This is a brief but brilliant book on Abraham Lincoln, which tries to show Lincoln as a product and developer of Enlightenment Liberalism. I've read many books on Lincoln, but most try to situate Lincoln in his historical and political context and not as a figure in the history of ideas.
Not that Guelzo doesn't also explain Lincoln's historical context as well. I understand now better than before how Lincoln stood apart from many of his immediate political predecessors, in particular Andrew Jackson, of whom Lincoln was the antithesis. In contemporary political terms, Jackson, despite being one of the key figures in the history of the Democratic party, was a passionate believer in small government. Lincoln, one of the founders of the Republican party, was an impassioned believer in the power of government and invested much of his political career in having government involved in large federal and state project. In today's terms, Jackson, the Democrat, was a believer is small government, while Lincoln, the Republican, was a believer in big government (Guelzo doesn't mention it, but it was under Lincoln that the largest federal program in American history to that point was undertaken, the building of the transcontinental railroad, undertaken by private companies funded by public capital). I've little doubt that today the two would switch parties (for the record, one of Lincoln's most prominent biographers, Doris Kearns Goodwin, also has stated her belief that today Lincoln would be a Democrat, since the GOP is today opposed to virtually all of the political issues that Lincoln held dear).
The book is largely organized around clusters of ideas that were crucial for the intellectual development of Lincoln as a political thinker. the Lincoln that emerges is Lincoln the philosopher of politics. And there are some very good results her from considering Lincoln more from an intellectual rather than a biographical point of view. Many personal details are omitted that are commonplaces in most books on Lincoln. For instance, little is said of Mary Todd Lincoln's struggles with sanity, or Lincoln's love for his sons and his relations with them, or his own struggles with sanity, or the possibilities of a homosexual relationship prior to his marriage (something I have always found to be extremely dubious), or -- what was central to Doris Kearns Goodwin's splendid recent book on Lincoln -- his contentious relation with his cabinet. Instead, Guelzo strives to make vivid the intellectual context for the major decisions that Lincoln made. In this he is absolutely brilliant and as a result I recommend this slender little book as much as many other larger and wordier volumes. I especially was intrigued by the passages in which Guelzo talks of Lincoln's growing religious beliefs. As is well known, Lincoln was not a Christian. He never attended or belonged to a church and could generally be considered uninterested in religious ideas. But as Guelzo shows, during the Civil War Lincoln, the sceptic, came more and more to see the conflict in religious terms, if not Christian ones. Thus the Enlightenment figure gave a unique turn to Enlightenment ideas. I previously knew Guelzo as the author of a well-regarded book on the Emancipation Proclamation(a book I have not read) as well as an intriguing biography of Lincoln on Wm. B. Eerdmans Press entitled ABRAHAM LINCOLN: REDEEMER PRESIDENT. More than ever I would like to read the latter, and reading this might also encourage me to read the former as well. It has also increased my interest in a book by the excellent evangelical historian Martin Noll (in my opinion, the best historian of the past century who can be described as an Evangelical) entitled THE CIVIL WAR AS THEOLOGICAL CRISIS.
I would not recommend this to anyone as the first or only book to read on Lincoln. But I would strongly recommend it to anyone who has read anything else on Lincoln and wants to have their understanding of Lincoln's work broadened and deepened.
on January 16, 2013
What Was Lincoln Thinking?: A Very Short Introduction
Lincoln: A Very Short Introduction, Allen C. Guelzo, Oxford University Press, 145 pp., 2 maps, ten photographs, index, bibliography, 2009, $11.95.
Abraham Lincoln is one of five Americans who are known on every continent of the planet earth. Allen Guelzo considers Lincoln's beliefs regarding seven essential issues being contested during the mid-19th century. The limits of equality, the possibility of advancement, the nature of law, the hazards of liberty, the importance of debate in a democratic republic, the emancipation of slaves, and the terms of reunion in order to end of the war.
