Amazon.com: The Shack (Special Hardcover Edition): William P. Young, Wayne Jacobsen & Brad Cummings: Books

3,413 Reviews

5 star:		(2,210)
4 star:		(305)
3 star:		(172)
2 star:		(169)
1 star:		(557)

Average Customer Review

4.0 out of 5 stars (3,413 customer reviews)

Share your thoughts with other customers:

Create your own review

Most Helpful Customer Reviews

1,590 of 1,864 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars No Flannel-Graph Jesus, January 27, 2008

By	Eric Wilson "novelist" (Nashville, TN United States) - See all my reviews (TOP 100 REVIEWER)

This review is from: The Shack (Paperback)

In the book world, it's hard to explain "the buzz." What causes word of mouth to start spreading? What turns an unknown author and novel into a surprise bestseller? Even more inexplicable for the book snobs is when a story fails to meet their literary standards and yet touches the masses in an undeniable way.

"The Shack" is the buzz book of the past few months. I hadn't even heard of it in November, but by the end of December I'd had relatives, friends, and online pals from across the country telling me I "had" to read this one. I've been burned by such recommendations in the past, particularly in relation to spiritually oriented titles. (Can anyone say "The Prayer of Jabez" and "Left Behind"?), but I was willing to give it a shot.

William P. Young's book has an intriguing premise. Years ago, a father name MacKenzie Phillips took his children camping and lost one of them to a man who has kidnapped and killed others. Mack has grieved since then. His marriage has struggled. Understandably, his relationship with God has suffered. Then, one wintry day, he receives a note in his mailbox inviting him back to the woods, to the shack in which his daughter's dress and bloodstains were found. The note, it would seem, is from God.

From this simple yet effective premise, Young leads Mack Phillips back to his point of despair and anger. The encounters he then has with God there in "The Shack" serve as thought-provoking moments for both Mack and the reader. This is not the God of stodgy Sunday school classes. This is not a flannel-graph Jesus. This is not limited to a fluttering dove of the Holy Spirit. The descriptions here are startling, while remaining true to the nature of God's love and grace as portrayed through Scripture. Not only are they startling, they're wise and moving and beautiful.

Some might argue that "The Shack" has little theology or accuracy to it, but the very argument is what Young is trying to melt away. I earned a Bachelor's from a Bible college, and the majority of Mack's godly encounters could be wrapped up in biblical theology: redemption, grace, forgiveness, propitiation, etc. Do I agree with every line of the book? Not necessarily. Yet, while never sounding like trite religion (because they're not and never should be!), the words spoken by God in this book are full of vibrancy and life.

Is it the best crafted novel ever? No. In many ways, it could be encapsulated in a non-fiction treatise. However, in sharing this remarkable tale in a fictional form, Young has breathed wonder and wisdom into a story that will continue to buzz around for years to come.

Comment Comments (118) | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)

366 of 441 people found the following review helpful:

1.0 out of 5 stars A poorly written, philosophically bankrupt, theologically challenged airport novel. , March 18, 2009

By	Drew Ross "Christian With A Brain" (Sharpsburg, GA) - See all my reviews

This review is from: The Shack (Paperback)

Wow am I really going to feel like a wet blanket. I hate to say it after all of these awesome reviews of this book, but I really didn't like it. Not just on a theological level either. I just didn't get to the destination that others have. I really don't want to be negative, especially when others have been so impacted by it. But here is what I think about The Shack.

First of all, being a former literature teacher, I actually am shocked by the comparison with Pilgrim's Progress. You are talking about the most popular book in human history second only to the Bible. Pilgrim's Progress is known for its emotional impact more than its literary accomplishment, so they are similar in that. But I think that is where the similarities end. The Shack is not well written at all and focuses on only one primary issue. PP covers the entire Christian walk and does so in a most unique way. It is not only the pinnacle of Christian literature, it is the best of an entire genre (allegory). PP relies upon the everyday Christian's ability to relate to the character Christian and his entire adventure. The Shack relies almost completely on the effect of trauma done to the characters.

