|
19 of 21 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A dark and fragmented recording... Goldsmith still has it, December 4, 2002
Opinions about the Nemesis score have been varied. I hope my review can help guide a potential buyer on whether they would like to add this soundtrack to their Star Trek collection.People who are not fans of Star Trek but ARE fans of Jerry Goldsmith will probably enjoy this CD greatly. Star Trek fans will no doubt need some time to get used to the EXTREMELY dark overtones of the music, much like we had to do with the Star Trek VI soundtrack by Cliff Eidelman. That soundtrack grew on me and became my favorite overall Original Series film score. One thing Star Trek fans will especially notice on this recording is a slight absence of recurring themes. We Trekkies are somewhat spoiled; we're used to gallant marching scores and sweeping themes that reflect our futuristic heroes. This film score takes a different approach. This music is lush, overlayed with eerie sythesizer sounds trying to create the dark and haunting feel the movie likely represents. The expected "recurring themes" are there in the score; but the themes are short, appearing in fragments here and there and maybe for twenty seconds, unfortunately with not much time to develop themselves. But we must keep in mind that Goldsmith is creating an accompaniment, not merely a stand-alone project. If the film itself is dark and fragmented, the film score is likely to mirror that. The themes in Nemesis are more percussive in nature than melodic, which might make some listeners miss them. The score tries more to create an atmosphere than a "single-worthy" orchestral theme. And on those grounds, Goldsmith succeeds without a doubt. As a treat to a careful listener, he also slips in homages to Trek scores past. In listening to the CD I heard echoes of a three-note measure pulled from Insurrection, the lush strings and solo horn style of First Contact, and the "Busy Man" theme from ST V, one of the most beautiful themes Goldsmith has ever composed. As the musical accompaniment to possibly the final Trek film, this soundtrack deserves a place in every Trek library. And any listener will find they can pull this CD off the shelf any into the stereo when they want something rhythmic, atmospheric and eerie all at the same time.
|