting. The ease of use is great, it allows her to select her file and convert it to the format she needs easily. Getting video of the kids onto the ipod was great and straightforward. It took time, but she now has a video gallery of our kids to show to friends and family.
What I didn't understand was the definition of "your DVD's." This actually means DVD's you have created yourself, not DVD's in your video library. This is not a tool for ripping copyrighted DVD's. Somehow I was thinking it was like iTunes where you can rip your personal CD's for use on your iPod. In hindsight, this makes sense, but it didn't seem to be a limitation in the description, nor was there any disclaimer.
While it didn't live up to its "One-stop shop for your video needs" claim, it is what it is; an easy way to massage your personal videos into an iPod format. For that part, it lived up to my expectations.
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Freddy, My Babysitter's Dad, Just Loves to Crunch, October 26, 2007
Customer review from the Amazon Vine™ Program (What's this?)
I had great hopes for Crunch, but they were quickly dashed. Yes it lets me convert my DivX movies to Quicktime, but I don't have an Apple TV or an iPhone, so who cares? Also it won't do anything with DVD movies which are encrypted with copy protection which includes every movie you can legally buy. So I use Mac the Ripper, a free program which does the job for me just fine. However, I can see that if you used Apple TV, you could really benefit from this program, especially if you broke the DRM copy protection on your legally purchased movies.
I should had that the interface is very much like what you'd expect if you've used Roxio Toast. Like most good Mac products, you can figure out how to use Crunch without a manual.
I should also add that I've given my copy of Crunch to our babysitter's dad who does have an Apple TV and he has reported back to me that he likes it a lot. He takes a lot of video and now he's crunched it all up and he claims to have recovered acres of hard drive space. So for the right person this is apparently a great product. Sadly I'm not that person, but since I've seen Freddy (the babysitter's dad) get along swimmingly with Crunch, I guess I have to give it five stars, even though it isn't for me.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|