Experiments in establishing democratic republics during this era had failed with the exception of the United States of America. During the 1850s it became apparent that this government was on the brink of collapse. The possibility of all men being equal was put at risk by the presence of slavery. The opportunity of all men to rise, economically and socially, was in conflict with the right to hold property in the form of slaves. Lincoln tailored and tempered his ambitions to rise in the frontier environment of a capitalistic, democratic republic. His advancement came though agriculture, transportation, retail work, military life, the practice of law and participation in local, state and national politics. Rejecting farm work, he embraced Mississippi River and Indiana commerce, militia leadership during the Black Hawk War, the bar and legislative election campaigns.
In his law practice he represented both masters and runaway slaves. The natural rights of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness, among others, were for Lincoln in direct conflict and contradicted by slavery. Hammered out in political debate, Lincoln's understanding of these natural rights were honed by his service in the courtrooms, the federal House of Representatives and the Presidency. The necessity of emancipation and the possibility of reuniting the states perplexed Lincoln.
Guelzo, Gettysburg College professor and preeminent Lincoln scholar, carefully describes Lincoln's beliefs and their context within post-revolutionary America and Europe. In clear and concise language, the author clarifies what Lincoln believed, thought and practiced. The Old Testament declares that out of the heart flows the issues of life. Guelzo's very short introduction to Lincoln's beliefs and his struggle to conform his life's work to them is a thought provoking revelation for 21st century readers.
Lincoln: A Very Short Introduction, is one of over 200 Very Short Introductions offered by Oxford University Press. CWL recommends this series; it well rewards the brief amount of time it takes to read one of the series. Curious about Freud, Jung, Islam, History, Dreaming, or the American Presidency? There is a Very Short Introduction for you.
on April 10, 2009
This is a rather unique treatment of Lincoln, but it is not easy to describe its uniqueness. Perhaps we might specify what the book is not. You won't find much about Lincoln's personal life here. There is not detailed info on his political career. The last four years of his life (the presidency) receive minimal coverage. His murder gets a paragraph. Then what *is* it about?
When I was an undergraduate during the 1960s, this book would probably have been categorized as "intellectual history". It still might be. In his introduction the author states that he is mainly interested in Lincoln's thinking: "This will be a biography of his ideas." (p. 8) Some of the ideas he pursues appear as the chapter titles: Equality; Advancement; Law; Liberty; Debate; Emancipation; Reunion. So the book proceeds chronologically but in a topical manner. The emphasis is clearly on the pre-presidential years, with only two of the seven chapters devoted to his presidency. There is also a short epilogue summarizing Guelzo's view of the man's legacy and why he became "the Great American Man" (saved the union; championed economic mobility and political equality; advocated moral principles).
In looking at the notes I took while reading, I can't say I came across much new information. This might be because I earlier had read Guelzo's full length bio of Lincoln (ABRAHAM LINCOLN: REDEEMER PRESIDENT), to which one desiring elaboration should turn. In fairness it should be noted this book contains only about 125 pages of text (and small size pages they are). In this regard, I suppose it invites comparison with another (even briefer at about 65 pages) recent biography of Lincoln by James M. Mc Pherson (ABRAHAM LINCOLN). Of the two I prefer Guelzo, probably because of his ideas emphasis.
Although there aren't any endnotes here, readers are given two separate listings (organized by chapters) of books for further reading. That's 12 pages in a book containing only 147 total pages --especially impressive these days when publishers seem to have pretty much abandoned bibliographies. Shame.
This book is recommended to those interested in a brief look at Lincoln's ideas.
4 and 3/4 stars
Tim Koerner April 2009
on June 30, 2009
A very high benchmark set by this VSI book on short biography. Regardless of how many books you read about Lincoln, you could find things interesting and memorable from this slim volume, which is organized in major themes of Lincoln's life, achievements and historical significance. What an enjoyable read! Highly recommended.