Customer Discussions > Classic Rock forum

Best Genesis Song Game 70-75 The Gabriel Years


Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 101-125 of 349 posts in this discussion
Posted on Nov 14, 2012 8:04:40 AM PST
Music Lover says:
here's the removal list so far:

52. Ravine
51. Anyway
50. The Waiting Room
49. Looking For Someone
48. The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging
47. After The Ordeal
46. Harold The Barrel
45. Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist
44. It
43. For Absent Friends
42.(tie)Harlequin
42.(tie)In The Rapids
40. Dusk
39. White Mountain
38. Riding The Scree
37. Aisle Of Plenty
36. Time Table
35. Broadway Melody of 1974
34. Happy The Man

Posted on Nov 14, 2012 12:20:36 PM PST
After Music Lover

Visions Of Angels-3
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
Seven Stones-3
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-9
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-6
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-10
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
More Fool Me -2
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-9
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-7
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-4
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-5

The Musical Box +
Seven Stones -
Hairless Heart -

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 14, 2012 12:28:25 PM PST
Lauren says:
After Curry:

Visions Of Angels-3
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
Seven Stones-3
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-9
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-10
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
More Fool Me -1
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-9
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-7
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-4
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

Can-Utility +
More Fool Me -
The Light Dies Down -

Posted on Nov 14, 2012 2:38:52 PM PST
Music Lover says:
If any of you are King Crimson fans I just started a game

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 14, 2012 5:45:49 PM PST
Captain Ogre says:
After Lauren,

Visions Of Angels-2
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
Seven Stones-2
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-9
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
More Fool Me -1
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-9
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-7
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-4
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

+ Moonlit Knight
- Visions & Stones

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 14, 2012 5:48:15 PM PST
Captain Ogre says:
I'm really not getting how More Fool Me is nearly done here

Is it just me?

Posted on Nov 14, 2012 7:26:25 PM PST
@Captain Ogre

There's just too few bad songs to vote off before it.

Aside from a few of the filler tracks on The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway, there are very few early Genesis songs I dislike. My least favorites are so-so at worse.

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 15, 2012 4:33:11 AM PST
After Ogre

Visions Of Angels-2
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
Seven Stones-2
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
More Fool Me -1
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-9
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-7
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-3
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

Watcher Of The Sky +
Hairless Heart -

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 5:38:24 AM PST
After Ogre

Visions Of Angels-2
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
Seven Stones-1
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
More Fool Me -1
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-9
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-2
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

In The Cage +
Hairless Heart -
Seven Stones -

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 6:21:50 AM PST
patc71s says:
After the third curry
Visions Of Angels-2
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-2
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-4
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

+The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway
-More Fool Me -eliminated
-Seven Stones -eliminated

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 7:47:04 AM PST
Music Lover says:
after patc71s:

Visions Of Angels-1
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-5
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Hairless Heart-1
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-7
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

Chamber of 32+
Hairless, Visions-

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 7:48:24 AM PST
Music Lover says:
here's the removal list so far:

52. Ravine
51. Anyway
50. The Waiting Room
49. Looking For Someone
48. The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging
47. After The Ordeal
46. Harold The Barrel
45. Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist
44. It
43. For Absent Friends
42.(tie)Harlequin
42.(tie)In The Rapids
40. Dusk
39. White Mountain
38. Riding The Scree
37. Aisle Of Plenty
36. Time Table
35. Broadway Melody of 1974
34. Happy The Man
33.(tie) Seven Stones
33.(tie)More Fool Me

I,too, am sad to see More Fool Me go so early but it's my own fault, i should have tried to throw it a vote or two

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 9:13:51 AM PST
after Music Lover:

Visions Of Angels-1
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-4
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

The Carpet Crawlers +
Hairless Heart- gone
Fly on a Windshield -

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 9:57:11 AM PST
Music Lover says:
here's the removal list so far:

52. Ravine
51. Anyway
50. The Waiting Room
49. Looking For Someone
48. The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging
47. After The Ordeal
46. Harold The Barrel
45. Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist
44. It
43. For Absent Friends
42.(tie)Harlequin
42.(tie)In The Rapids
40. Dusk
39. White Mountain
38. Riding The Scree
37. Aisle Of Plenty
36. Time Table
35. Broadway Melody of 1974
34. Happy The Man
33.(tie) Seven Stones
33.(tie)More Fool Me
31. Hairless Heart

Album Breakdown of the top 30 left:

Trespass-3 left,3 removed
Nursery Cryme-3 left,4 removed
Foxtrot-5 left,1 removed
Selling England-5 left,3 removed
The Lamb-13 left, 9 removed

Twilight Alehouse is still surviving too as a bonus track

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 15, 2012 10:16:57 AM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 15, 2012 10:17:23 AM PST
Lauren says:
After Animal:

Visions Of Angels-1
Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-6
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-4
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-4

Supper's Ready +
Twilight Alehouse -
Fly on a Windshield -

For me, this game is really driving home the point that The Lamb is greater than the sum of its parts. The Rock and Roll Gestalt, one of my old friends used to call it...

