Amazon.com: Customer Reviews: Doctor Who: The Reign of Terror (Story 8)
Automotive Deals HPCC Amazon Fashion Learn more nav_sap_plcc_ascpsc Billy Talent Fire TV Stick Health, Household and Grocery Back to School Handmade school supplies Shop-by-Room Amazon Cash Back Offer CafeSociety CafeSociety CafeSociety  Amazon Echo  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Amazon Echo Starting at $49.99 All-New Kindle Oasis AutoRip in CDs & Vinyl Segway miniPro

Customer Reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars
48
Format: DVD|Change
Price:$17.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on March 2, 2013
I am glad that 2-Entertain has taken to animating a few classic Doctor Who stories because it allows fans of the classic series to still enjoy the stories from the past. As most classic Doctor Who fans know the BBC wiped many of the the stories from the Hartnell-Troughton years to save money. All of the audio exists thanks to fans who would plop their cassette recorders in front of the TV each week to to capture the original shows as they aired in the 1960's. The BBC did not have the same marketing attitude of US TV producers who kept a lot of old TV shows that some of us would like to forget. But it allowed these shows to continue on in syndication for years (and years and years).

The animation here is pretty basic and I think it is done in such a way to reflect the original version in its original concept. The story is more of an historical drama rather than Sci-Fi. Granted I would prefer if the original 'live' performances still existed but this is a fine substitution.

The DVD includes a "making of" documentary like the others. But we are talking about stories that are about a half-century old so, sadly, many of the original actors and crew behind this story have passed away. So instead of their input you get input from people who are knowledgeable about the inner workings of the BBC from an intelligent point of view rather than hands on.

I am a collector of these DVD's so this is a great addition to my collection. But for the average person this might be a little slow to watch.
0Comment| 7 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
The Doctor is trying to land in present-day England (1964), in another attempt to take Barbara and Ian home. Unfortunately, the TARDIS ends up in the French countryside. More to the point, it is 1794 France. The French Revolution is five years old and Madame Guillotine reigns.

In spite of finding period clothing to change into (Ian comments on Barbara's transformation with, "Hairstyle's a bit modern, but it's all right."), it doesn't take them long to get into trouble. Susan, Ian and Barbara find themselves arrested and taken to Paris, and the infamous Conciergerie Prison, to await their execution. They're told, "You will be guillotined as soon as it can be arranged." [Historical note: This is due to a new law that gives the authorities the right to execute not only without a trial, but based on suspicion only.]

The Doctor, fortunately, was separated from the trio and not arrested. He takes off down the road to Paris to rescue them. He meets a forced gang road work crew, and because the Doctor can't keep his mouth shut, he ends up being pressed into labor himself.

Fortunately, our travelers, in more than one place, stumble onto an escape chain. But it is not that easy to get anyone out of Paris, even with the chaos that is still France, and it will be a close shave (heh heh). Spies and turncoats from both sides operate on secrecy and paranoia. But how often do you get to meet a world figure such as Napoleon?

This is a review of the January 2013 1-disc DVD release of "The Reign of Terror", the first time the full serial has been released on DVD. It was considered a "lost serial" until the 1980's when copies of the video for episodes 1, 2, 3 and 6 were recovered from stations in Malta and Cyprus and a private collector. A VHS was released in 2003 with narration by Carole Ford (who plays Susan) linking episodes 3 and 6.

For this DVD release, however, the BBC is including animated versions of episodes 4 & 5. They did recover the full original audio of episodes 4 & 5, so the animation will be matched with the original voices of William Hartnell, et al. As Toby Hadoke says, in the Commentary: "A doughty fan with a microphone next to their telly recorded the sound track."

[Added after I received and watched the DVD:] I was pleasantly surprised by the two animated episodes. The animation is grayscale; I've added a still to this page as a Customer Image to give you an idea of how it looks. If you aren't going to go to the expense to get Disney-quality animation, then this grayscale animation is an elegant solution. It rather looks like a modern graphic novel. In particular, look at the characters' eyes. Whoever animated the eyes is a genius. Susan occasionally looks like a scarecrow and the Doctor like a wrinkled apple, but overall, I thought it was a decent effort. The sound on the two animated sequences still has a bit of the microphone recorded sound to it, and I had to turn up the volume a bit, but, overall, it wasn't a problem for me.

This is a decent episode of Dr. Who, which originally aired in August/September 1964. The show has six 25-minute episodes. I take a star off because there isn't much science fiction in the tale. This is just my opinion - it's a historical show and has nice twists and turns to the plot, but it's still not science fiction and the driving force behind the plot is that it is an escape thriller. The only science-fiction-y moment is when Barbara says that she learned her lesson about trying to change the future in "The Aztecs".

But there is a lot to like about "Reign of Terror". The sets are great and the atmosphere appropriately tense. There is some nice acting, and I particularly got a kick out of the jailer, a sodden bully who's alternately servile. He's humorous without meaning to be.

