Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The 'Symphony of Seasons' is Good ..., September 4, 2007
... but the rest is not anything I particularly want to hear again, with the possible exception of 'In Memory -- H.H.L.' for string orchestra.
Dan Locklair is a name I'd been hearing a fair amount in the past few years, primarily associated with choral music. But I'd never heard any of his other music. He was born in 1949 and is professor of composition at Wake Forest University. He's been a professional organist since his teens, and studied composition at Eastman under Joseph Schwantner, and also with Ezra Laderman. Thus it is no surprise that he is a competent composer. The music on this disc is notable for its subtle and expert orchestration. The music is entirely tonal. Use of rhythmic and metric complexity is attractive. Where much of this music falls down is in its too-frequent use of mundane, even boring, materials and its disappointingly bland harmonies. In the harp concerto, for instance, there is ceaseless triadic arpeggiation, enough that one wants to say 'there's more to the harp than that!' The song cycle 'Lairs of Soundings', to texts by Ursula Le Guin, is edgy and made more so by the voice of soprano Janeanne Houston. The five-minute overture 'Phoenix and Again' is for full orchestra. It was written for a celebration at Wake Forest and is suitably celebratory in nature, with recurring brass fanfares and wind filigree.
The find on this disc is Locklair's Symphony No. 1 (2002), subtitled 'Symphony of Seasons.' The orchestration is incredibly rich and varied. Locklair has almost certainly put in deep study of such masters as Respighi and Rimsky Korsakov. The four movements are, in this order: Autumn, Winter, Spring, Summer. 'Autumn' is bracing, even triumphant, and I had to think that to some extent this is based on Locklair's being an academic for whom the beginning of the school year is cause for excitement. For me 'Winter' is the most attractive. It is a chaconne that recurs twelve times with varying orchestration and harmonization, building to towering climaxes before tapering off to a serene almost medieval-sounding finish. 'Spring' is the symphony's scherzo and revels in its asymmetric time signatures. Like the classic scherzo, the movement has a gentler trio section that is succeeded by a joyful, whirling conclusion. 'Summer' reflects the balmy even enervating weather of the American South with lush harmonies and serene rhythms. A clever touch is the use of 'Sumer is icumen in' in counterpoint with the chorus of 'In the Good Old Summertime.' I can easily see this work gaining some sort of hold in American symphony programs.
Finally, one cannot but respond to 'In Memory -- H.H.L.' (2005) written in tribute to the composer's late mother. It is an entirely lovely adagio for string orchestra and as the CD's conductor, Kirk Trevor, mentions it has a more than passing resemblance to Barber's 'Adagio for Strings.' I would not go so far as to say, as Trevor does, that it is a 'worthy successor' of Barber's piece, but it certainly has much the same feel. It is given a fine reading here.
The orchestra on this CD is one that has recorded much for Naxos -- the Slovak Radio Symphony Orchestra -- and its participation here is variable. It does itself proud in the Symphony and 'In Memory'. There are ensemble and intonation problems, possibly reflecting inadequate rehearsal time, in some of the rest of the program.
A cautious recommendation, primarily for the Symphony and 'In Memory.'
Scott Morrison
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Noble, October 2, 2007
Since a full exegesis has been already posted I will rather go straight to the point. This CD shows a good American composer. The footprints of favorite American composers permeate throughout, which is no criticism! The Symphony is a worthy piece, quite noble. The other pieces are OK, but I've heard much worse from many others.
What frustrates me is not Mr Locklair's music, but the fact that American composers have to go to Slovakia to hear their music recorded. That is sad and pathetic. When I was listening to the Symphony I was tinking: "If it only was a good (American) orchestra in better sound..." So Mr Locklair's music loses; and we as well. As always, it probably all boils down to money. Sad state of events when you live and care for this country, the US of A.
My four stars are because Mtr Locklair's music deserves a hear and the price is right. I just hope someone in the future records a second version of the Symphony, the way it deserves.
|
|
|
|
- the new music site from IMDb and Amazon.
