Theology in Fantasy---Opinions requested. Please read through
Dec. 13th, 2012 at 10:21 AM
Opinions requested. Please read through. Apparently I managed to offend someone by stating that the Christian God did not truly exist. Yeah I know--thems fightin' words. But it's fantasy people. In all honesty I've heaved a book or two across the room because midway through they tried to cram the one god idea down the reader's throat.But this was one line in eight books and it fit the rest of the world(s) theology which this person then proceeded to remember completely incorrectly since apparently I made her see red.
IN eight books --thus far-- I've managed to run through multiple pantheons of gods in what boils down to-- none of them were really gods they were just magically gifted and long-lived people from a world where they were common and eventually that world placed wardens(Hard-case loner type elves) to prevent magical imbalances from people playing god to short-lived largely unmagical humans, so by the time the christian god rolled around nobody was getting away with that kind of role-playing anymore. But humans needed something to believe in so they built their mythology and they wrote their bibles and they created rituals which in the long run had a magic all its own, created miracles, and leant strength to the mythology. But according to this review I claimed all the old gods were real(I guess they were-- of course I also mention they're about twenty Odins off from the original) and the christian god wasn't.(the author of this review did not however seem to have a problem with the idea that hell is nothing more than a demesne filled with demons locked in their homelands by the ruling council--they never get out unless someone is stupid enough to summon them --Or the king of the fairies works a deal with them) Never intended to offend anybody because ...well...it's fiction. Better yet Fantasy fiction.And theology is really just a backdrop( a scarcely mentioned backdrop) for my worlds-- not a hard and fast statement of anybody's real beliefs.
OK having gone through all that there is a point. If you were presented with the line above in the context stated, would it offend you? Should I be concerned that this may be a common reaction?
Maybe I should hope some holy rollers will try to ban my books, a little controversy can be a good thing sometimes but that really wasn't what I was going for. These are meant to be fun light tales easy to read without a lot of thought in them and maybe a little too much sex. I would have thought I'd offend more people with the sex than the religion(or lack thereof) but thus far even the one review I got that seemed to think maybe I could do with fewer sex scenes still rated it five stars, which I figured meant I must be doing something right. :)
Recent discussions in the Fantasy forum
AnnouncementRead fresh new fantasy stories - and help take them to the next level
|5||Jul 18, 2015|
|It's June 2016. What fantasy books are you reading?||57||5 hours ago|
|KTT-A (imagine all the curly decorations, please) :-D||4653||5 hours ago|
|Books on Sale||1426||1 day ago|
|Which is your 'least' favorite Harry Potter book?||16||2 days ago|
|What is your opinion on fantasy and magic with galactic adventures for a debut book series?||2||4 days ago|
|Lois McMaster Bujold, C.J. Cherryh, Robin Hobb||96||5 days ago|
|Clean Adult Fantasy Books||283||5 days ago|
|2016 Reading Challenge||37||6 days ago|
|Book Challenge: Best Books of the Year||16||8 days ago|
|Book Recs for urban/high/epic fantasy?||21||16 days ago|
|Kindle Unlimited: Fantasy Recommendations||91||20 days ago|