Winter Driving Best Books of the Month Men's Leather Watches Learn more nav_sap_SWP_6M_fly_beacon $5 Albums Explore Home Audio All-New Amazon Fire TV Grocery Valentine's Day Cards Knock snow out cold Amazon Gift Card Offer girls2 girls2 girls2  Amazon Echo All-New Fire Kindle Paperwhite Winter Sports on SnS

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars14
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

TOP 500 REVIEWERon October 13, 2009
When we look back and evaluate the comic books published by DC in 2009, odds are that the consensus runaway hit event is gonna be Blackest Night. Which is too bad for Superman and the pretty compelling New Krypton saga. If you haven't been keeping up with what the Man of Steel's been up to lately, then chances are you'll be startled at all the major, major developments.

Things irrevocably changed for Clark Kent following the monumental events in Action Comics #870 (Superman: Brainiac). In that issue Brainiac's assault on the Kent farm induced a fatal heart attack on Clark's adoptive father, Jonathan Kent. Superman proved oblivious to Martha Kent's cry for help, preoccupied as he was in the Arctic with the restoration of the bottled city of Kandor. In the end, Clark was too late to save his father.

SUPERMAN: NEW KRYPTON Vol. 2 reprints SUPERGIRL #35-36, SUPERMAN #682-683, and ACTION COMICS #872-873, this collected story arc helping to set the stage for the 12-issue SUPERMAN: WORLD OF NEW KRYPTON maxi-series (which I'm digging very much). This volume, as well as the volume preceding this (Superman: New Krypton, Vol. 1: Birth), illustrates that where and how you were raised plays an integral role in determining your adult worldview. Where it truly counts, there's more of the Kansas farm boy in Superman than there is the godlike extraterrestrial. Even so, with one hundred thousand Kryptonians suddenly walking our planet and rubbing elbows with him, Kal-El's Earth upbringing clashes hard with his alien heritage. Going into this bunch of issues I wasn't sure which side he'll end up on. But I did know - and you knew, as well - that this storyline is going to force him to choose. And this, with Clark still very much reeling from Jonathan Kent's death.

Earth loves Superman, loves its big blue boy scout. But folks are a bit more leery toward other Kryptonians, after what those Phantom Zone escapees did and after Supergirl's shenanigans during Amazons Attack! One hundred thousand displaced Kryptonians walking our planet, and try as Superman might to acclimate them to Earthly customs, there's a strong restless faction claiming that perhaps it should be Earth acclimating to the New Kryptonians. There's a reason that General Zod, whom we consider a supervillain, is so well regarded by his fellow Kryptonians. It turns out, his idealogy is shared by many. This brings to surface the most deadly sort of culture clash.

On the good side, Kara Zor-El (a.k.a. Supergirl) is at last reunited with her parents. But then her mom immediately demands that Kara forsake her secret identity of Linda Lang, scornfully dismissing her Earthly ties. Later on, her mom will make even more stringent demands. Poor Kara, poor Maid of Might.

***Oh, hey, it's a SPOILER alert now***

Raging paranoia ferments in one particular top secret U.S. military project, ramrodded by General Lane, Lois's believed-to-be-dead father. He aims to come up with a final counter for Superman and for the Kandorians, and his scheme involves the jailbird Lex Luthor, Reactron and Metallo (villains powered with gold and green kryptonite hearts, respectively), and the captive Brainiac. Checking out this roster, you just know it's a recipe for disastrous crippetycrap.

The writers toss in ever more intriguing elements, namely the debut of the mysterious Superwoman and further sightings of Nightwing and Flamebird, whose identities I'm very curious about. And then, most terrifically, the Creature Commandos (who some time ago were captured by Brainiac) leap into action. I've a couple of worn-out WEIRD WAR TALES issues from the early '80s, which is when I first read about the Creature Commandos. I've always been fond of these guys, so seeing them here is pretty awesome.

Back to the core story, the doodoo hits the fan when coordinated acts of aggression by a group of Kryptonians result in the abduction of some of Superman's rogue gallery and also a number of fatalities from the science police, this last being summed up by a leading Kryptonian as "collateral damage." This ultimately leads to members of the JSA and JLA (and the Guardian) storming Kandor, looking for an accounting. Except that Kandor isn't about to give up its own, no matter how desperately Superman urges the governing faction to do the right thing (because, to the New Kryptonites, the act that was committed was wholly justified, and "oops, but oh well" that there were casualties - again, warring philosophies).

The odds suck horribly for our Earth superguys as they go up against two hundred Kryptonians, all with Superman's abilities, none with his empathy. And, behind these 200 are 99,800 more standing by. Not to mention, we're still not totally, totally certain on which side Superman and Supergirl fall. But we're treated to a blistering, drag-out skirmish. It's neat how the Earth heroes, outgunned and undermanned, still find ways to gain an upper hand. Black Lightning and Starfire, in particular, are ingenious with how they apply their powers. Still, whatever momentum they gain is fleeting. I mean, these guys are basically fighting two hundred Supermen. But, then, as it turns out, the Earth heroes have back-up of their own. Hint: there are three things that can reliably take out a Kryptonian; two of them are kryptonite and a red sun...

With three writers involved, one has a fear of too many cooks. But Geoff Johns (ACTION COMICS), James Robinson (SUPERMAN), and Sterling Gates (SUPERGIRL) collaborate well enough that there's a clear cut cohesion to the story. As I read these issues, there's an electric sense of excitement, of things happening on an epic scale, of big plot points being advanced. I'm hoping that DC keeps moving forward with this, that they don't chicken out and return Superman to his former status quo (things look very promising so far, what with the good stuff going on in SUPERMAN: WORLD OF NEW KRYPTON). But I feel bad for Supergirl's plight. She really is torn between two worlds.

