Debate, whether on campaign trails, in apologetics, in online discussion forums, at dinner parties, or in general, is less about persuading others that our views are right, says one analyst on the Argumentation Theory. He said debate surprisingly often leads to "epistemic distortions and poor decisions".
"Skilled arguers, however, are not after the truth but after arguments supporting their views."
His theory is that we argue simply to hone the skill of arguing.
Another article describes how debate tactics usually focus more on decreasing the validity of the opposing point than proving the validity of our own points. (The lesser of the two evils case.) Campaign ads use mudslinging, because it is successful.
Although we learn new things in debate, rarely do we change positions. In fact, the first article I mentioned stated that we actually cement our positions with confirmation bias.
Why are you here? Have you fulfilled your mission?
Recent discussions in the Religion forum
AnnouncementAmazon Discussions Feedback Forum
|1527||12 days ago|
|Quotes by famous scientists (except for Dawkins) about God, with interpretations||35||6 minutes ago|
|Amy Hall claims: There is no Jesus, no thorny crown, and he was a mere man, just like you. There is no deity.||2969||9 minutes ago|
|Life||312||1 hour ago|
|Why did those who are now Christians leave atheism?||407||1 hour ago|
|Why did those who are now atheists leave Christianity?||1178||1 hour ago|
|Zen & Meditation||41||2 hours ago|
|Time for Christians to stop crying persecution.||581||3 hours ago|
|Define "God"||5278||4 hours ago|
|Today in Muslim History||6440||7 hours ago|
|A thread about theology. Not a thread about whether or not God exists.||1266||7 hours ago|
|keep one change one started 10 October 2014||5733||8 hours ago|