Secondly, the theological problems are difficult to overlook. I don't understand the mentality that says, God is pictured as a lot of things in the Bible, so why can't I picture Him/Her as whatever I feel comfortable with? Well, because one of the most devastating forms of heresy is to give God identifiable form, hence the graven images commandment. That's why Jesus was described as one that we would not find outstanding by Isaiah. I have discussed this topic earlier in the year on my podcast, Christian with a Brain. We are not supposed to put God in a box, whether that box be an old, bearded, caucasian male, or an overweight African-American female, it doesn't matter. The truth is that when even an angel enters the scene, people fall on their faces in awe. Making God a poker buddy isn't going to improve my relationship with Him.

This is also part of what I believe to be the humanization of God. We are trying to fashion God in our image, and this book simply reinforces that idea. We have gone from one extreme (God is an impersonal force that wants to punish me) to the other (God blows smoke rings, listens to punk rock and is my buddy). This is exactly like the enemy. He beats us up with one wrong image of God, then he shoves us all the way off the other end of the shelf by presenting a completely different, wrong image of God.

God is my Father, my Abba, my Friend, my King, my Deliverer, my Redeemer, my Fortress, my Strong Tower, my Mother Hen, my Alpha and Omega, my Bread and my Savior and the Word tells me that this is indeed so.

Finally, the philosophy in this book is very weak. In fact, I still don't know the conclusion. If you were to try to communicate the lesson of this book in a syllogism, what would it be? I have an 8 year-old daughter and I hate to sound harsh, but this book terrified me and then never really gave me any satisfying resolution. I believe the problem of evil to be the best arguement in the atheist's arsenal, but this book did nothing to dull its sting. I believe there are powerful and effective answers to address the problem of evil, but in my opinion, this book didn't give them to me.

Wow. I really sound like I hated this book. I hope I haven't offended anyone. But I also have a commitment to communicate what I believe to be true. If you were one of those who really didn't understand the powerful love of God simply by reading the Gospels, then this book was probably a blessing. But other than that, I think it fell way short and may even be destructive for many.

Comment Comments (53) | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)

306 of 376 people found the following review helpful:

5.0 out of 5 stars This Book Restored My Faith-Crystal Clear, January 27, 2008

By	The Time Keeper "Dave" (Battle Ground, WA. USA) - See all my reviews

This review is from: The Shack (Paperback)

This is probably the most profound and best book I have ever read in my entire life. It has brought me totally back to God. I have never felt better. I totally identified with Mack and the Great Sadness which has been in my life also.

I am a Viet Nam combat vet. In Viet Nam I had forsaken God. I could not believe that God would permit such things to happen on Earth. But as I learned more about WWII and Korea and other World events my lack of disbelieve just strengthened. Until about six and one half years ago I felt a need to come back and test the waters. My oldest son was in 9-11 as a paramedic (he went in on his day off) and I was so proud of him, but I felt a need to find my faith, because he had found it. He was a block away from the second tower when it collapsed. He went on to fulfill his lifelong ambition to become a New York Fire Fighter and actually entered into the prestigious Squad One. But oh, what a price for him and his family to pay. So much death to witness, and all of those funerals to attend. I wished I could have protected him from that, but I could not. I failed. I hold myself accountable for this lack of ability to successfully fulfill my mission in life as a father, just like I do the men I sent to their deaths in Viet Nam and the hundreds of people I have killed. I have lived with Viet Nam inside me for over 35 years until recently. These are only some of the crosses I bear. This book has brought me full circle. It has helped me to restore my faith. I have helped several people to purchase this book and I will continue. But I now know what is important and what is not so important.

My Step-daughter Lisa recommended I read this book after she read a Christmas message I sent to all of my children, step-children and special friends over and over again. I had sent a picture of Arlington at Christmas that had touched me very close to my heart. So I wanted each of them to see this and understand this was the price of liberty and that there were men and women who were willing to give their lives on foreign soil to guarantee their rights under the constitution of the United States. I penned a personal message to each of the couples or person along with the general message.

To John and Lisa, who are House Pastors for a local church, I was sorry I was not stronger for them when Kelsey their newborn went to heaven. Kelsey was born with a small aorta and Dr. Starr in Portland, OR was going to fix that. He was the best. I felt we were fine, but I had no faith, just my gut instincts that had gotten me out of every other jam before except a couple that resulted in loss of life. I went to the hospital every noon to see Lisa and Kelsey and got to hold Kelsey and she was so innocent.. So the day came, Dr. Starr entered the waiting room with the bad news. Kelsey had not survived. John went to pieces and Lisa was helping him because she seemed stronger at the time. My wife was asking me if I was going to go to John and help him. She said this several times. I was standing up, but I was not there. I was near a river west of Danang trying to get two of my men out of a jam that I had ordered to stay back and lay down fire so we could extract some wounded. The smells, the visual, the noises were all real. My men were dead and so was Kelsey. I never told anyone about that until I wrote that letter. So Lisa read that over and over and recommended I read "The Shack". I am so glad she did too!!

