I have been absent from this forum for years, but about 4 or 5 years ago I presented this same topic for public discussion here, and it resulted in a very lively and satisfying discussion. So, I thought perhaps enough time has passed that presenting this topic for discussion again would not be amiss.
So here goes:
We're discussing Counterfactual History. This is a scholarly exercise that goes at least all the way back to ancient Rome. To contribute an idea, please do the following:
1. present us with a specific historic event
2. propose a realistic and probable alternate event
3. if you wish, provide a brief analysis of how the alternate event would have changed history
This is meant to be a fun discussion, so please no name calling, no disrespectful jabs, and be polite. The inserted link is just ONE of many books written on this subject.
The Collected What If? Eminent Historians Imagine What Might Have Been
Later edit: For anyone new to this thread, do not feel obligated to read all of the posts before contributing. If something you bring to the discussion has already been touched upon, nobody will hold it against you, and if you want to propose a new idea, please feel free to jump in and do so. This thread is HEAVILY MODERATED by me to try to keep the discussion friendly and relaxed, so feel free to contribute.
Recent discussions in the History forum
AnnouncementAmazon Discussions Feedback Forum
|430||Mar 23, 2015|
|Who killed JFK on November 22nd, 1963? What are some of your answers and beliefs? VOLUME II||3332||8 minutes ago|
|GWB used secret e-mail serves to comunicate with is staff about the Gulf War, and he recieved $100 million for his Presidential Library from Haliburton||0||17 minutes ago|
|History of the Palestinian Nation (Part IV)||1220||29 minutes ago|
|Kennedy Assassination II||7343||55 minutes ago|
|May 23-24: Centennial of Italy's entry in WWI||0||1 hour ago|
|New Biography Of The Kaiser||39||1 hour ago|
|Could Germany Won WWII If It Wouldn't Have Had Japan and Italy as "Allies"?||81||2 hours ago|
|Putin in the Ukraine, sanctions, more Russian military intrusions, what's next?||802||2 hours ago|
|Fighter aces head to head match up.||68||3 hours ago|
|Was Groening guilty?||458||3 hours ago|
|Rome in Palmyra||0||5 hours ago|