Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
8 of 8 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Classical Hatha Yoga - A WONDERFUL RESOURCE for the sincere yoga practitioner, January 26, 2008
This review is from: Classical Hatha Yoga (Hardcover)
Firstly, I'd like to say that this book is very nicely produced, with glossy heavyweight paper, clear printing of both text and colour plates, and an overall very substantial feel to the book. Occasionally, I have purchased books published in India, which are a little lacking in physical quality (though the content they conveyed was nonetheless excellent). Fortunately, I am happy to report that 'Classical Hatha Yoga' suffers no such shortcomings, materially-speaking, and gets two thumbs up, being well worth the asking price.
In terms of the content conveyed within, I am most impressed by this book. For example, the section discussing the fabled, and apparently oft-misunderstood, 'Khechari Mudra', is downright ASTONISHING.
NEVER before have I encountered a text that is so incredibly incisive and authoritative about this practice (not even BSY/YPT books, for which I have enormous respect). Though I would not presume to be fortunate enough to ever achieve such an advanced state in my humble lifetime, simply having so many misconceptions about the practice stripped away and replaced with a clear understanding (intellectually-confined, of course) has made this book worth several times its asking price, as far as this reader is concerned.
You'll have to read this section for yourself (I am not doing you a disservice by suggesting you buy the book rather than have me tell you for free, in this review - quite the contrary, I think when you have it in your own hands, you'll silently thank me for urging you to buy it. I am extremely confident that you will NOT regret making the investment). All I will say is that the author cuts straight to the heart of the matter, utterly-unflinchingly, and, having read more than a few well-respected texts encompassing the topic of khechari mudra, I was very pleasantly surprised at Swami Rajarshi Muni's detailed discussion and dissolution of many widely-propogated misconceptions on the matter. In fact, the anatomical details provided in this discussion, in specific relation to this yogic practice, have NEVER, so far as I am aware, been put into generally-available print, at ANY point in time. EVER. I studied the fundamentals of human neuropsychology and neuroanatomy as part of my psych degree, some years ago, and consequently I really appreciate the manner in which Swami Rajarshi Muni cuts through the nonsense and provides exact details of the structures involved and the means by which they are engaged during the mudra, yet managing to do so in such a manner that the vast majority of readers, regardless of educational background, would be able to broadly comprehend his explanation (though, owing to the forthrightness of the discussion, readers of a frail constitution would do well to sit or lie down before reading!). No dancing around the issue, no vague references to 'Eating Beef' (see 'Hatha Yoga Pradipika', 'Kriya Yoga: Its Mystery and Performing Art' by Swami Sadhanananda Giri, or any of several other books discussing khechari mudra in Traditional terms, otherwise-excellent though these books may be) etc. - just cold hard facts (the icing on the cake would have been for the author to include a clear anatomical diagram, but this is a small criticism and readers can access Harvard's on-line model of the human brain, for free - searching for, amongst other structures, the 'Sphenoid Sinus' - med.harvard.edu). Incidentally, if you're simply thinking 'nasal or sinus cavities', then you don't have anywhere near the whole story.
Furthermore, the comparison between 'spontaneous' and 'artificial' means of approaching Khechari Mudra is thoroughly illuminating (actually, on this point, Swami Rajarshi even appears to disagree with the discussion of Khechari Mudra in the BSY/YPT books, which really did come as a surprise to me) and the precise anatomical explanation has FINALLY enabled me to understand how amrit (nectar) from the pituitary gland can, in a very real manner, flow, as a consequence of influence by the tongue. Prior to reading 'Classical Hatha Yoga', I could find no way to reconcile what I'd read of amrit in the yogic texts, with my understanding of anatomy and neuroanatomy - the two standpoints just didn't 'fit' with each other into a coherent and logical process, so couched in vague analogies, 'smoke & mirrors' and lack of actual first-hand experience on the part of modern-day interpreters, were the numerous discussions of khechari mudra. I began to wonder whether the flow of amrit was actually real at all, or just some nebulous reference to an entirely-spiritual, rather than physical process. Not only has Swami Rajarshi made logical sense of my bewilderment, but, in so doing, he has made an esoteric aspect of Hatha yoga that bit less mythical and that bit more tangible. Whether or not I will ever reach such lofty heights as to experience full khechari mudra in this lifetime is not all that matters - every bit as important is simply the fact that one's inclination to pursue yoga as a viable path of spiritual unfoldment is dependent, to a considerable extent (and certainly, in the absence of a guru), on whether one holds to be true what is expounded in the literature on the subject - if one loses faith in the truth of what is written about yogic practices, then how is one to wholeheartedly pursue such a path? Let's face it, the closer certain yogic principles get to the realm of myth, the less one is inclined to believe in their reality or consequently to seek to pursue them in practice.
It is only fair to acknowledge that the author is at pains to point out that "Although the ancient yogis kept the real technique of khechari mudra a highly guarded secret, this author humbly ventures to disclose some of the details. The comments...are based on actual personal experience with the spontaneous manifestation of khechari mudra. The intention here is neither to violate the traditional code of secrecy nor to gain personal recognition. It is only to acquaint the reader with the difference between artificial and spontaneous, or true, khechari mudra."
