Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
12 of 12 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Essential reissue for Cure enthusiasts, April 26, 2005
Out of all of the three Cure reissues, I would go as far as to say that the 'Seventeen Seconds' one has the most improved sound quality versus the original cd issue, but lacks the most in the bonus material (despite the Cult Hero single being present).
The original album now has a slightly more "spacious" quality to it that the last cd issue lacked. 'A Forest' sounds absolutely brilliant. In my opinion, this remaster revealed the most. The short instrumental tracks are much clearer and the vocals more distant and ethereal. Where the 'Pornography' reissue reinforced the sonic density of its original production, the 'Seventeen Seconds' reissue reinforces the dry, spare quality to its production.
The rarities material, however, and despite the obscure and quite cool Cult Hero material, doesn't quite live up to the 'Faith' and 'Pornography' reissues. Having the Cult Hero single is definitely the highlight of portion of the set.
Overall, this is still an essential package, with great artwork, much improved sound quality, and a few essential goodies on the rarities disc.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
10 of 10 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Wrapped up in perfect cover art, May 5, 2005
This is an awesome, moody little album that fits right in today with the slew of bands going after the early-80s 'post-punk' sound. This disc marks the first of a masterful trilogy that continues with Faith and Pornography.
The Cure are famous for being gloomy, and this album backs it up, but it's not heavy or depressing and it never gets to be too much. Quite the opposite. Some songs are slower, like In Your House, while other like Play For Today (the first track after the instrumental opening) open up with an electronic calling in the back and a punchy little rhythm, immediately catchy, and the perfect length. Three, meanwhile, has the feeling of a dark jingle. At Night has a slow, fuzzy opening and a steady beat, sounding a little like a dark Police. The classic track A Forest sounds even richer in the remastered format. There's the classic Cure guitar, the bobbing basslines, some swishy help from the keyboards in the background to lend that gray atmosphere...it sounds like 1980, it's spot-on. The whole trilogy is accompanied by perfect album art--they each sound like the covers. A wash of muted colors on what looks like a blurry windshield here, to the mysterious gray, faint scribbling of Faith, to the tortured Scream-like cover of Pornography.
An addictive album of good songs, with Smith's voice never overbearing, nor never too much whining, and some very fine singing. Pornography would bring the band to a darker place, with its far more depressed quality. Seventeen Seconds is getting there, but it's minor-key pop with some very good production. Cure addicts may break it down more in terms of band lineups, but I find the whole release an excellent effort.
Quite frankly, better than most of the bands out there who were in diapers when this was released, you may as well check out the original thing. And at 30-odd minutes, it's the old style of complete, quality beginning-to-end albums perfect for a slow day at home, preferably in the middle of the week when it's raining.
The new Cure remastereds are excellent, a real value for fans. For one, the sound is vastly improved--just compare any track on here, but especially 'A Forest', with your old AAD disc--big difference. The bass is bigger, punchier, the sounds are all clearer and brought up front. The older, unremastered rock albums really do suffer with the original CD format--everything is flattened right out to the middle, while the new discs bring much-needed oomph to everything. The second disc is full of goodies, from demos to live versions of nearly the entire album in great sound quality. And of course, nice liner notes with actual notes, old pictures, the whole job. Quality re-release in this era of downloading, however, it must be said that these sets are BIT on the pricey side, but will likely be a must for fans of this album (and the following two).
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
25 of 31 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A Wonderful Deluxe Edition, Cure fans should be pleased!, April 26, 2005
It is SO incredibly awesome that Rhino and Fiction records worked together to remaster and reissue this classic album from The Cure. Seventeen Seconds was released in 1980--before The Cure were huge and before Robert Smith had long hair and really into the makeup thing. The look may have been different but this is the sound of The Cure that their fans have grown to love and the fact that these songs have been remastered and re-packaged is totally awesome. Track number 3, "Secrets," is classic Cure with the guitar and basslines. The lyrics are sparse but the song will speak to you. "Secrets," is followed up by "In Your House," another musically driven piece. The way that the songs breaks down into the bridge is classic Cure. If you didn't get into The Cure until their later releases, you should really pick up Seventeen Seconds.
The original 1980 release contained 10 songs. The remastered reissue not only features these songs, but disc two includes 15 rarities recorded between 1979 and 1980. All of these songs are great. The CD packaging is wonderful and the set includes a color booklet that has lyrics, pictures from that time period and a forward by Johnny Black.
I hope you find this review helpful. I was 5 years old in 1980 and didn't really get into The Cure until "Just Like Heaven," so I have really enjoyed going back in time and rediscovering all of their classic hits.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|