Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
76 of 80 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
My second Garmin GPS: Extremely good, but missing lower-end features., September 13, 2006
This review is from: Garmin StreetPilot 2820 5.6-Inch Bluetooth Portable GPS Navigator (Electronics)
(EDIT 12-19-2006: If you're looking at the 2820, unless you drive a motorcycle I strongly recommend the StreetPilot c550 which I've also reviewed. Read this review and then compare it to the c550.)
This is the second Garmin product I've purchased, the first being a StreetPilot C320 for my mother which I've also used extensively. (I've reviewed the C320 also. Most of the good things I pointed out in that review also apply here, so read that one if you want more details than what I give here.) This one was purchased for myself and my wife to use in our new car. (New toys! Hooray!)
The unit itself is pretty solid, measuring about the size of an oversized Stephen King novel, weighing about a pound and having a large widescreen-format touchscreen with four (backlit) rubberized buttons to the right of the screen. A power switch is on the right side, ports for microphone-in and audio-out are on the left side, and a mini USB port is on the back. The screen and buttons automatically adjust their brightness depending on the ambient light (the more light there is the brighter they get), but you can override the brightness levels manually.
One big disappointment was the lack of a built-in microphone and speaker, although Garmin includes a wired microphone that is surprisingly sensitive. Considering that both a microphone and the GPS would need to be within line of sight of the driver it doesn't make sense that Garmin didn't integrate the microphone right into the unit. The speaker is even more unusual; it's actually attached to the plug that goes into the cigarette lighter. So if your car has an awkwardly positioned cigarette lighter you'll find the audio coming out from an unusual angle. The fact that my mother's C320 (which cost less than half) has a built-in speaker while the 2820 does not is a further disappointment.
The unit truly is a plug-and-play affair. Setup is this: Take the unit, the power cord, and the mounting base (more on that in a moment) out of the box. Position the unit on your car's dashboard. Plug in the power cord to your car's cigarette lighter outlet. Turn on the unit. That's it -- done and ready to go. Provided you've got a reasonably clear view of the sky it'll take about 10-15 seconds for the GPS to locate itself, after which you'll have full functionality.
Installation caveats: As with all GPS systems you'll need to position the GPS in an area where it can get a clear view of the sky as the antenna is internal. (External antennas are available.) Garmin includes a weighted "pad" with a high-friction base that securely holds the unit onto the dash. They also provide a means of "permanently" mounting the unit onto the dash via an adhesive disc. I used the weighted pad and have no problems with it.
For gadget geeks like me, you'll want to connect the unit to your Windows PC (via USB) and download Garmin's WebUpdater application. This will update the software in the unit. Mine required about 15-20 updates, including a multitude of voice updates as well as a couple of "system" updates. I therefore strongly recommend you download and use Garmin's WebUpdater (which, incidentally, works on all Garmin products with USB interfaces).
So, how does it work? Garmin's interface is very smooth and polished. It's not perfect and you will sometimes find yourself getting lost in the multitide of menus and functions, but for most of your navigation needs you'll never notice this. You'll be using perhaps 15% of the menus 90% of the time and that 15% is very easy to work with. The navigation process is clear, concise and accurate. As an experiment I went through the same intersection several times and the 2820 announced the upcoming turn at virtually the same exact point, so it's definitely got some accurate positioning happening.
The unit offers a "traditional" 2D GPS perspective (where you're looking straight down onto a map of the surrounding area, with your vehicle positioned in the center of the map) or a pseudo-3D perspective (where the map is angled and you're looking down and forward from above the car's position on the map). I find the 3D perspective to be more interesting and Garmin seems to agree since that view is the default. Unlike the C320, the 2820 will zoom out depending on how far you need to go. For example, if you're traveling 10 miles on a highway the 2820 will zoom the view out to show you more of the surrounding area including points of interest, if applicable. As you approach your turn the 2820 will zoom in to closer detail so you don't miss the turn (you can also manually override this function and zoom in to whatever setting you want). In contrast, the C320 maintains its zoom level at whatever the user specifies.
