Amazon.com: Tomb Raider: Legend: PC: Video Games

66 Reviews

5 star:		(16)
4 star:		(27)
3 star:		(8)
2 star:		(7)
1 star:		(8)

Average Customer Review

3.5 out of 5 stars (66 customer reviews)

Share your thoughts with other customers:

Create your own review

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

33 of 36 people found the following review helpful:

4.0 out of 5 stars A Return to Form That's Great While it Lasts, April 25, 2006

By	Adam Sugarman (Miami Beach, FL) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

Fun:4.0 out of 5 stars

I have been a Tomb Raider fan since the beginning. I fell in love with Ms. Croft the second she unsheathed those dual pistols, just as many other gamers did back in 1996, and followed her to her ungainly demise. After Tomb Raider III, I sat back and lamented the fall in quality, silently hoping Eidos would either just kill the series altogether or find a way to make it work.

Tomb Raider: Legend (the seventh iteration) finds itself in the hands of Crystal Dynamics. Thank god for them, too; they take what was great about the original and revamp it into a good, if not necessarily brilliant, game.

We gain more backstory for Lady Croft in this game than we have in the past. When she was a small girl she and her mother suffered a plane crash in the Nepal. While trying to reach safety, they come accross an artifact that whisks Lara's mom into some strange portal, never to be seen again. It's not consistent with the previous games, but given their lack of interest in a cohesive storyline, that's not a bad thing.

The voice acting is usually quite good, especially on the part of Ms. Croft. To her benefit ( or detriment, depending on your personal prefference), she is alwasy in contact via an earpiece/camera with her comrades back home, so there is always dialogue being delivered. It helps to keep the mood light, and the writing can be funny at times, but it sometimes comes off as corny. Based on various reviews, it's bound to be a love-it-or-hate-it kind of device. Personally, I think it helped flesh out Lara as a character (let's face it; irregardless of her physical form, we don't know much about her, really), but I understand why others might not have.

The graphics are all very good, sometimes bordering on gorgeous. The PC version may look either the best or the worst, depending on your system. For me, it looked great, but on lower-end systems, it might look like a first generation PS2 game. There were slowdowns at times, but nothing that broke up the gameplay.

Thankfully, gameplay can really be a lot of fun. Thanks to the new physics engine, what might have been a typical "insert key in slot A, after backtracking through three levels, then move X number of boxes onto switches" kind of game, the environmental puzzles are much more interesting. The game borrows very heavily from the Prince of Persia games in terms of control and platforming, which is a great thing. Controlling Lara no longer feels like driving a tank, and the mouse-and-keyboard combination is standard. It's not all that original, and Lara isn't as capable a gymnast as the Prince, but it's certainly a step in the right direction.

The downside to gameplay are the now legendary god-awful motorcycle levels. There are only two of them, thank god, but they are absolutely terrible. The graphics get a major downgrade, control is wonky, and they are much too long for their own good. They aren't enough to make you stop playing, but they should have been omitted. Clearly Crystal Dynamics were sold on their "hot chick on a bike" stereotype. The gunplay needs work, too. While it's certainly an improvement on the original's, it's very easy. There is a nifty bullet-time effect you can activate, but it gets old after the 80th enemy you kill using it.

The game is also over far too soon. If it were about ten hours longer than it is, I would have given the fun factor a five, but as is, it simply isn't long enough. It only took me five and a half hours to complete the first time through, although other reviewers have quoted even double that time. Perhaps it's because I'm a Tomb Raider veteran (as well as Prince of Persia veteran), but I simply couldn't imagine it taking anybody, even on the hardest difficulty level, ten hours to complete. The Croft Mansion makes a return, too (with the design of the movie's mansion, rather than the original one we're all so used to), and it is a lot of fun to search through. It might not take too terribly long, either, to discover all the secrets, but it's a nice distraction.

I also get the feeling that this is a test for Eidos to see whether or not to greenlight development on a sequel. The story ends on a cliffhanger, and as a whole it feels episodic. I wouldn't mind seeing a sequel, though, as long as those darned bike levels were removed. At last a Lara Croft game worth its wait in cardboard!

Pros:
Great graphics
Fun gameplay
Better storyline than in the past
Great return to form

Cons:
Terrible motorcycle levels
Far too short
No incentive to replay
Gunplay is weak

Hopefully the next Lara game (we all know there will be one) will utilize the great things this game does, and improve on its weaknesses.

Comment Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)

40 of 46 people found the following review helpful:

3.0 out of 5 stars Fun gameplay, but far too short for its price, April 14, 2006

By	Double W (West Virginia) - See all my reviews

Fun:4.0 out of 5 stars

Lara is certainly back in top shape in this newest game. Tomb Raider: Legend may be the best in the series outside the original game, returning the focus to exploration and puzzle-solving, although there is certainly some gunplay. But it's far too short, with a story that literally ends midway without resolving major plot elements, leaving you feeling a little cheated once it's all over.

First the positives: The graphics are gorgeous even without the next generation content turned on -- the tombs themselves are very well realized -- and the game will run well even for those of us that lack a supercomputer. The voice acting is terrific, and the story is involving. The gameplay also is top notch, relying less on quick reflexes than on brains, with smart level design.

