Customer Reviews

The keys of the kingdom

5 star:		(25)
4 star:		(3)
3 star:		(2)
2 star:		(0)
1 star:		(0)

 

 

The first Cronin work I read was "The Citadel," just because it was a medical theme, which interests me, & it came in an auction box lot but was in too poor condition to be able to sell, but I couldn't bear to throw it out without reading it first. I'm very glad I did, as I now have a new author to search out all of his books to read.

"The Keys of the Kingdom" I read solely because I saw it was A.J. Cronin & had liked "The Citadel" so much, and again came in an auction box lot but was in poor condition but because of the author I decided to read it before giving it away. I have no interest in Catholicism, & so was surprised at how much I still got totally absorbed in the story. That is a real tribute to the author's writing ability! It was the kind of story that made my surroundings disappear, made me lose all track of time, & kept me reading when I should have been doing other things.

While he uses some words I'm not familiar with because they're Scottish or British or no longer used or about "priestly" items, I found I could just skip right over them & not interrupt the flow of the story to go to the dictionary, & I still understood everything that was going on. (e.g. I could figure out that the word was something he was wearing, I just didn't know exactly what it looked like. A nice detail to picture if you know the word, but no loss to the important parts of the story line if you don't.)

I think what makes Cronin most absorbing for me is that he makes his characters so full-dimensional. They're complex HUMAN beings, with faults & foibles & weaknesses & anxieties. Cronin's characters have an INNER life--you're privvy to their thoughts & feelings, not just their actions.

What's most memorable about this story to me was the way the main character was so perfectly humble that he really didn't grasp just how good he really was at following the PRINCIPLES of his religion & his personal convictions. He unfortunately kept measuring himself against the criticism of his "superiors." It seems to me Chisholm represented the SUBSTANCE of Christian faith & sincerely trying to follow Christ's example, vs most of his "superiors" who seemed to be into APPEARANCES (e.g. Paying Chinese to come to their church so they could claim to have "converted" thousands.) I think even if you're an atheist you'd find Chisholm's character interesting as one who felt strongly about his credo/ethics/beliefs & sincerely tried to stick to them--& succeeded better than he realized. In one sense it's rather sad that in spite of all he did he's left feeling like he's been an utter failure, but then again it's that lack of awareness of his own goodness that enabled him to win the admiration & loyalty of so many people, including some who started out dead set against him. (A perfect example of the complexity of the characters Cronin creates!)

It is amazing how A. J. Cronin, under the guise of a simple tale of one humble priest, weaves a complex picture of varied matters related to faith - and, in the process, unfolds a frank and intriguing look at viewpoints and problems within the Catholic Church. Francis, the main character, is far from being a theologian - he accepts his priestly vocation and then just lives it. (That sounds simple - but it is a rare approach.) Yet his questions about doctrine, authority, and the like, never defiant but born of true confusion about intolerance, are those which have haunted many a devout believer.

It could be difficult today for new readers to grasp the hateful prejudice which gripped many Protestants and Catholics in Scotland of the era. As one example of the insight Cronin expresses in the character of Francis, the question, as a seminarian, of why creed would determine salvation when it was usually an accident of birth, was pressing and unanswered.

Those who have a pretty picture of the seeming calm within the pre-conciliar church would do well to see the frank honesty which Cronin employs in this tale. Characters include a vain and self-centred bishop; a young woman who apparently commits suicide to avoid being forced into a marriage after incest causes a pregnancy; an hysteric who convinces herself that she has seen a vision of Mary; a religious superior who burns with pride and haughtiness. There is no bitterness or ugliness in Cronin's portrayal, but there is a vivid picture of the complexity of human nature and of faith.

Cronin is unhesitatingly realistic about the 'rice Christian' approaches which were not uncommon during the period. Of course, Francis' luck is a bit over the top - yet the message comes through that the Chinese would respect a man of honour even if they could not embrace his faith.

I would highly recommend this book from both a literary and historical perspective.

What can one say about AJ Cronin's writing that hasn't already been said? He is a master craftsman who propels the reader along with mounting desire to see what happens next. He glorifies the human spirit and adds wings to our hearts. The moral he teaches is simple. Live for the betterment of your fellowman, despite religion, caste, race or ethnic origin and you will attain heaven and perhaps make one for yourself right here on earth. This novel was originally published in 1941 yet it speaks to the soul of mankind for all ages. The movie starring Gregory Peck (1944) won Peck an academy award nomination in only his second movie. It has become a much-loved classic among Catholics. Archibald Joseph Cronin died in 1981. I wish I could have known him. I was brought up Catholic but unfortunately those I came in contact with never demonstrated the sweetness and courage of Father Chisholm. I had the misfortune of meeting several that were not unlike Bishop Mealey. Unlike The Citadel, which moved me to tears numerous times, this novel only provoked three such moments but still they were wonderful moments. If you wonder what Catholicism is supposed to be all about or just want an affirmation of your own faith this is the novel for you.

I've been an admirer of A.J. Cronin since I was a teenager in the early 1960's. He was an author who knew the meaning of his craft. Starting with Hatter's Castle in the early 1930's and concluding many books later in the 1970's, Cronin just kept improving and expanding as a writer.