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 15, 2012 5:48:22 PM PST
Captain Ogre says:
After Lauren,

Stagnation-5
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-5
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-4
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-3

+ Epping Forest
- Visions (and gone)
- The Light Lies Down

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 11:45:42 PM PST
Music Lover says:
after Capt.O:

Stagnation-4
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-9
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-4
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-5
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-2

Hogweed+
Twilight,The Light Dies-

Posted on Nov 15, 2012 11:46:48 PM PST
Music Lover says:
here's the removal list so far:

52. Ravine
51. Anyway
50. The Waiting Room
49. Looking For Someone
48. The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging
47. After The Ordeal
46. Harold The Barrel
45. Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist
44. It
43. For Absent Friends
42.(tie)Harlequin
42.(tie)In The Rapids
40. Dusk
39. White Mountain
38. Riding The Scree
37. Aisle Of Plenty
36. Time Table
35. Broadway Melody of 1974
34. Happy The Man
33.(tie) Seven Stones
33.(tie)More Fool Me
31. Hairless Heart
30. Visions Of Angels

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 16, 2012 4:49:28 AM PST
After Music Lover

Stagnation-3
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-4
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-8
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-4
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-2

Firth Of Fifth +
The Colony, Stagnation -

Posted on Nov 16, 2012 5:10:11 AM PST
After Daniel E. White

Stagnation-3
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-5
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-7
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-11
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-3
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-9
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-4
The Light Dies Down On Broadway-1

In the Cage +
The Light Dies Down On Broadway -
Fly On A Windshield -

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 16, 2012 5:59:34 AM PST
Last edited by the author on Nov 16, 2012 6:00:00 AM PST
Lauren says:
After Curry:

It looks like I voted yesterday (Supper's Ready+; Twilight Alehouse-; Fly on a Windshield-) but didn't adjust totals. Also, Music Lover negged Twilight but didn't subtract a point from this. I'm adding all these votes back in below, but if this doesn't look right please readjust.

Stagnation-3
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-2
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-8
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-12
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-6
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-2
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-9
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-4

Can-Utility +
The Light Dies Down - (and goes out)
Twilight Alehouse -

Posted on Nov 16, 2012 6:34:04 AM PST
patc71s says:
after Lauren

Stagnation-3
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Twilight Alehouse-1
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-8
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-12
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-7
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-1
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-9
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-4

+I Know What I Like
-Fly on a Windshield
-Twilight Alehouse

Posted on Nov 17, 2012 8:20:15 AM PST
Music Lover says:
good catch,Lauren.thanks

after patc71s:

Stagnation-2
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-6
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-8
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-13
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-7
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Fly On A Windshield-1
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-9
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-6
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slipperman-4

Supper's Ready+
stagnation- and Twilight removed

Posted on Nov 17, 2012 8:21:27 AM PST
Music Lover says:
here's the removal list so far:

52. Ravine
51. Anyway
50. The Waiting Room
49. Looking For Someone
48. The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging
47. After The Ordeal
46. Harold The Barrel
45. Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist
44. It
43. For Absent Friends
42.(tie)Harlequin
42.(tie)In The Rapids
40. Dusk
39. White Mountain
38. Riding The Scree
37. Aisle Of Plenty
36. Time Table
35. Broadway Melody of 1974
34. Happy The Man
33.(tie) Seven Stones
33.(tie)More Fool Me
31. Hairless Heart
30. Visions Of Angels
29. The Light Dies Down On Broadway
28. Twilight Alehouse

In reply to an earlier post on Nov 17, 2012 8:42:24 AM PST
Lauren says:
After Music Lover:

Stagnation-2
The Knife-13
The Musical Box-12
The Return Of the Giant Hogweed-6
The Fountain Of Salmacis-6
Watcher Of The Skies-10
Get 'Em Out By Friday-5
Can-Utility & The Coastliners-8
Horizons-6
Supper's Ready-13
Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-11
I Know What I Like-7
Firth Of Fifth-10
The Battle Of Epping Forest-7
Cinema Show-10
The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway-10
Cuckoo Cocoon-6
In The Cage-9
Back In NYC-7
Counting Out Time-7
The Carpet Crawlers-8
The Chamber Of 32 Doors-5
Lilywhite Lilith-7
The Lamia-6
Silent Sorrows In Empty Boats-6
The Colony Of Slippermen-4

Counting Out Time +
Fly On A Windshield - (splat)
Get 'Em Out By Friday -
[Add comment]
Add your own message to the discussion
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Prompts for sign-in
 


 

This discussion

Discussion in:  Classic Rock forum
Participants:  9
Total posts:  349
Initial post:  Nov 1, 2012
Latest post:  Dec 26, 2012

New! Receive e-mail when new posts are made.

Search Customer Discussions