All the ones with 1 star are for Harry Potter Wizard's Collection and all the ones with 4 or 5 stars are for the 8 disc set. Only teasing. Well, actually it is almost true. However, I'm one of the few people who pre-ordered the Wizard's Collection (yes, expensive, but i've held off buying any other bluray (or recent dvd) knowing that a set like this would come out) and find it strange they combined reviews for this as the products are completely different. Not like some type of electronics device where just the color is different or something. Includes completely different things. It is misleading (both for the 31 disc set and for the 8 disc set).
(I do not agree with the 1 star reviews, I just find it funny that you basically can separate the reviews based on the number of stars)
Ryan, you make an interesting point about the 1 star vs. 5 star reviews. With 900+ reviews to slog through (due to Amazon's laziness for not separating 2 very different products), I had not begun to pick up on that general trend. I am not a huge HP fan (I've never read the books), but I did buy my niece's 'collection' on DVD (as she upgraded to the Blu-Ray 8 pack last fall and she loves it). Anyhow, I agree also that merging the reviews makes it much more difficult to sort through all the opinions. Your comment was very useful though, and has given me some guidance on how to sort through those reviews. Thank you for your insight.
It's not laziness. They were separate until about a week ago. They combined the reviews in a cheap obvious ploy to disguise the negative reviews and ratings. It is a very sorry ill-conceived move which is a blow to their credibility and puts their integrity in question. I say this as someone who has had the Wizard's collection on pre-order since March, and feel the one-star reviews are misguided. I do understand the emotion behind them from those who loyally collected the Ultimate editions since the beginning.
It's a shame because the 1-star Wizard's Collection reviews are bringing down the rating of the 8-disc sets. Those sets are fairly priced and you know what you're getting. Now their ratings dropped a few stars because they merged it with the sinking stone that is the WC.
It looks like they've listened and have again separated the reviews. I understand combining them for some things, but the blu-ray wizard's collection is completely different than the 8-disc blu-ray boxed set that it didn't make any sense to combine.