The artwork is really good, notably the issues worked on by Renato Guedes (SUPERMAN) and Pete Woods (ACTION COMICS). Even Jamal Igle (SUPERGIRL) isn't bad, his stuff somewhat reminiscent of Phil Jimenez's style, which in turn strays close to hallowed George Perez territory. And then there are Alex Ross's glossy covers which continue to get me all gobsmacked. I've been off and on with Superman all my life, his sort of bland superheroing not really my cup of tea. But with Geoff Johns and company breathing new life into him, I am hanging on for dear life, enjoying this ride. Kal-El no longer the Last Son of Krypton? Works for me.
11 comment15 of 16 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 19, 2011
This book is WAY better than volume 1!!.

Superman is between a rock and a hard place here. How can you be Kryptonian and Human at the same time. LEt me tell you right now that is not possible. Poor Supes!.

Sorry if my review of the bok seems hollow, but I hate giving spoilers, but what I can say about this one is that it have action, mistery, WTF moments and more.

What I don't like is the art. So many artist and just a handful can get the characters right. Sometimes the drawings are good but the coloring is too shining. Anyway, I topok a star out because of the screwy art.

This hardcover edition doesn't give you anything new nor cool, and the art make it non-worthy of having it in cool hardbound. Without the dustjacket the book is very simple. Nothing fancy, and because of that I recomend you to save your money and get the sofcover edition instead.
0Comment1 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on November 2, 2009
This New Krypton story line has been a awesome series. It is definitly building with each book and is the only Superman book that I collect. Highly recommend.
0Comment4 of 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 4, 2011
These three writer's are extremely talented. Johns, Robinson and Gates deliver a tale told in a modern conversational way about an epic event in the DC world. The character moments really feel genuine. The art crosses the spectrum from great to poor. The covers by Alex Ross, Gary Frank and Joshua Middleton are all really nice. The interior art varies, but the story more than makes up for it.
0Comment1 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 29, 2015
Collects (in order)
Supergirl 35 (Sterling Gates)
Superman 682 (James Robinson)
Action 872 (Geoff Johns)
Supergirl 36 (Gates)
Superman 683 (Robinson)
Action 873 (Johns)

Unbeknownst to Supergirl, she has been suffering from kryptonite poisoning. When she's cured of this, she regains her memories of what really happened to Argo City (a clever way to do a mini-reboot). The Kryptonians have difficulty adjusting to life on Earth. They round up Superman's enemies (with some exceptions, like Luthor and Brainiac.) There is collateral damage, which Alura (Supergirl's mother) has no problems with. Metallo And Reactron are sent by Project 7734 (read it upside down) to Kandor with tragic results (and then they just, what, diasappear? The Kryptonians don't go after them?) There's a big fight between Kryptonians and superheroes (Starfire can suck energy from Kryptonians by stopping light from reaching them? Yeah, fine whatever). The Kryptonians decide they can't coexist on Earth with humans, so they use Brainiac's technology to create a new planet on the other side of the sun from Earth: New Krypton (conservation of matter?)

Apart from my geeky quibbles, this volume is actually better than the previous one. The story flows well in spite of the rotating multiple authors. The artists are very adept with facial expressions.
22 commentsWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 10, 2015
Okay so maybe having a Kryptonian city on Earth wasn't such a good idea after all.


The new Kryptonians aren't like Superman at all, they seem to see themselves as better than humans and they feel that the laws of our planet shouldn't apply to them while they are here. They go around and at a few points they seem to try and do good, like when they take some of Superman's villains and bring them in to face trial and banish them to the phantom zone. Sure that's a good idea in theory but when you have to bust them out of prison to do it, and in the process you happen to kill a few guards and police officers... not so good.

Eventually there is a huge battle and Brainiac and Lex Luthor are on the sidelines but still they manage to affect the outcome. In the end New Krypton leaves the Earth, they form a new planet and it is in orbit around the sun directly opposite from Earth so it can no longer be seen by us.


Geoff Johns did a great job writing this and it really renewed my interest in the Man of Steel and Supergirl. I am very eager to read the next volume. Check it out!
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on September 29, 2011
Great story for any Superman fan. Would be a great gift or even something for yourself. Drawn good and wonderful story.
0Comment1 of 1 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 31, 2015
I'm enjoying this New Krypton story arc. Volume two has somewhat better artwork than volume one. The six chapters in volume two lead up to the creation of New Krypton in synchronous orbit with Earth, and Superman departing for his new home. There are lots of confrontations and fisticuffs, General Lane and Luthor continue to scheme and attack Kryptonians, Aunt Alura needs a hug, and Superman just wants everyone to get along. The many story threads are still dangling at the end of the volume, so I was left feeling a bit at sea, but I'm having a pretty good time reading and looking forward to the rest of the tale, so I consider this $10 well spent.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 3, 2011
Continuing the story from Superman: New Krypton, Vol. 1, this volume includes some surprising developments and more confrontations between the people of Kandor and the people of Earth. This is the last crossover volume, before most of the characters split up and enjoy their own story arc. The mysteries of Nightwing and Flamebird are particularly intriguing, as is the conclusion to this volume. New Krypton clearly does not warrant the hatred it has garnered (although I am reviewing these books with the powerful weapon of Hindsight).
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 2, 2014
I just finished reading part 2. The very good storyline started in part 1 continues. It has several surprises for Superman and Supergirl fans.
0CommentWas this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse