Who took my panties, I have to agree!! ha ha!! I don't even know why I don't like it so much, maybe it is just so repetitive or something. I DO like most of them....even the odd ones (like I'm Gonna Lasso Santa Claus). Also, Mel Torme's version of Good King Wenceslas is awesome.
I'm not thrilled with any holiday songs; could go the entire holiday season without hearing a one. My absolute worst: 'The 12 Days of Guido Christmas', my favorite: 'Grandma Got Run Over By A Reindeer'.
Really, I start to hate them all by the time Christmas rolls around. Not that they are bad, or anything. It's just that I've got a coworker who plays Christmas music on his computer starting before Halloween, and keeps playing it loudly, all day, every day, until well past New Years. It's just a constant cycle of the same songs, over and over and over and over again. I'm not a violent person, but the thought of murder has crossed my mind.
I gave up on 'traditional' holiday songs about 5 years ago. After so many years of those I couldn't listen one more time. I found TranSiberian Orchestra's 3 or 4 Christmas ~what shall I call them~operettas? I love them and play them every year.