The attention to historical detail seems very good. For example, when Robespierre is arrested, he holds a hand over the lower part of his face. In real life, Robespierre unsuccessfully attempted to kill himself before capture, by shooting himself through the jaw (some believe he was shot by one of his captors). On the other hand, as revealed in the Info Text, Extra #6, the Secretary of the Napoleon I Society wrote a letter to the BBC stating that "Today's episode [#6] was, factually speaking, nonsense."

One thing I noticed is that I am not fond of this series' incidental music. That's a surprise for me, because usually I don't even notice the incidental music.

Extras on the DVD:
** Commentary on all six episodes, which I found great fun to listen to. It is found under the Audio Options Extra #5, but I wanted to describe it first. Moderated by Toby Hadoke, who is, once again, a fan extraordinaire with many facts at his fingertips. Commentators include Carole Ann Ford (plays Susan), Neville Smith (plays D'Argenson, the blonde panicky escapee at the farmhouse), Jeffry Wickham (plays Webster, Ian's English cellmate, who promptly dies), Caroline Hunt (plays Danielle, living at the safe house, her 1st job straight out of drama school), Patrick Marley (soldier on the left arresting Robespierre), Timothy Coombe (his first job after being promoted to production assistant) and Ronald Pickup (the physician who betrays Susan and Barbara, in his very first job on TV). In addition, Paul Vanezis and Philip Morris talk about the search for the missing episodes.
The commentary for the two animated episodes was recorded before the animation was completed, but the commentators did have the audio and photos to go by.
The commentators have a lot of fun together. Jeffry Wickam, for example, appears in only one episode, ever, of Doctor Who, and he's flat on his back dying in short order. Yet, "It absolutely amazes me that I quite often get people saying how enormously they admire my artistry as Webster."
In 1981, Dr. Who Magazine published a list of lost episodes. On his own, Paul Vanezis "started writing letters to television stations all over the world, hoping that some episodes might turn up." Though we may be unhappy with BBC's decision to destroy old footage, Phillip Morris reminds us that "General Hindsight never won a war."
Last but not least, at one point, Hadoke says to Neville Smith, "You're about to get rhubarbed to death." You have to listen to the commentary to find out what he was talking about!
[If you're interested, the sfx.co.uk website has an April, 2012, article that I found fun and interesting. It's about how some recent commentaries have been recorded for Doctor Who, including photos of studio sessions. You can find it by googling "Doctor Who: Recording The DVD Commentaries".]
1. "Don't Lose Your Head - The Making of the Reign of Terror" (25 minutes) Commentators are Carole Ann Ford, William Russell (plays Ian) and Timothy Combe. The filming had some low points, some of which can be summed up as The Curse of Lime Grove Studios. The studio was very cramped and very hot. So hot that a couple times the sprinklers came on in the middle of filming. The odd oblong shape made set design as well as camera placement difficult.
2. "Robespierre's Domain: Animated Backgrounds Tour" (4 minutes) While listening to audio from the show of action that takes place in the animated episodes 4 & 5, you are shown the animated backgrounds before the animated characters were added. All in black & white, of course, and quite atmospheric.
3. "The Reign of Terror - Photo Gallery" (4 minutes) A variety of stills are shown. There are color photos from rehearsals, and black & white stills from the show and as well as the empty sets. It's all accompanied by a rousing rendition of La Marseillaise.
4. "The Reign of Terror - Animation Gallery" (4 minutes) I found this very intersting. There are character studies, as a painter might make, with an actor's face from different angles. There are examples of where the animator started from a photo of an actor and then translated it into animation. There are examples where the animation started with a line drawing of the actor, and then filled out into the full animation.
5. Audio Options:
...A) Feature Audio (ie. regular viewing)
...B) Commentary
6. Production Info Text. This can be viewed only on the four non-animated episodes. Reviewers don't often mention the Info Text. Am I the only one who enjoys it? For example, at the beginning of episode 1 of "Reign of Terror", we see the "first ever on-screen materialisation [British spelling] of the full-sized police box prop". I liked the details on the differences between filming TV in the 60's, versus today. Some mechanical/actor/continuity/costume bloopers are mentioned, as well as historical tidbits: "Nearly three quarters of those condemned by the revolutionary tribunals were workers and peasants". And how about clothes hangers? When were they invented?
Director Henric Hirsch is mentioned many times in the commentary and other extras. He collapsed on the set, from nervous exhaustion, for a couple reasons combined. In the other extras, the unfortunate common view seems to be that "Reign of Terror" ruined Hirsch for any more BBC jobs. In the Info Text, however, it says that Hirsch went on to direct five other dramas for BBC.
7. PDF. On your computer DVD ROM, view the Radio Times Listings
8. Coming Soon Trailer. This is a GREAT trailer, scary and suspenseful, for "The Ark in Space", a superlative Dr. Who episode with Tom Baker.

