From Publishers Weekly
Stone offers a thorough if pedestrian account of the life of Ralph "Blackie" Schwamb, a promising pitcher from the 1940s with an unfortunate tendency for getting into trouble. After setting a backdrop of Los Angeles awash with glitz, gangsters and temptation, Stone (a journalist who, oddly, specializes in Asian economics and politics) follows Schwamb along his unfortunate ride from a troubled stint in the Navy to equally unsuccessful flirtations with organized crime and big-league baseball. The elements for a good story are here: the skilled yet brash Schwamb is a flawed antihero whose aggressive nature and frequent drunken binges ultimately combined to destroy his career and land him in San Quentin Prison for murder. But the narrative lacks inventiveness. Aside from providing historical context, Stone merely ticks off the events of Schwamb's life; this results in a leaden tour from hangover to hangover, punctuated by blown chances and missed opportunities. Readers will empathize with Schwamb when-more than halfway through the book-he shows his stuff for the prison team. This bright spot isn't early or effective enough, however, to establish a true connection with the subject. Fans and historians of the game may enjoy this account, but others will be left with an unsatisfying portrait of a potentially compelling character.
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Review
It's useful to remember that there's nothing terribly modern about the spectacle of an athlete throwing it all away. --
Sports Illustrated, March 21, 2005Stone interweaves interesting tidbits of popular culture and history (particularly that of Los Angeles). Recommended for public libraries. --
Library Journal, February 1, 2005Stone's riveting account of Schwamb's great baseball talent and equally great character defects is much more than a sports story. --
Tom Brokaw - NBC News Anchorman and Best Selling AuthorThis compelling biography reads as if it had been filmed in B&W in the golden age of film noir Hollywood. --
Kevin Starr - Historian and State Librarian Emeritus of CaliforniaThis is not a "sports" story. It is brilliant, chilling and real. --
Peter Gammons, ESPN Baseball Analyst