I never loan books, so I gave it to a close friend. I purchased the hardbound edition for keeping and rereading.

Since reading "The Shack" I have never felt so whole in my entire life. I have redevoted my life to Jesus and I have laughed with him in his presence. Thank you for the Great Book. Thank you Paul for introducing me to Mack. He made me realize I was not alone. Be careful when they make this into a movie. I am not sure how they can do it justice.

One more thing. Take your time reading this book. Take time to smell the roses. If you cannot, then read it again.

Remember who is writing this review!! As Paul Young told me, live one day at a time and live in the moment. It is the only thing that is real. Enjoy your life!!

Comment Comments (18) | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)

Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review

› See all 3,413 customer reviews...

Most Recent Customer Reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars Interesting read
Reading the book has made me think about my relationship with the BIG GUY. Well worth reading.

Published 29 minutes ago by T. C. Cornell

5.0 out of 5 stars The Shack - A great read
Don't get stopped before you finish this book. I was stopped for the better part of a year until I heard the author interviewed on TV and picked it up for a second time. Read more

Published 1 hour ago by Marian H. Melville

5.0 out of 5 stars The Shack
I was very impressed with The Shack. I think everyone that reads it comes away with something different. It really made me think about life and what it really means. Read more

Published 9 hours ago by Willda Parbst

3.0 out of 5 stars The Shack
The Shack was bought for someone else -- two people that bought it were talking about it last night -- one liked it better than the other, but I got the feeling that they did not... Read more

Published 9 hours ago by Anonymous

4.0 out of 5 stars Good book
It is definitely a page turner. The author has a good of explaining things, but I won't necessarily make it all theology (it was not written to be such anyways). Read more

Published 11 hours ago by Student_PhD

5.0 out of 5 stars The Shack
Whether you are religious or not, the book has a lesson for learning to forgive those that have offended you in life and allow yourself to grow beyond the pains from the past and... Read more

Published 12 hours ago by John G. Clancey

5.0 out of 5 stars The Shack
I have read and re-read The Shack more than a dozen times. On occasion, I would finish the last page and turn back to the first page to start re-reading. Read more

Published 13 hours ago by Dr. John W. Hard

5.0 out of 5 stars excellent message in this book
If you have any doubts in God and why He does things, or why you think he does not do things, then read this book and you will have alot to think about..

Published 13 hours ago by S. Seddon

2.0 out of 5 stars Nothing special or groundbreaking here.
For what it's worth, The Shack is a half-decent work of fiction. Some people who read this may need to watch their emotions throughout the story simply because it can be very easy... Read more

Published 22 hours ago by M. Terry

5.0 out of 5 stars pinheadsal
One of the best books I have ever read. Get ready to open you mind and spirit(you know the part that is only known to you). If you do this, The Shack will rock your world.

Published 1 day ago by Sally Mills

› See all 3,413 customer reviews...

	93% buy the item featured on this page: The Shack (Special Hardcover Edition) 4.0 out of 5 stars (3,413) $15.74
	2% buy Glenn Beck's Common Sense: The Case Against an Out-of-Control Government, Inspired by Thomas Paine 3.8 out of 5 stars (180) $6.59
	2% buy The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (Vintage) 4.2 out of 5 stars (322) $8.97
	2% buy The Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society (Random House Reader's Circle) 4.6 out of 5 stars (678) $7.70

The Shack (Special Hardcover Edition) (Hardcover)

Frequently Bought Together

Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought

Editorial Reviews

Product Details

What Do Customers Ultimately Buy After Viewing This Item?

Tags Customers Associate with This Product

Customer Reviews

Customer Discussions

Start a new discussion

Product Information from the Amapedia Community

Listmania!

So You'd Like to...

Look for Similar Items by Category

Transform Your Bathroom for Less

Big Savings in Books

Buy Three Books, Get a Fourth Free

Search for Sinks

Feedback

Where's My Stuff?

Shipping & Returns

Need Help?

Your Recent History