I'm sorry I have to post this in the Broadway forum, as it might not get much exposure in the opera forum. But I would like to get this concern about the Lloyd-Webber musicals off my chest.
I am confronted by people's misconceptions that they are real operas. Yes I know that Lloyd-Webber's music borrows from Puccini at times, and I know that Phantom has some operatic tendencies. I also know that the Lloyd-Webber shows are sung-through scores, but the hard truth is that sung-through pieces of music theatre doth not an opera make. The Lloyd-Webber musicals are most definitely not operas, even with the rock-opera tendencies of Superstar and Evita. His music is written in a more popular style than real opera.
I sense that my arguments might not have much grounding, but yet I'm aware that even classical performers have included the Lloyd-Webber show tunes in their repertory. I know that Kiri has sung some Lloyd-Webber, and so have the Three Tenors, most notably the songs from Phantom and Cats. I also do not deny that one of the singers associated with his music, Sarah Brightman, played a role in the genre of operatic pop. So while I do not deny the classical appearance of Lloyd-Webber's musicals, they are inherently not classical.
Recent discussions in the Broadway forum (68 discussions)
|old broadway playbills have a life?||142||6 days ago|
|in your dreams - what should be revived and who would you cast in it?||43||Jan 6, 2015|
|What's your favorite memory of a Broadway show?||395||Oct 10, 2013|
|Dream Les Miserables Cast||7||Sep 12, 2013|
|Most disappointing show||87||Aug 20, 2013|
|tony disappointments||2||Jul 23, 2013|
|Favorite flop musical||174||Sep 3, 2012|
|Obscure Broadway singers and songs||220||Jul 4, 2012|
|The issues involved in revivals of musicals||5||Jul 2, 2012|
|Spider-Man on Broadway: should we bother seeing it if our seats aren't close to the stage or in the flying circle?||0||May 17, 2012|
|Fairly new fan of Broadway - what are five DVDs and five cast alblums I should experience?||126||May 9, 2012|
|What's you're the most over-top-top idea you've got (or heard about) for a musical? (Real, heard from another source, or your own warped idea?)||19||Apr 20, 2012|