Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
34 of 38 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
I wanted to love it. I like it, instead., June 16, 2009
So I downloaded this more or less the second it was available. I've had the original concept album Chess for years now, and I was very excited to get the Menzel/Pascal/Groban(????) version. It is nice to get a more complete version than the original discs. The added songs have some of the connective tissue that hold the plot together make a substantial difference in listening to a cohesive show. But I'm afraid that musically, at least at first listen, it's only good, not great. And I'm not sure that it's as fun as the earlier recording either.
While I know the creators are touting this as the definitive version of Chess, the older recording has strengths this version lacks. Sure, Josh Groban as the Russian has a beautifully pure voice, but he brings little of the angst that Tommy Körberg brought to the original version, just as Adam Pascal brings little of the fun and snark that Murray Head has as the American. Again, on the concept discs Denis Quilley was a brilliant Malakov, and David Bedella can't match the profound bass or the evil glee of the previous recording. Idina Menzel is a capable Florence, though Elaine Page was wonderful too. The original was lush -- if anything, it's overproduced, but the grandeur of some of the numbers ("Merrano," "Mountain Duet" for example) was part of its charm. Some of these tracks seem a little less grand, and the lyrics have been altered in several places, rarely for the better.
Chess in Concert takes a while to get going. Act II of Chess in Concert is much stronger than Act I, whereas the opposite is true on the original concept discs. Lots of my issues with Chess in Concert redeem themselves in Act II. Pascal and Menzel are quite good, and even Groban sort of acts a role, and doesn't just sing. Chess in Concert really does get better as it goes on.
I'm not sorry I own it, and I will give it several listens before deciding what tracks get heavier rotation. But so far, it's just three and one-half stars to the original's four and one-half.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
The New Revised Standard Version., July 8, 2009
"Chess" is one of the most revised and re-revised shows in history. Beginning with the original concept album in 1984, the show went through a slightly altered London production, then a drastically altered Broadway version (which tanked), and numerous international productions since then, most of which combined songs and plot elements from both the London and New York productions. Still, Tim Rice seems to have wanted to present a "definitive" version, and so we have 'Chess in Concert', presented in London's Royal Albert Hall in 2008.
This version features some of today's brightest young stars from Broadway and the West End: Idina Menzel, Adam Pascal, Kerry Ellis, and Marti Pellow, as well as baritone crooner Josh Groban as Anatoly. Overall the cast is excellent, although Menzel's vocal stylings will perhaps not be to everyone's taste. She does, however, capture Florence's vulnerabilities quite well, and is an excellent vocal belter.
Kerry Ellis has the pleasure of singing "Someone Else's Story", now a song for Svetlana, whose character has been greatly expanded. She approaches the role with grace and a firm vocal confidence. "Rent" veteran Adam Pascal makes an excellent Freddie, capturing both his sleaziness and rather pathetic narcissism. Marti Pellow, the former UK pop star, takes on the role of the Arbiter, although he plays it coolly and with almost too much subtlety. Finally, Josh Groban is superb as Anatoly, his "Anthem" bringing down the Act I curtain with an inspirational and moving performance.
The orchestra under David Firman and the very entertaining chorus add polish and verve to the sometimes difficult and wordy score. Indeed, a lyric booklet would have been helpful (be sure to use the captioning when watching the DVD).
The CD includes most of the show as presented on the DVD, with some minor deletions of dialogue (the part of Walter has been drastically reduced), and most of the explicit language is retained, except for Freddie's use of the "f" word in Act II. I mention this only because there is no Parental Advisory sticker on the CD, so listeners who might be offended should take note.
Overall this is the most complete version of Chess yet recorded, and though nothing could ever replace the original concept album, it does stand on its own merits and hopefully will introduce this exciting and stirring pop opera to a new generation of listeners.
|
|
|
10 of 13 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
It has its merits and its faults, June 17, 2009
I'm giving this newest recording of CHESS three stars for the performance, and an additional star for including material that has, up until now, not been heard on CD.
When I heard that Idina Menzel, Adam Pascal and Josh Groban were going to perform a concert rendition of CHESS, I was very excited. I like each of these performers already, and they do seem to possess the vocal qualities necessary for the characters they play.
The reality was a bit of a let-down, I'm afraid to say. While they are good in the roles, they aren't GREAT. I wasn't blown away by the performances. Frankly, the singing sounds a little unsure in places, as if they were perhaps under-rehearsed or just nervous onstage. This is more true at the beginning of the recording than at the end.
Many listeners might disagree with my assessment -- I'm not trying to say that anyone is BAD here. But, compared to the previous versions of CHESS on record, the performers here don't quite rise to the same level of strength.
That's not to say that this version of CHESS should be skipped. This is, by far, the most complete recording of the score ever made available. It is also a melding of the London and Broadway versions of the score, making it different from either of the cast recordings. Any fan of CHESS should get this recording, for sure.
My hope is that this recording will bring a new group of fans to CHESS. If you're not familiar with the musical, but buy this because you're a fan of Idina Menzel or Josh Groban, hopefully you will eventually purchase the original British album as well. And if you can find the Broadway cast recording, grab it, since it appears to be out-of-print and growing scarce.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
~ Alice Ripley
~ Dolly Parton
~ The New Broadway Cast Recording
~ John Weidman
~ Original Broadway Cast Recording
by Josh Groban 
