|
|
16 of 18 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Maybe I expected too much, November 22, 2001
I wrote a review of this album a few weeks back, when I first received as a freebie from American Gramaphone, and at the time I had awarded it 5 stars. Now, after several listenings, I'm afraid I'll have to knock off a star or two. Don't get me wrong, if you liked Mannheim's previous albums, you'll probably like this, but it definitely lacks something. It starts off with a typical, almost cliche Mannheim flourish, by taking Handel's beautiful and majestic Hallelujah chorus and devolving it into something that sounds closer to "Chariots of Fire." Good music if you're running track, I guess, but is it Christmas... I don't know. Still, you should enjoy the energy of this opening piece while it lasts, because the next five tracks are little more than lullabyes. I've always liked Chip Davis' softer pieces, and he does them well here, but he throws too many of them together. After several tracks, what should have sounded nostalgic just sounds depressingly dreary. "Faeries" (from The Nutcracker) almost seems as it wants to be this album's equivalent of "Little Drummer Boy," (from "A Fresh Aire Christmas"), but it never builds up enough, which is unfortunate since it could helped liven things up. "Fum Fum Fum" remains my favorite piece. It gives a much needed shot of energy to the album, and it relies on real Renaissance instruments, rather than Chip's tired MIDI instruments. If more of the album had sounded like this, I would have to give it five stars. Chip claims to have written this album in only a few months. If that were entirely true, it would be easier to forgive some of its shortcomings. But the arrangement of "Auld Lang Syne" which appears on this album is the same as what he had done on his Impressions album... he merely changed some of the synthesizer sounds and added a choir. Fortunately, it'll be new to most people since Impressions didn't sell particularly well, and it's a good arrangement-- but it still feels as though he cheated (especially since the big yellow sticker on the album cover proclaims, "ALL NEW MUSIC".) So should you buy it? Yes, if you already listened to their previous albums and enjoyed them. But if you've only just heard of Mannheim Steamroller and want to try one of their Christmas albums, you really should start with "A Fresh Aire Christmas," which is a truly great album, and then come back to this one later.
|