Profile for James R. Taylor > Reviews

Browse

James R. Taylor's Profile

Customer Reviews: 3
Top Reviewer Ranking: 845,887
Helpful Votes: 477




Community Features
Review Discussion Boards
Top Reviewers

Guidelines: Learn more about the ins and outs of Your Profile.

Reviews Written by
James R. Taylor RSS Feed
(REAL NAME)   

Show:  
Page: 1
pixel
Start! Walking with Leslie Sansone 1 & 2 Mile Walk
Start! Walking with Leslie Sansone 1 & 2 Mile Walk
DVD
Price: $1.99

2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Walking with Leslie Sansone rocks!, December 22, 2013
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
I gave this video by Leslie 5 stars because the video is as promised. It is a fairly easy, but still very energetic short "walking" session. Leslie is upbeat, but restrained, not like some of the trainers who shout and keep up a silly patter of encouragement.

She is very encouraging without being obnoxious, another plus to using this video.

I am in my 70's and my husband is 80, and we are using this DVD to replace some of our mall walking as the Walk at Home program seems much healthier, more energy expending and aerobic. JR Taylor


Carmex Cherry Flavor Moisturizing Lip Balm Tube SPF 15 (Quantity of 9)
Carmex Cherry Flavor Moisturizing Lip Balm Tube SPF 15 (Quantity of 9)
Offered by Corner Drugstore
Price: $11.96
4 used & new from $11.96

5.0 out of 5 stars Carmex Lip Balm is the best buy!, December 23, 2012
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
Carmex Cheery Lip Balm and the plain are excellent. They keep the lips very moist and work better than more expensive products as well as products in their price range.

They are the best for the money. I discovered this product from looking on the web and I was not disappointed.


Free Will
Free Will
by Sam Harris
Edition: Paperback
Price: $7.52
105 used & new from $3.50

475 of 631 people found the following review helpful
1.0 out of 5 stars Sam Harris Misses the Mark in Free Will, March 9, 2012
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Free Will (Paperback)
Sam Harris Free Will

Sam Harris is a master of the polemic. He has written very eloquently and convincingly concerning atheism in his books, The End of Faith and Letter to a Christian Nation. Full disclosure: My wife, Mary C. Taylor, and I are atheists and she has a website and video lectures on atheism, as well as being assistant organizer and lecturer of an atheist Meetup. She has contributed signifantly to this essay. Mr. Harris is an important force for secularism in the United States.
But his latest offering, Free Will, a scant 66 page essay in book format (with some 7 pages of notes,) is lacking in many essential ways, particularly in the matter of evidence for his claims. Harris states there is no free will, that it is an illusion, but offers no proof for his assertion. In fact, on Pages 13, 38, 39, and 40, he states that the sources of our intentions, desires, actions, and wants are unknown, a mystery, inscrutable or obscure. He seems to be asserting that because we do not know the sources for our thoughts and actions, it necessarily follows that we do not have free will. Such a flimsy connection is not proof. He cites some well known experiments, such as the Libet, all of which are inconclusive, and does not provide the reader with strong scientific evidence to back up his assertions.
Mr. Harris critiques compatibilism by too often, for such a short essay, emphasizing the differences between himself and Daniel Dennett, the philosopher who has written Elbow Room and Freedom Evolves. In fact, Dennett makes a very cogent case for the compatibilism and coexistence of determinism and free will in human beings. One of Mr. Harris's breezy dismissals of compatibilism on Page 16 is that the "free will compatibilists defend is not the free will most people feel they have." Such a statement seems to imply that Mr. Harris sets aside the fine and scholarly work of many philosophers such as Dennett, because it does not accord with some popular misconception of free will. Populism would appear to trump scholarship in this book.
On Pages 10 and 24, Harris apparently infers that if we had exceptional machines and brain scanners to monitor our action sequences and choices, we would be astounded to discover that we were not in control of them. However, we do not yet have experiments that might be conclusive. To state that one knows the outcome of future experiments is nonsense. In fact, neuroscience is at the beginning of a long voyage of discovery about the brain, the mind and consciousness.
Another difficulty with "Free Will" is the author's shift to prescription rather than description. Such a segue is yet another example of the philosopher David Hume's famous and much discussed Is/Ought problem concerning Ethics. Harris suddenly advocates what the justice system should do. On Page 54, he writes: "Our system of justice should reflect an understanding that any of us could have been dealt a different hand in life. In fact, it seems immoral not to recognize just how much luck is involved with morality itself." Why should any of us assume, given Mr. Harris's assertion that choices are not in our control, that most citizens will agree about changes to our justice system? Many people, if not in conscious control of their belief and ethical systems, may reach opposite conclusions. Mr. Harris is not the only champion of determinism who seems to dismiss reason as a motivating factor, and then to advocate change based on conscious reasoning.
My opinion, after reading this small book, is that Sam Harris has done very little to advance understanding or forward the argument in the contentious and knotty issue of free will and determinism. With all due respect, I regretfully cannot recommend his Free Will to readers. Daniel Dennett's Elbow Room and Freedom Evolves are excellent starting places for a discussion of the argument. The problem of free will vis-à-vis determinism reaches back to Ancient Greece and Israel, and is not quickly or easily perused. Galen Strawson, Saul Smilansky, Peter Strawson, Manuel Vargas, Robert Kane and Daniel Wegner are excellent sources. Robert Kane has edited the Oxford Handbook of Free Will, with superb essays on both sides of the divide. Professor Shaun Nichols, from the University of Arizona, offers an excellent DVD course from the Teaching Company on Free Will and Determinism that is very balanced, thorough and essential for the appraisal and understanding of the multitudinous opinions and experiments concerning free will and determinism.
Comment Comments (92) | Permalink | Most recent comment: May 18, 2015 9:54 AM PDT


Page: 1