Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
21 of 23 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
4.5 Stars... Excellent overview of Radiohead's EMI studio albums, June 3, 2008
Music: 5 Stars... Compilation: 4 Stars
When Radiohead decided with the "In Rainbows" album not to re-up with EMI, it was only a matter of time before the label would squeeze a few more drops out of the money machine that Radiohead was for EMI. The label simply had to find a good time and excuse to do so, and that time has come (new tour!). The band has made clear that it has nothing to do with this "best of", all the while also acknowledging that EMI has the legal right to do this. Now the question is: is this compilation any good?
"The Best of Radiohead" (17 tracks; 76 min.) not surprisingly focuses on tracks from three albums: a whopping 6 tracks from 1995's commercial breakthrough album "The Bends", including the singles Just, My Iron Lung, High and Dry, Fake Plastic Trees, Street Spirit (Fade Out) and also the fabulous title tracks. 1997's "OK Computer" album, viewed by many as one of the most important albums of the 90s, gets 4 tracks, including the singles Paranoid Android, Karma Police, No surprises, and also Lucky. 2000's "Kid A" gets 3 tracks: Optimistic, Idioteque, and Everything In Its Right Place. With that, 75% of this "best of" compilation is filled. The remaining 3 studio albums get a mere 4 tracks: the monster hit Creep from 1993's "Pablo Honey"; Pyramid Song from 2001's "Amnesiac; and finally There There and 2+2=5 from 2004's "Hail to the Thief".
In all, it is difficult to argue with that selection. Only 2 singles did not make in on here (Knives Out from "Amnesiac" and Go to Sleep from "Hail to the Thief", but this is not "The Singles of Radiohead". I will say that I am not crazy with the sequencing of the album (notice that the 3 tracks from "Kid A" are buried in the second half). But all in all, EMI actually did make a pretty good job of it, imagine that! For anyone not all that familiar with Radiohead, this is a great place to start. If you are wondering whether to buy this, or instead the 2CD "Special Edition" (which comes with an additional 13 songs on a second CD), I'd recommend to buy this single CD compilation. If you like what you hear, the next step is to explore the individual studio albums of Radiohead.
|
|
|
9 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A pretty good overview of the best band currently out there, June 4, 2008
First off, let me say that I am somewhat obsessed with Radiohead - they're my favorite band other than the Beatles, and easily the best group currently making music. So when I first learned of a Radiohead compilation, I almost flew into a "Pacifist's rampage". That is, I almost threw assorted harmless objects such as cloth napkins and pillowcases within a five-inch radius in an otherwise empty room. But then I calmed myself down, and realized that this is a great intro to a fantastic band. See, the thing about Radiohead is that a compilation actually works for them. Their albums (particularly the Bends, OK Computer, Kid A and In Rainbows, though they have yet to disappoint me) are all very good, or at least have very good moments, and they've never made a bad one. But their best songs make perfect sense out of album context (other than "Treefingers", a brief instrumental that serves no purpose other than to link the first and second halves of the album). So they're not like Pink Floyd, whose albums you have to hear entirely in order to get where they're going. Nor are they the Beatles (the greatest band ever, by the way) who have too many hits, famous songs, and whatnot, to fit on four CD's.
So, basically, the casual Radiohead fan should just go for it. It contains all of Radiohead's most significant hits not found on In Rainbows, after all - "Creep", "High and Dry", "Fake Plastic Trees", "Just", "Paranoid Android", "Karma Police", "No Surprises", "Lucky", "Optimistic", "Pyramid Song", "There There" and so forth; and a few album tracks, too! I have to give them the thumbs-up for including "The Bends", which rocks like hell, and the apocalyptic techno "Idioteque", a fan favorite.
I don't know what else to say, really. If you're new to Radiohead, and just want all the hits on one disc, scoop it up. But be warned: this group can be addicting.
|
|
|
12 of 15 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A good place for fans to begin?, June 3, 2008
I have never been a fan of Radiohead. But I kept hearing how amazing the band was and how they are considered music royalty of the late 90s and 2000's.
So I picked this compilation up.
Radiohead are an interesting band.
I always thought of them as a boring, overly praised mediocre band.
I can tell now that they are legitimate.
Im still getting used to them...but im hoping the album will fully grow on me!
The tracks are pretty good and I especially enjoy the first 9 or so tracks.
I look forward to listening to some of their full albums as I heard, the songs fully flourish when in company with the context of the other tracks.
I keep hearing about EMIs 'corporate greed' by releasing this.
I say why not? It gives non-fans a platform to hear their music before fully investing in their back catalogue. Im so sick of these people whining about EMIs greed. Look, they distributed Radioheads music since 1993 to all you fans, so why dont they have the right to compile some of the best tracks so new fans can discover them? Without EMI there might not even be a succesful Radiohead.
So 3.5 stars from me. For now.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|