The "classic" arguments against Our Lady's sinlessness:
1) Romans 3:23 -- Paul quotes a hyperbolic OT verse written before either Mary or Jesus were conceived. This verse may apply to us, but it doesn't apply to Mary any more than it applies to Jesus.
2) Infinite Regress of Sinless Grannies -- For Mary to be sinless, her mother, St. Anne, had to be sinless, as did Mary's maternal grandmother, great-grandmother, great-great-grandmother, and so on, to the beginning of the human race. This "argument" insults God's power over sin, and is patently silly as well.
3) "It's not in the Bible" -- Thanks to Scripture's endorsements of Apostolic Tradition (2 Thessalonians 2:15) and the Church (1 Timothy 3:15), it doesn't have to be in Scripture. OTOH, God's holiness, a sinners' inability to withstand God's glory in fullness, and OT Marian typology, all of which ARE in Scripture, point to it.
4) "Only Catholics believe it." -- That's an argument? Yes, it is. It's an _ad hominem_ argument, and therefore fallacious.
5) "Catholics didn't believe it until 1854." -- Not true. Most did, even before it was elevated to a dogma in 1854.
6) "Mary needed a savior, and only sinners need a savior" (Luke 1:47) -- a howling non-sequitur; God saved Mary from sin by keeping sin from entering her when she was conceived. Mary then continued, eventually saying, "(F)or he who is mighty has done great things for me, and holy is his name" (Luke 1:49).
7) Luke 2:22-24: Mary and Joseph offered two turtledoves because a woman who'd had a baby was RITUALLY UNCLEAN. Having a baby is NOT a sin (aborting one, though, is). I should also note that this sacrifice is one of the "works of the law" which Paul rightly pointed out justifies no one (not one of the "works of mercy" which James was talking about when he said "Faith without works is dead").
8) The Church Fathers weren't in unanimity on the matter, or didn't think so: Oh, puh-LEEZ give me a break!
9) "If Mary had been sinless, she could have been sacrificed instead of Christ." -- again, ignorance of OT typology. The Passover Lamb, which prefigures Christ, had to be male (XY chromosome, etc.).
10) "(I)f you knew how a female body nourishes a baby, you'd know that no blood is mingled." -- Sin enters the child at the moment of conception (Ps 51:5), inside the mother's womb. "No intermingling of blood" doesn't matter. God wouldn't want to be inside a sinner anymore than the _shekinah_ would remain inside a defiled temple (as if a placenta would stop sin, anyway).
Let's see what they throw at us in this round.
Recent discussions in the Christianity forum
AnnouncementAmazon Discussions Feedback Forum
|1197||9 days ago|
|This is why atheism is growing throughout the world...||88||14 minutes ago|
|Jesus' wife?-nope it's a forgery||362||37 minutes ago|
|Mary was not sinless.||6458||40 minutes ago|
|Tim Kaine, a Catholic who believes in good works is VP pick on the Hillary Democratic ticket!||128||1 hour ago|
|If a man dies will he live again? Or, is physical death the end?||700||1 hour ago|
|Christianity described as a 'profitable fable' by an early pope.||90||2 hours ago|
|My Mob's pub and coffee shop, Part the Twelfth||251||2 hours ago|
|World leaders alone - and not Religions - can call to God for the end of this era||18||2 hours ago|
|The Church of JESUS CHRIST of Latter-day Saints is Christian.||7538||3 hours ago|
|Interesting Comments by Posters||210||3 hours ago|
|Jesus of History vs. Christ of Faith||503||4 hours ago|