Audio quality is very good, much improved over my mother's C320 and there's even support for multiple languages (so, yeah, it'll talk to you in Spanish or any of a dozen other languages.) There are three "American English" voices. One is dubbed "Jack", the second "Jill", and the third is unnamed. The "Jill" (female) voice is similar to the voice on the C320 and is the default choice for the 2820. The "Jack" (male) voice is somewhat easier to understand (versus Jill) but the unnamed (female) voice is inarguably the best of them. However, with this clarity comes a trade-off; using the unnamed voice will cause the 2820 to use generic directions ("turn left", "in 500 feet keep right") while using the "Jack" or "Jill" voice will cause the 2820 to call out street names and exit numbers. The reason for this is because the unnamed voice is really little more than a collection of sampled audio that the 2820 strings together appropriately, while "Jack" and "Jill" are a combination of sampled audio and computer-generated speech, thus allowing the unit to call out proper names and numbers when applicable.
There's a phenominal amount of data on this thing. I was particularly surprised by its airport options; not only will it guide you to the airport, but it will also guide you to the appropriate terminal or drop-off/pick-up area. There's also an extensive points-of-interest guide; tell the GPS what you want and it will tell you what's closest and guide you there with aplomb. Map accuracy is exceptional. It doesn't always take me via the route I expect to go or I'm used to going but it always gets me to my destination. I recently took this unit with me to DisneyWorld in Orlando and it successfully plotted dozens of locations for me, both on and off DisneyWorld property. It even recognizes DisneyWorld restaurants in at least four resorts and will guide you there accurately.
I selected the 2820 for its other features as well. The hands-free Bluetooth function works fine. After pairing it with a Treo 650 I was able to send and receive calls through the Garmin unit.
The 2820 also has the ability to receive XM satellite radio and XM's dynamic traffic system, "XM NavTraffic", which will reroute your path to avoid traffic congestion. This requires an XM subscription which I don't have (I'm a Sirius guy) so I was unable to test this.
You can also connect the 2820 to an optional FM TMC traffic receiver which, in areas that support the technology (mainly large cities like Manhattan), will also dynamically reroute your path. This is a less expensive option than the XM system but, again, I have not (yet) installed this so I cannot test it.
One particular item of note: The C320 has one significant shortcoming, and that is the screen tends to get washed out in anything resembling sunlight. I actually had to fabricate a small plastic hood for the C320 to make it visible and therefore more useful. I am happy to say that the 2820 has a significantly better screen. I had it on the dashboard of a PT Cruiser convertible, with the top down, at high noon, in the middle of Florida, on a bright and sunny 90 degree day and had absolutely no problems viewing the screen. The C320 (without the hood) would have shown me a vague blur in a similar situation.
So, overall this is a very positive review. So why only two stars? Several reasons, most of which having to do with comparing the 2820 to the lower-end products like the C320. First, the omission of a built-in speaker and microphone. The fact that Garmin's lower-priced systems has a speaker and the higher-priced systems do not is inexcusable, and the logic behind the external microphone eludes me. I am also removing a star for the other "nickel-and-dime" things. For example, the C320 includes a suction cup mounting for the windshield which is very convenient; the 2820 does not. The C320 has a built-in rechargeable battery good for about four hours which makes it invaluable if you're ever stranded on the side of the road in the middle of nowhere; the 2820 has no battery. Combined the entire package is a little nonsensical; it's like getting a full stereo w/CD player as standard equipment in a Kia, but not even offering it as an option in a Mercedes-Benz. I am also taking a full star off for Garmin's failure to respond to two pre-sale and one post-sale email I sent to them. There is absolutely no excuse for lackluster customer support.
On the other hand, it could fairly be said that I'm not giving credit where credit is due. After all, the 2820 has excellent directions, a very good screen, a ton of preprogrammed locations and a host of additional features like the XM satellite radio connection. To that I say: So what? Any GPS worth anything will have excellent directions, a good screen, and tons of preprogrammed locations so crediting the 2820 for something that it should have just by its very nature is kind of silly. As for the additional features, yeah, you're probably right, but since I'm not actually using many of those additional features I can't rightfully praise the 2820 for having them.
So, is this a good GPS? Yes, one of Garmin's best. But there's a lot of room for improvement and if you don't need the Bluetooth, XM satellite, and/or TMC traffic functions there are much less expensive Garmin units that offer better value.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
 
|
|
|
|
|
|
31 of 36 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great portable unit, but in hindsight, the smaller square models are best, October 10, 2006
This review is from: Garmin StreetPilot 2820 5.6-Inch Bluetooth Portable GPS Navigator (Electronics)
The sound is clear and it even has an audio out jack for my auxiliary input jack of my stereo. So, if I'm *really* paranoid about missing audio cues when I'm driving, I don't miss them now. Alternatively, if you pair it with a bluetooth headset, you should be able to get the same in ear (of course you could also use the audio out for regular headphones while driving, say one earbud in, if you wanted).
The interface is very logical and anticipates what you want reasonably well. The navigation at a couple of weird spots in Toronto was a bit disappointing. Don't know whether to attribute to less attention to the Canadian map data or just a sampling anomaly. For example, I punched in a Wynford drive address (cultural centre) and after it took me off the DVP, it didn't tell me to turn onto a crucial cross street (was highly unintuitive at night) to actually get to the entrance of the destination. I'm used to these things generally routing you right to the front door.
Conversely, going to a friends new condo in Downsview, everything was perfect and I got right to the front entrance.
The thing with the 2820 is that like with most of these portable units, I don't leave it on the dash ready to use, b/c it's of course, more of a theft target, alarm notwithstanding. So I wrap it up in a little sports bag and whip it out when I need nav help. It's too big for the glove box (unless you have a really big glove box with nothing else in it). Often, I'll leave the GPS in the trunk so there's less for wandering eyes to wonder about. I really wish I had a unit built into the vehicle I didn't have to fold away, unplug etc.
Really, these units are best for travelers. In one's main car, I'd recommend going to the mobile audio/nav specialty shop and installing something.
While my 2820 has a bigger display than the Garmin ones with the "c" prefix (the smaller square shaped ones), I noticed that the extra screen space is mostly used for extra stats like distance to destination, ETA, current speed etc. In hindsight, the smaller "c" models that you can shove in your glovebox with effectively the same map display area, are probably better. That is - if it's going to be portable than make it fit in your glove box - otherwise - go with a properly installed permanent device.
Having used the device, I realized my concerns about a slightly larger screen size than the "c" models provide, was unfounded. Perhaps there's a mode I can set mine to to take up the full screen, sans the stats. It would be of negligible impact however. The audio cues and a quick glance over seem to really be all that one needs - even with a smaller model.
My 2820 is definitely a solid piece of technology and it does the job. It'll always get me in the area, if not to the doorstep of where I need to go. I've not used the "places of interest" and other such look ups, but my brother in law and cousin have the smaller Garmin units that do this as well, and they've been happy with those functions.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
11 of 11 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
garmin street pilot 2820, January 27, 2007
This review is from: Garmin StreetPilot 2820 5.6-Inch Bluetooth Portable GPS Navigator (Electronics)
Let me start by saying the 2820 is a complete and terrific GPS however if you already own a Garmin 2720, 2620 or any other model with pre-loaded maps don't bother investing in the 2820. I own a 2620 and thought the traffic warning and blue tooth was worth the upgrade. Well as they say in Joisey "fuhgetaboutit". First you need to purchase an extra antenna at about $230,the traffic alert requires an extra XM radio subscription at $13 a month and once you sign up you will find out that the service is only available in limited areas. The blue tooth doesn't work with most cell phones out there (although the very newest ones will) and the 3D screen is not worth the expense of upgrading. Let me say further that I don't blame garmin, I blame myself for not researching better. The information was out there and if I did my homework I would still be using my 2620. If you do not own a GPS do not let this information give you a bad image of Garmin. In my opinion you CAN NOT OWN A BETTER PRODUCT!
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
Saving...
