Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
31 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Fascinating close-up portrait of a brilliant, damaged card player, June 24, 2005
This review is from: One of a Kind: The Rise and Fall of Stuey "The Kid" Ungar, The World's Greatest Poker Player (Hardcover)
Stu Ungar's legend transcends poker: he won the world championship three times (the third more than a decade and a half after the second and when he was regarded as a has-been or curiosity) and was supposedly an even BETTER gin player. He had a genius for games that was almost unfathomable. Then, just a year and a half after his greatest triumph, he was dead.
Nolan Dalla and Peter Alson have big-league credentials as researchers and writers of a story about a broken genius of cards. Among other things, Dalla is the media director for the World Series of Poker, can get in touch with ANYONE connected with poker, and interviewed Ungar several times before his death in 1998. Dalla has papered poker publications and web sites with excellent accounts. Alson wrote a highly-acclaimed book about his days as a bookie at Harvard and has written for a writer's wish-list of men's magazines.
Their account is so intimate that it's almost uncomfortable. I say this as a GOOD THING! Ungar was very private, closed even to most people in the poker world, and not a frequent interview subject. This was especially true regarding the two things we'd want to know about: his genius at cards and his self-destruction. Dalla interviewed him before his death and the periodic first-person accounts by Ungar are fascinating and shocking. In addition, the higher echelons of poker (especially where organized crime figures are possibly near, as they were in Ungar's early days and, socially, later on) can be a closed world. Even though men like Mike Sexton and Doyle Brunson are public figures, you would not expect them to be frank about their tragic friend, or about matters potentially at odds with poker's relatively recent, relatively wholesome reputation. But Dalla and Alson got the inside accounts from Stuey's closest friends and even those shadowy mobsters. They also obtained the story from Ungar's ex-wife and daughter; again, invaluable sources you'd expect would be difficult to get.
Stu Ungar's life story is fascinating, no matter how it is told, so the authors are starting with a good hand. From a research perspective, there can be no more authoritative work on the man.
But it is the writing and story telling that REALLY shine. The authors weave together Ungar's first-person accounts with the stories of their many sources in a way that is seamless and compelling. Ungar's essential mystery remains, but the authors allow us to experience the key moments of his bizarre life, always knowing what he's up to and why.
At the risk of mixing metaphors, Ungar lived a roller-coaster life that came to a train-wreck end. The story, ultimately, is a sad one, but it is a thrilling ride for the reader.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
35 of 37 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Fire that Drives Also Destroys., July 9, 2005
This review is from: One of a Kind: The Rise and Fall of Stuey "The Kid" Ungar, The World's Greatest Poker Player (Hardcover)
I recall that Jim Mcmanus, in his book on the World Series of Poker, mentioned that Stu Ungar was someone with a life truly in need of exploring, so I was pleased to find out about the existence of this book. I ordered it the minute it was released.
I could not be more pleased with the purchase. Its pages flow like frames in a motion picture. I could not put the biography down. This is a tribute both to the professional writer employed, Peter Alson, and also to the ornate texture of the life it documents.
Stu Ungar was a thoroughly compulsive, brilliant man who was given many gifts that he, with unprecedented impatience, smoked away through the tube of a crack pipe. There was no "could have been a champ" with Stuey though. He won The World Series of Poker three times and was victorious in 381 competitions overall. His memory was photographic and his mind a spinning computer, yet it was his ever-present need for instant gratification that finished him. A lack of concern for money was his greatest No Limit characteristic, but it was also his biggest weakness as he blew millions on sports betting, the ponies, and every other proposition put before him.
Ungar was a man of total contradictions. He loved being a father and cared intensely for his daughter and stepson, yet he disappeared for weeks at a time and could often not be reached when they needed him. Stuey lived for competition but allowed drugs to cause him to skip the 1998 WSOP and sleep through the last two days of the 1990 one. He could be charming and entertaining but had few social graces. This genius had parts which canceled out his whole.
The book succeeds at many levels. We feel tremendous sympathy for the main character, but wonder what more any single person could have done to save him. The finest of the poker players are emotionally non-responsive at the table and possess "alligator blood." However, with Stuey, they brought misery upon themselves in the hopes of diverting him from his inevitable destruction. Doyle Brunson let him move in with his family in El Paso, while Mike Sexton, the same cheeseball who provides color for the World Poker Tour, paid Ungar's hotel bills time and again just so his friend would have a place to live. Chip Reese had written him off, but, finally, as Ungar sat in a jail cell, he pulled out 55 C notes to secure his release.
Stuey Ungar had more talent than practically anyone else on this earth, and being rich should have been a sure thing, but his love of life never equaled his lust for action. He died by his own hand even if the coroner's report said otherwise.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Riveting and tragically compelling, October 1, 2005
This review is from: One of a Kind: The Rise and Fall of Stuey "The Kid" Ungar, The World's Greatest Poker Player (Hardcover)
This book began as a tell-all biography written by/with Ungar, that turned out to be for tragic but inevitable reasons about Ungar instead. Dalla and Alson weave a riveting tale of Ungar's growing up a bookie's son in New York, falling in as a sort of pet of the mob, finding his true calling in Las Vegas, and reaching, virtually simultaneously, the highest highs and lowest lows one can experience in a gambling career. His transcendent, really almost extrasensory brilliance and feel for cards is obvious.
Unfortunately Ungar's personality was wildly unbalanced, and a genius for cards was matched with a gaping hole where the rest of his personality should have been. Prodigies in other fields equally abstruse - take for example Morphy or Fischer in chess - had something of this, too. The book is anything but a psychological study, but in its sheer repetition of the ups and downs of Ungar's life, shows the cycles of mania and self-destruction getting tigher and tighter like a vise around him. The end was completely predictable and inevitable, from this viewpoint.
Dalla and Alson write well, with a flair for telling dramatic poker stories, and of course they had access to a lot of very colorful people who spent a lot of time with Ungar. In that sense, it is a page-turner, and hard to put down. However, despite the fact that a lot of poker players will tell you they can learn everything about a man through how he plays poker, I came away from the book feeling that while I knew more about Ungar's ultimately tragic life, I didn't really know what drove him.
It's easy to say that hunger for action, a self-destructive willingness and even eagerness to court disaster constantly, and a soft affection for his daughter, and a savant-like talent all resided in the body - well, yes, but why? How did he become that way? In the end he seems to have just grown up an overindulged talent who never did grow to even the maturity of the average 20 year old.
The book does tell a fascinating story of the unique personalities of poker and Las Vegas, and makes great reading.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|