Swami Rajarshi also responsibly cautions that "In the Yoga Kundali Upanishad it is advised : 'One should practice Khechari Mudra step by step, and not all at once. Whosoeverpractices this mudra with haste shall meet with destruction of his body' (II: 39). That aspirant is cautioned not to pick up threads of this narrative, or of any other, and try to artificially manipulate the muscles and bones described here in a zealous attempt to find the door to liberation. In all probability, such an attempt will prove fatal. Therefore, a genuine seeker is advised to learn the true spontaneous technique...from an experienced Guru or spiritual master."
However, despite the above words of caution, I note that perhaps the one thing that is missing from Swami Rajarshi's discussion of the topic is the mundane but (for householder sadhakas, at least) important issue of the practical side effects of severing the frenulum. Swami Niranjanananda points out, in his YPT book 'Yoga Darshan', that the normal processes of swallowing and speech are (irreversibly) negatively impacted as a direct consequence of severing the frenulum - i.e. the tongue becomes more difficult to control. Whether this would be less of an issue if severance occurs during early teenage years, when the brain retains a higher degree of neuroplasticity and thus, potentially, a greater ability to lay down neural pathways to compensate, I do not know for certain. (For example, with regard to language abilities - see Noam Chomsky, Eric Lenneberg etc. on 'critical period' theory of language acquisition, although their focus is primarily on cognitive aspects of language rather than motor skills of the tongue etc., the point here is that neuroplasticity of certain areas of the brain does appear to decline as adulthood is reached). Lest this sounds too tenuous, I should point out that Swami Muktibodhananda, in her commentary on Khechari Mudra, in 'Hatha Yoga Pradipika', does note that manual severence of the frenulum "is taught from an early age, twelve to sixteen years, during the period when the body is still developing". A further consideration is that Niranjanananda's and Muktibodhananda's discussions refer to artificial severence of the frenulum and it is just possible that there are subtle hidden factors that result in a different outcome for language and swallowing when the frenulum has been severed spontaneously, which might account for Swami Rajarshi's decision not to mention any such side-issues. In truth, though, I suspect the decision is probably more a reflection of his single-minded pursual of yoga for its true spiritual purpose; all practical, worldly, considerations thus being viewed as of distinctly secondary importance. If this is the case, it is quite understandable, since the claimed benefits of khechari mudra are so incredible as to make the tradeoff, remarkably, well worthwhile, if one seeks true Yoga (union). Personally, I am now acutely conscious of Swami Rajarshi's firm assertion that khechari mudra can (and, he claims, should) occur spontaneously. I say acutely conscious because now that I know it can occur spontaneously, this raises PROFOUND philosophical questions. If one considers the negative side effects as justification for arguing that khechari mudra must be unnatural and, in effect, a perversion of normal human anatomical processes, then WHY can it occur spontaneously? Furthermore, if you read the truly mind-blowing explanation of the neuroanatomical basis for the flow of amrit, you will find it is so utterly astonishing that it seems, to me at least, that there was DEFINITELY some kind of deliberate implementation of this potential in...
Read more ›
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Yoga and more..., October 20, 2008
This review is from: Classical Hatha Yoga (Hardcover)
First of all, there is already a HUGE review for this book & I agree with all of that. But here's where I add my opinion: This is a no-nonsense book written almost like a text / reference book. So if you are looking for a easy reading book, this is not it. On the other hand, if you are looking for a book that guides you as a serious Yoga student, then you are on right track. Go ahead and get it - You won't find another book like this.
The book is divided into many sections and the Asanas are grouped into various stages. This is done to allow each student to master each individual group separately and then progress to the next level. The yoga institute (in India) that he (the author) has reshaped follows the same approach. They teach you a set of asanas and theory behind those asana and let you master those. Once you pass the test on the asanas, you are allowed to go to the next level. This book follows similar structure however, it does not talk about mastering each stage before moving onto the next one. Along with each asana, the book describes the benefits of each asana as well as pitfalls. (Note that the Lotus position, very well known for meditation, should not be practiced for a long time without a guru's guidance. i.e. Don't use it for meditation if your sessions are beyond 5-minute range.)
The preliminary chapters talk about the 8 parts of yoga (Ashtanga Yoga) and what is necessary to get one out of the "Maya" of this world, out of the business of building bad karma. The author states that this is important for one's progress through yoga. One of the important aspects that Swami Rajarshi Muni has stressed on is "Mitahar" or eat sufficient and only as much as is needed for the body - no more.
All the talk about Khechari Mudra with that Huge Review is well described in the book. The Khechari Mudra is the ultimate mudra for a Yogi through which the "Divine Body" can be achieved. The author's other book: "Divine body through Yoga", talks about what the "Divine body" is and reasons why it must be possible. It is the ultimate goal for a Yogi. The author is the first one to talk about "Divine Body" with the intent of making it known to everyone outside of India and outside of those few reading sanskrit scriptures. It is another companion book you want to read to understand the "Divine Body" and why it should be an ultimate goal.
Another book also from the same author is "Infinite Grace", a must read if you want to know the path the author's Guru took and how the guru initiates Swami Rajarshi Muni into the next stage of yoga. This book would tell you what it takes to be a disciple in this lineage and what it means to be one.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
|