Happy Reader
review image review image
2020 comments| 53 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 4, 2014
As we all know, many of the First and Second Doctor's serials have been lost. This is one of those that was missing two of the six episodes (four and five). The video for these two episodes has been reconstructed using animation, and merged with the original audio. The animated episodes seem to catch the essence of the characters very well, although some have issues with its style. However, I personally think that one should prefer it to a incomplete serial, or one with only audio and telesnaps from the filming (like the missing episode in "Web of Fear").

So, on to the story itself, a more or less pure historical set in the French Revolution. Ian, Barbara, and Susan manage to get captured and sentenced to death by Guillotine. The Doctor must rescue them by guile and deception. A number of interesting subsidiary characters and plots make this an interesting story in spite of having no science-fictional elements.

The special features include a "making of" with William Russle (Ian), and Carol Ann Ford (Susan), a couple of shorts about the animation of the two lost episodes, a photo gallery, PDF materials, and audio commentary.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 13, 2013
Finally got around to watching the entire story. The story is average but I do have a huge gripe with the animation. I applaud the effort in doing this but they maybe tried too hard. Too many quick edits with too many up close shots and it hurts the eyes because of all the edits. Every shot lasts maybe at most 2 or 3 seconds then BAM another close up or different angle. I've lost count at how many cut edits there are in 30 seconds let alone a full animated episode. Plus they seem centered on just pure close ups on facial features which are overdone. They look in reality....creepy. However I do like the fact that they did keep the animation to a black and white type feature.
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 17, 2013
In another attempt to get Ian & Barbra back to England they arrive in France at the height of the French Revolution, They are taken prisoner by the 'Citizens' and imprisoned to wait for their turn to meet Lady Guillotine, but the Doctor had been knocked out by some Loyalists and had to walk to Paris and find his companions. It's not only a good adventure story but a good history lesson about the revolt in France against the Monarchy, it's one of Hartnell's better stories, with sub plots and lots of action.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 16, 2013
I might not have bought this save for the animated episodes. I'd like to see other DW serials animated to complete them (one even hopes someday this will be done for serials with little to no episodes left). This is a good story but far from one of my favorites. The animation is well done even if the animators make things more lively than the very studio bound episodes were. I'm waiting for The Tenth Planet and The Ice Warriors to be done this way.
11 comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on December 28, 2013
while it's good to have this story, it's a pity that the animation couldn't have been professional. This looks like the Japanese anime garbage which is a pity. It could've been done so much better by a professional studio. Let's hope the other "retsorations" are done better.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on June 1, 2013
I love all the Dr Who older movies, as well as the newer ones. Had this on CD, but it is much better having the images. Even though some are cartoons. Invasions also has cartoons, from having lost the films. This being the first Doctor, it is always
a favorite.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on August 27, 2015
The Doctor ends up in the middle of the French Revolution in a well done story by Dennis Spooner. While at times a bit slow, the overall story comes off good and there is plenty of action overall,

Episodes 4 & 5 are animated but are well done which doesn't limit the enjoyment of the story at all.

This is a great addition to any Doctor Who collection.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 4, 2013
A fun time-travelling adventure set in France at the time of the French Revolution, seeing some of the key characters brought to life in interaction with our Doctor Who regulars.

This story has one main thing to commend it: It has never been released on video' before. The reason for this is that two episodes were missing from the archive. Thus, all Doctor Who fans had were croaky old fifth generation pirate copies and soundtrack recordings. Now, with the help of some lacklustre animation, the full six parts have been restored for your viewing pleasure.

Dennis Spooner's story isn't one of his greatest, but it's reasonable. There are little educational bits about the French Revolution thrown in, which I quite enjoyed. It does seem rather slow-moving, but more than that, it's repetitive, with people in and out of prison. The realisationm however, is pretty good. Despite beginning the story in the cramped Lime Grove studios, Director Henric Hirsch manages to pull off a stylish and convincing production. The costumes are superb, particularly the outfit William Hartnell's first Doctor is shown wearing on the cover of the DVD. Likewise the sets are exemplary, and not for one moment do you think you are not in France. The regulars are on good form, particularly Hartnell, who delights in his temporary costume change and the chance it gives him to play an authority figure.

The two animated episodes try hard, but despite some wonderful drawings of sets and good character artwork, the actual movements are poor and this is compounded by a distracting "morphing" effect used in facial expressions. Thankfully, it's only two episodes, and then we are back to reality.

The extras are great, with a feature about the making of the programme showing just how difficult it was for poor old Henric Hirsch (so much so that he had a breakdown). The commentary is reasonably good, with Carole Ann Ford and Tim Combe being moderated by Toby Hadoke, then for the animated episodes there is a rather odd commentary track, bearing no relation to the visuals. This is Paul Vanezis telling the story of the missing episodes and how some were recovered. This gives him a chance to set the record straight (there's a bit of Ian Levine myth-making in there!). While this is a tale worth telling, it doesn't belong on a commentary track, and really the disc should have had something like The Invasion, where the stars could watch animated versions of themselves and still give a meaningful commentary on the action of the episode.

Not one of the best, but hey, it's Doctor Who, it's enjoyable, and it's William Hartnell, so four stars :-)
22 comments|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse