Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
5 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
I just wish he'd gone into the castile soap business, January 1, 2008
Dr Bronner was able to take a good product and make it a great product by surrounding it with crank religious babble; Mr Sim took a great product and turned it into a mediocre one by interleaving it with such.
Traditionally, in Jewish sacred text study at least, the first, essential, step is to find a well-regarded teacher. This is because Torah uses ancient and often obscure language, with some uncertainty as to vowel points and proper punctuation. I don't know if the same obtains for the Quran (and sunna, and hadith), but I shouldn't be surprised if there weren't similar problems, and the same for the Christian books' Aramaic and koine Greek.
In all cases, knowledge of how people lived at the time also helps; in one case Mr Sim made an uncharacteristic turn toward a possible acceptance of lesbian sexuality based on a simple misunderstanding that up until recently, bed-sharing among the poor was nearly universal in all cold climates, orthogonal to sexual intent....
Auto-didacts are to be admired for their desire and their energy, but easily stray into idiosyncratic alleys, making their interpretations much more about the their inner selves than about the text or its application to people in general. Clouds without water, men who plough the roof.
That being said, the art was still good, especially Gerhard's, whose political and religious beliefs remain tom-me-blissfully unknown.
|
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Almost home!, December 10, 2008
If you've made it this far, why stop now? This is, to say the least, more than a little tedious. Sim has created a very unique commentary on the book of Genesis. He postulates that God and YHWH (the LORD in English translations) are two separate beings. YHWH, who Sim refers to as Yoowhoo, is a feminine being which more or less makes decisions that God always goes along with. I was about a third of the way through the book before I could really understand the line of reasoning (at least as much as I think it's understandable) and had to start the book over, now getting the idea. It's almost all text, really small text, that if you can get through it, it's at least as interesting (if not more refined) as the infamous Reads volume. As I say, if you've made it to vol. 15, make your way through it, it's worth it.
|
|
|
2 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
1.0 out of 5 stars
Warning a lot of this is text analyzing scripture, July 21, 2007
The majopr weakness of this volume is that a significant chunk of the last portion of it is dense text wit ha few illustrations on each page of Cerebus analysizing and interpreting the early books of the Torah. I actually don't mind religous comics in fact find them interesting but this isn't comics it's dense not very well written text- if you are interested in Cerebus and comics this books lacks a lot of the quality comics found in earlier volumes. If yo uare interested in Judeo Christian religous interpretations and analysis- my guess is yo uwould be better off with a realo text discussion of the issue than this non-graphic novel.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|