But there are several negatives that detract from the game. The levels are short and not nearly as large as in some of the other TR titles. You'll find yourself often saying "That's it?" The game itself can easily be beaten in two or three quiet evenings, even at normal difficulty, with not much replay value after that. The controls are clumsy, lacking the fluidity and responsiveness of the Prince of Persia games. Many times you know what you want to do, but can't do it because Lara won't respond the way you want her too. The bosses are unimaginative -- with the exception of one encountered outside a medieval castle -- and there are too many of them. And, in what may be the worst sin of all, the story ends without any sort of resolution to the mysteries it raises. Legend is obviously meant to be the first chapter in a larger story, like the first Lord of the Rings film, but when you've invested so much time (and money) in a game title, you're entitled to a well-rounded story experience.

The plus for PC owners is that Legend is cheaper than its console counterparts at $40, although $30 would be more reasonable given how short it is. If you own a console, this is a renter. Too bad the company didn't spend a little more time investing in a longer gaming experience - I suspect poor sales will finally spell the doom of Lara Croft, which is a pity.

Comment Comments (2) | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)

29 of 34 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars An awesome game, supported by an talented voice cast!, April 11, 2006

By	J. Lumbroso (Paris, France) - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)

Fun:5.0 out of 5 stars

I was lucky to experience this game a few days early, and I have to say I have not had this much fun in a long time.

Tomb Raider is back, with a vengeance. Forget the used Tomb Raider Chronicles, forget the botched Angel of Darkness. What Crystal Dynamics is giving us here is a completely rethought franchise.

Depending on the quality of your hardware, you'll either be amazed by the graphics, or completely bedazzled. Tomb Raider now actually looks good, and not just the lush curves (and expressive face) of its archaeologist heroine. The environments are masterfully crafted, and (thanks to an game engine completely rewritten since the past episodes) manage to successfully break from the cube-geometry we've all been used to.

But, but, but-Tomb Raider doesn't only *look* good, it also sounds wicked!! I would never have imagined how big a difference the audio voice-over makes. Indeed, Keeley Hawes is excellent (*excellent*!! "I haven't the foggiest."), and gives Lara some added depth and class. I promise you'll come to love the witty banter exchanged by Lara and her faithful geek team.

The obvious aim of the designers was to make this feel as much as a movie as possible-hence the "action sequences", sort of interactive cinematics. While I have to confess they do not always succeed (and, having to play through the same, at the beginning of a checkpoint "interactive cinematic" over and over, is maddening!!), they are none-the-less a commendable attempt to diversify the action. On the other hand, the vehicle sequences were always fun (if sometimes a bit long), and the race behind the Russian built train in Kazakhstan was a memorable one.

Now, as for the controls, they are exceptionally fluid-think Prince of Persia-, and make controlling Lara one of the most exhilarating experiences. Even though sometimes I cursed the complexity of them (in one boss, you have to shoot, then put your gun away, then throw the hook, then the pull-this is not particularly easy, and I was swore quite distinctly under my breath before I finally got a hang of it). While frustratingly, the camera on occasion has a mind of its own, I think you'll find this to be, at the worst of times, not much more than a nuisance (it does a great job the rest of the time). The grapple hook is reminiscent of Indy's whip, and adds an extra element that was much needed to make the puzzles interesting.

The weapons though, are a bit disappointing. Well not disappointing, because I was completely happy using Lara's trademark dual guns. They have unlimited ammo, and are so efficient that there is never really a need to use anything else. The grenades, I found, were particularly useless. (But to be honest, I *never* have any luck with grenades, ever.)

The plot and locations. Well, as I said above, this game is like a movie. Never a dull moment, and the plot motivates you to go along (you'll play the game as much to see what happens, than to shoot down bad guys). Supernatural is very efficiently mixed with real-life myths, ? la Indiana Jones and the Fate of Atlantis (in which the designers blended several versions of the myth of the Lost City to produce their own interpretation), to create a believable (well, at the very least, not so far-fetched as most) story.

You begin your journey in Bolivia. This is the tutorial level, that eases you into the game. Then you go to Peru. Peru is good old fashioned tomb-a real tomb, in which you do some digging to discover a friend you thought was dead, actually isn't either (isn't a friend, and isn't dead). You then discover elements that point you to a mafia boss in Japan. Japan in one of the most fun levels, I found, because how often to you get to swing (and occasionally motoride) through the skyscrapers of Tokyo?! (That, and Lara's outfit is pretty smooth!)

Then you go to Ghana in West Africa, in a tomb that is mostly a big giant puzzle (well, it's much more fun than that). The puzzles in this game, by the way, is not the old trademark "Push a bunch of cubes around until you feel like jumping out the window." The puzzles here are actually interesting, never illogical, and never impossible to figure out. In doubt, you can always use the R.A.D. mode of your binoculars to discern what you'll have to move, what you'll to shoot, etc. After Ghana, there's that Kazakhstan level that I *really* enjoyed (I'm a sucker for Soviet experiments awry) ... and then England (in an odd King Arthur museum), Nepal and Bolivia again for the final confrontation. The ending practically announces the next installment! (and yes, perhaps the game is a bit on the short side.)

I have to confess I've never been as much a Tomb Raider fan as I am now. This is one of the most enjoyable and gripping games I've played in the past two years, and I highly recommend to all action game fans (regardless of whether they've enjoyed the previous instalments).

[PS: the disk space requirements for this PC version are unheard of, but well worth it--I promise.]