|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A testament to the universal appeal of music, March 21, 2003
This album is a testament to the universal appeal of music. You can't imagine two more different bands - in terms of geographical origin, philosophical outlook and musical disposition - than late-70s Pink Floyd and early-noughties Frog Brigade. And yet the Frog Brigade play Pink Floyd's album `Animals' live in its entirety, and something magical happens.Do the Frog Brigade even know what they're singing about on here? `Animals' is a terribly bleak album. Its three major songs are cruel dissections of 1970s British society, with lyrics penned by the miserabilist Roger Waters - `Dogs' is about mercenaries and tyrants, `Pigs (Three Different Ones)' is a portrait of three unsavoury figures in British public life, and `Sheep' is an awfully scathing, not to mention awfully patronising, attack on ordinary Joes. That's you and me, folks. The drab sepia picture of London's Battersea Power Station on the cover of `Animals' says it all (this picture is reproduced on the back cover of `Live Frogs Set 2', but with the inflatable pig next to Battersea Power Station irreverently replaced with an inflatable frog). The Frog Brigade, by contrast, are exuberant people, American through and through, who enjoy playing protracted jams wearing wacky costumes. And yet somehow, their rendition of `Animals' works. The Frog Brigade are clearly enormous fans of `Animals' (in the sleevenotes, Claypool touchingly recounts his first encounter with the album as a boy), and have worked hard to do justice to it. The vocals are passable, if workmanlike. But the playing is phenomenal - although even in this department, the band is careful not to overdo it. After the barnstorming version of Pink Floyd's `Shine On You Crazy Diamond' that closed `Live Frogs Set 1' (followed by Claypool's inimitable words `we'll be back in 20 minutes with more Pink Floyd than any human being should ever withstand'), I was looking forward to the Frog Brigade really stretching out on the `Animals' numbers. But they restrain themselves - oh well. The one song where the band does seem to let go a little, and undoubtedly the best song on the album, is `Pigs (Three Different Ones)', which has some awesome instrumental passages. (Again, reading Claypool's sleevenotes I discover that `Pigs (Three Different Ones)' is his favourite track on `Animals', so it makes sense that it would be the best performed.) What would be really nice would be if Pink Floyd fans who have never heard of Les Claypool - hell, if the actual members of Pink Floyd - buy this album simply because the prospect of `Animals' played live in its entirety by another band intrigues them. I'm certain they would love it.
|