The Keys to the Kingdom is one of my favorites of his works. It is the story of Francis Chisholm, son of Alec Chisholm a Catholic in Presbyterian Scotland. Francis is orphaned at a young age when his father and mother are killed in a wave of anti-Catholicism. After his boyhood love commits suicide, young Francis decides to be a priest.

His vocation is an example of humility, love, compassion and tolerance--virtues which are contrasted with the worldliness and superficiality of the ambitious clergyman, Anselm Mealy. Cronin is a master at portraying the character of Scottish people whom he loves in spite of his succint insight and commentary on their faults and foibles.

I highly recommend this book to those who want to know more about Catholicism at its best.

AJ Cronin (author of Citadel and Hatters Castle), tells the story of a Catholic Missionary to China. If you're not Catholic and, therefore, think this book is not for you, guess again. Father Francis Chisholm is an exemplary Christian of any genre. Though he faces trial, tribulation and persecution from early childhood through late adulthood, he stands firm and unwavering in his faith. As is always the case, AJ Cronin makes his characters come alive right off the page.

I first read this AJ Cronin novel some 30+ years ago. While pondering what book I should read next I happened to pull this one out of my bookcase. I remembered liking the book so I gave it another read. And like a fine wine I found that it has much improved with age.

Author AJ Cronin tells a wonderfully moving and inspiring story of a young Scottish priest who sets out to China and spends the better part of his life overcoming many hardships to establish a Catholic mission there. Father Chisholm is a protagonist to be admired by both secular and non-secular readers because he is a man who dedicates his life to a faith and to a cause and achieves not by doctrine but through personal example. This culminates in a very moving passage which should be left to those who have not yet read book to enjoy.

"The Keys of the Kingdom" is still a 5-star read after all these years.

I purchased this book on the cheap not knowing a thing about A.J. Cronin. Reading the back, seeing the "Christian" theme, I decided to give it a try (it was on the clearence table!).

Grabbed from the first few pages, one can't help but feel for poor Francis as he struggles through his emotional and tumultous childhood, discovering his faith and ultimately landing in China to rekindle the flame of a forgotten mission. Through the story he meets various characters: the local militia, outcast roughians, the tender and vulnerable Chinese people, Catholic hiarchy and a few friends...

Francis remains true to Scripture (with one notable exception) and his vocation by being pious, and living in only very minor indulgences. He lives for the God, the mission and for the Chinese people, often to his own detriment, leading the way by his example.

A great read...a treasure that I "just" picked up...

It's puzzling that Loyola Press choose to print Joseph Bottum's preface to The Keys to the Kingdom. After reading his preface, I almost returned the book to Amazon. Thankfully, I didn't because I loved reading this story.

I disagree with Mr. Bottum on three points:

1- The Keys to the Kingdom was not written by a "hack." Cronin was clearly inspired by an ideal, not money. The fact that Loyola Press reprinted it seventy years later as a "classic" contradicts Mr. Bottum's opinion.

2- The thoughts of the main character may not be "deep," but any philosophy Francis voices is less important than how he lives his life.

3- I did not see the "unique Christian faith" that Bottum claims "shines through" the story. Then again, despite the many examples of less admirable clerics, both Protestant and Catholic, I did not think that Christianity was denigrated.

Many things happen in Father Francis Chisolm's life, he encounters many different kinds of people, and he faces many challenges. However, the most engaging aspect of the book, for me, was the mystery of his character. Was he simply born a good person? What was the source of his goodness? Was his humility a virtue and did it help or hinder him? (I also wonder about the ways various people responded to him, but to say more would spoil the story for you.)

Each of the characters could easily have belonged to any religion. I didn't feel that I was reading Catholic novel. Cronin rarely points out specific ideas that propel the less admirable characters ("do this or be damned" or "have you been saved") and never explains what guides Father Francis, the Fiskes, Mr. Chia, or Lieutenant Shon. I don't know if that makes this a good book or a poor one, but it made me think and wonder.

Joseph Bottum is right in asserting that "When Cronin sets down what he clearly imagines are the profound spiritual revelations of his novel they turn out to be little more than pious uplift, along the lines of 'Why can't we all just get along?' and 'Aren't all the religions really saying the same thing?'" Although described disdainfully, those do seem to be Cronin's ideals. However this is not a naive story and Francis is not a weak person. He is strong and admirable and I wonder at his ability to walk through his difficult life without losing his love or faith.

While I would like to criticize the fact that Cronin does not apologize for the impulse to send missions to China (or to convert an atheist Scotsman), I can't. This book isn't an attempt to promote a particular doctrine; it's not even about China or missionaries. It's about a good man who should be, and sometimes is, an example others emulate.

It is a sweet story.

I read this book in 1997 and it quickly took its place as my favorite book that year. I have given it as a gift for countless birthdays and holidays. You need a Scottish dictionary for the first few chapters but it's truly wonderful. Don't bother with the movie, despite the presence of the wonderful Gregory Peck, it doesn't come anywhere NEAR doing justice to the book.

A truly great work. The tale of an early Christian missionary in China through which the meaning of true faith, compassion and tolerance is revealed. Beautifully written and inspiring, the novel also stands as a quiet indictment of religious institutions and hierarchies