I perused the two recent horror short story threads and got some ideas, but didn't know where many of the stories were readily available and the list just got out of hand.
I typically just go one song per artist, so here's what I have so far:
Graham Masterton: either "Eric the Pie" free pdf at http://www.grahammasterton.co.uk/pdf/eric
Richard Laymon: "Mess Hall" from Book of the Dead
Clive Barker: "In the Hills, the Cities" found here Clive Barker's Books of Blood 1-3
David Morrell: "Orange for Anguish, Blue for Insanity" from Black Evening: Tales of Dark Suspense
Ramsey Campbell: "The Entertainment", easily the best tale from 999 I've across so far.
I would surely have a Stephen King tale in there, but which one??
Matheson would have one in there, but what to choose??
Going old school: Lovecraft? Poe? Blackwood?
So if you would be kind enough to offer up a truly frightening, absolutely fat-free horror short chiller or two and where to get it, we could probably come up with something that would rival the best of all horror anthologies.