Profile for J. Cox > Reviews

Browse

J. Cox's Profile

Customer Reviews: 2
Top Reviewer Ranking: 21,659,692
Helpful Votes: 1




Community Features
Review Discussion Boards
Top Reviewers

Guidelines: Learn more about the ins and outs of Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
J. Cox "bibliophile" RSS Feed (Massachusetts)
(REAL NAME)   

Show:  
Page: 1
pixel
Revolutionary underground: The story of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, 1858-1924
Revolutionary underground: The story of the Irish Republican Brotherhood, 1858-1924
by Leon O'Broin
Edition: Hardcover
15 used & new from $74.95

4.0 out of 5 stars An important gap in Irish history filled., October 22, 2012
Leon O Broin's sadly hard to find book, Revolutionary Underground deals with the Irish nationalist tradition during the years between the Great Hunger and the victory of the Free State faction during the Irish Civil War. It supposes a good deal of already existing knowledge on the part of the reader, and neophytes may wish to read it in conjunction with a more lighter and general introduction to Irish history and culture such as Ballantine Books' "Everything Irish". O'Broin's volume is a brief and exciting read, with some serious original research behind it.

The basic thesis is that Charles Stuart Parnell's land reform movement planted the seeds which would bear fruit years later in the 1916 Easter rebellion, despite Parnell's eventual disgrace and many decades of frustration. Parnell, despite his Protestant ism and commitment to non-violence, nurtured secret connections to the Fenian movement mediated by sympathetic Roman Catholic clergyman. After the great reformer was swept out of power by scandal, these individuals labored in secret to transmit the ideal of a free Ireland to the next generation, ultimately serving as incubators to the consciousness of such men as James Connolly, Arthur Griffith, and Michael Collins. William Butler Yeats is mentioned in the interim but his involvement comes across as dilettantish.

Leon O Brion was a fine and brave man. He participated in the aftermath of these events, as a soldier for the ultimately victorious Free State. He wrote books in English and Gaelic both. During World War II attempted to build bridges between Irish Catholics and Jews. It is a pity that he did not offer any opinions here as to the contemporary nationalist movement. The Troubles were just heating up when this volume was published. Also a pity that is apparently out of print and expensive. You might find it at a good size library.


OSS in World War II
OSS in World War II
by Edward Hymoff
Edition: Hardcover
25 used & new from $6.97

1 of 1 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Very fascinating personal history., May 15, 2011
This review is from: OSS in World War II (Hardcover)
Edward Hymoff's book should be of great interest to anyone curious about the history of the intelligence community. He was known primarily as a TV executive, but during the war he did espionage. This volume is as revealing an insider's view of the Office of Strategic Services as any I know of and also quite entertaining.

The OSS, apparently, was a hastily constructed affair, getting started entirely too late to enter the war with any foresight. Its agents had to essentially learn the trade while they were on the battlefield. The OSS's successor the CIA is known for hiring disciplined professionals. The OSS, on the other hand often recruited malcontents, adventurers, and eccentrics. This leads to some darkly humorous anecdotes.

Hymoff is frank about the Agency's early involvement with the Sicilian Cosa Nostra, and its American offshoot. They managed to successfully construct a fifth column to cooperate with Allied troops when the invasion of Mussolini's Italy finally began, though this required the US government to release and then coddle Lucky Luciano. A less successful mission involved attempts to infiltrate Tiso's Slovakia using Slovakian born Americans (including Catholic priests) as agents. Ultimately they succeeded in stirring up the Slovak National Uprising, but the cost in human life, Hymoff demonstrates was far greater then what was accomplished.

This is one of those real life stories that manage to trump novels and films in sheer incredibly. The parts about the exploits of American and American supported guerillas in Greece, and the use of seductive "honey-traps" to get information from exiles in technically neutral Istanbul read like something out of Rambo or James Bond respectively, but Hymoff provides endnotes and a bibliography to prove that it is all very real. Another fascinating tidbit: the prime opposition to the establishment of an overseas intelligence agency came from the FBI, which didn't want its own status as America's "eyes and ears" challenged. The FBI continued to have jurisdiction over Latin America throughout the entire war.

Hymoff doesn't say whether he remained in the game as the OSS was dismantled and its key players absorbed into the newly formed CIA. His own pragmatic opposition to the Vietnam War is interesting in light of the passages of this book that emphasize OSS support for Ho Chi Minh against the Japanese. For those interested in unraveling the riddles of the twentieth century's answer to the "Great Game" this volume will elucidate.
Comment Comment (1) | Permalink | Most recent comment: Jul 18, 2011 5:02 PM PDT


Page: 1