My reference to the "Monolith" was in fact referring to the movie "2001: A Space Odessey" which, in turn was based on the Clarke novel. No novel - hence no monolith. Backward logic, indeed, but I had to think of something!
I see no problem with calling Marilyn on her facts, and even some good-natured sarcasm and ribbing, but in some posts, I have seen what amounts to intellectual invisceration. I guess what I'm saying is I've got not problem calling someone "silly" or "outrageous" or even "ridiculous". I do object when it gets personal, and instead of IDEAS being "silly", the POSTER now becomes "stupid", "idiotic", or a "moron". The topic turns from fun and interesting to painful and embarrassing.
As this IS the "Science Fiction" Forum, I don't see why any "flights of fancy" can't be discussed. Would you also object to discussions of the "possibility" of hobbits, elves, and fairies on the "Fantasy" Forum?
Now, if the poster with the outlandish ideas is NOT willing to admit the info they have posted is unproven, or even questionable (as are ANY unsubstatiated "facts"), then the gloves can come off . . .
Recent discussions in the Science Fiction forum
AnnouncementRead fresh new science fiction stories - and help take them to the next level
|8||4 days ago|
AnnouncementImportant announcement from Amazon
|190||Jul 2, 2014|
AnnouncementNew Star Wars Release: The Jedi Path now available. Read the author's insider notes...
|29||Sep 24, 2014|
|How about LitRPG (MMO-based virtual reality books)?||65||2 hours ago|
|It's August 2015. What sci-fi book are you reading?||4||1 day ago|
|Too many female authors flooding sci fi , fantasy books||271||1 day ago|
|Looking for Recommendations - Dystopian reading||36||1 day ago|
|Stories that are kindof-sortof about evolution / ecology||23||1 day ago|
|Books having to do with Robots and what it is to be human?||24||1 day ago|
|Your Favorite Science-Fiction books and films of the year?||46||3 days ago|
|It's July 2015. What sci-fi book are you reading?||12||3 days ago|
|Need some recommendations on Military sci fi books||123||3 days ago|