Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
92 of 97 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
great quality and fantastic noise isolation, November 11, 2004
I've been using these for about 3 years - since I start using an IPod. I listen to huge range of music, all classical styles - from renaissance to atonal, all rock styles, jazz, funk and R&B, rap, brit pop, punk etc. I rarely walk out of the door with my fully loaded 40gig IPod, and these are what goes with them.
Sound Quality is superb, much better than Sony funtopias, and Bose noise cancelling (and don't get me started on the virtually useless Apple headphones). I haven't tried the Shures, so no comment on them. Not as good as my Sennheiser HD 600, but that's to be expected.
They are extremely clear, and revealing, and have great frequency balance across the range. Some complain that the bass is not good enough, and it could be better, but at least it's accurate, this may not matter to some, but flabby artificial bass just annoys me and just becomes fatiguing. The quality is so good its easy to get use to them, but when I temporarily started using the Sony's (having stepped on and broken the ER6s) and then came back to these I realised how good they are. No going back again for me!
Noise isolation is amazing, when I'm on the subway without them I get to (sadly) remember how noisy the subway is, I just don't notice it with these headphones on. I use them when I'm flying, and I did a back-to-back with the Bose and the ER6s blew them away, in both quality and noise isolation. I even get to sleep. Using this style of 'phones when flying or travelling on subways is a must.
Points to note: You do have to put these into the ear canal to use them effectively, and this takes some getting use to. There is some microphony from the cable which may be intrusive especially during very quiet music. Filters may need changing fairly often. I just scrap of the muck off the filter and they last much longer. I know it sound disgusting but it does work. They don't appear to be that well made, but mine (2nd pair) are still going and I don't treat them well at all (see previous)
If you want to go better, try the ER4Ps, they give even better bass and isolation (for twice the money), possibly the Shure equivalents or top end 'phones like the HD 600, but no noise isolation from these beauties!
|
|
|
72 of 75 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
The best portable headphones in their class, February 7, 2006
I bought these phones approximately 18 months ago when they cost 20% more than do today, and I never regretted the purchase. My upgrade path took me from the standard Sennheiser earbuds that were (at the time) bundled with various MP3 players including ones manufactured by MPIO, Rio, and Apple; then to a set of Sony in-ear headphones; then these Etymotics. I like the cheaper Sony's price and sound isolation, but not the asymmetric headphone cable or the boomy bass. The Etymotics brought even better sound isolation, smoother sound (with ample, if not accentuated bass) and better detail. For my buck, these headphones inhabit the sweet spot where improved sound quality/isolation begin to encounter the law of diminishing returns. I.e., the ER6 are a lot more of an improvement over the Sony in-ear phones, or stock earbuds, than the Etymotic ER4 or Shure E4c/5c are over the ER6's.
Sound isolation with the ER6 is extremly good -- I use mine daily on Chicago's mass transit system (buses and subways) and routinely for airplane flights. Notwithstanding the soundproof fit, they are comfortable to wear. I haven't experienced sore or uncomfortable ears using the Etymotics, even on long transatlantic flights.
These are not the best choice for working out because the cables rub against your clothes and transmit vibrations as sound right into your ear. In practice, when walking or commuting you can easily drape the cables in a way where this doesn't occur. But running around, leaning up and down, and changing positions frequently, I don't think you could escape the issue entirely. In that case, I'd hypothesize you might want in-ear headphones that drape over the back of the earlobe, which might prevent this from happening.
I couldn't help noticing that a small number of people have suddenly posted strongly negative reviews of these headphones, making implausibly strong claims about how bad they allegedly sound, lacking bass, or falling out of their ears despite the reviewer's claim that s/he inserted the according to directions. These reviews are so far against the manifest weight of numerous other reviews (and, more importantly, my personal experience) that I simply cannot fathom how any of these 1-star reviews have a basis in reality. The ER6 is not hard to use, not hard to insert, and does not produce bad sound, as tons of independent reviewers agree. Maybe, despite their belief to the contrary, these reviewers aren't doing as good a job reading the instructions as they think they are?
My last comment relates to a few people out there who seem to think that you need an external portable headphone amplifier to make these things really sound good. To that, I have a three word reply: "hogwash" and "snake oil". I tried a popular external amp with these phones, and after extensive testing (and single-blind testing with my wife to ensure I hadn't suddenly gone deaf) concluded that they make no audible difference, on any genre of music I own from classical to hip hop to alternative, on any bitrates from 160 to lossless. So save your money, save some space, and just jack the Etymotics right into your portable player. If you want more than that, go buy a higher model headphone; don't think that an amp will make any difference beyond the placebo effect.
|
|
|
90 of 96 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Love the product, hate the lifespan, March 22, 2006
Over the past three years, I've owned several pairs of Etymotic ER-6s.
I won't try to sway you on their sound quality; some people love them, others don't. I've never had a complaint in that regard. The customer service I've received from the company has been consistently exemplary.
They do have one fatal flaw, and it's the reason I've stopped using them. Unlike the more expensive ER-4s, they're too small to remove from your ear without pulling a bit on the cable.
If you use your ER-6s daily, this cable strain will destroy them within a year or so. In effect, you're not buying a set of earphones, but a subscription that you'll have to renew almost annually with an expensive replacement pair. Unlike Shure, Etymotic charges nearly the full retail price (about $80) for an out-of-warranty replacement.
So, as much as I've enjoyed my ER-6s, I'm afraid I can't recommend them here until Etymotic fixes this design flaw.
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|