The Hidden History of Women's Ordination: Female Clergy in the Medieval West (Hardcover)

+

+

Price For All Three: $63.92

Show availability and shipping details

• This item: The Hidden History of Women's Ordination: Female Clergy in the Medieval West by Gary Macy

  In Stock.
  Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
  Eligible for FREE Super Saver Shipping on orders over $25. Details
  

• When Women Were Priests: Women's Leadership in the Early Church and the Scandal of Their Subordination in by Karen J. Torjesen

  In Stock.
  Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
  Eligible for FREE Super Saver Shipping on orders over $25. Details
  

• Ordained Women in the Early Church: A Documentary History by Kevin Madigan

  In Stock.
  Ships from and sold by Amazon.com.
  This item ships for FREE with Super Saver Shipping. Details
  

What Happened at Vatican II by John W. O'Malley 5.0 out of 5 stars (5)  $19.77

The Church: The Evolution of Catholicism by Richard P. Mcbrien 3.6 out of 5 stars (7)  $22.76

Confronting Power and Sex in the Catholic Church by Bishop Geoffrey Robinson 5.0 out of 5 stars (17)  $18.96

Quest for the Living God: Mapping Frontiers in the Theology of God by Elizabeth A. Johnson 4.7 out of 5 stars (12)  $17.96

Ordained Women in the Early Church: A Documentary History by Kevin Madigan $33.75

› Explore similar items

Review

"Here is a truly groundbreaking book, essential reading for anyone interested in the complex story of how the ministry of women has been valued (and devalued) within the Christian church. Gary Macy convincingly demonstrates that in the early church women were ordained into various roles, but in the eleventh and twelfth centuries a new definition of ordination was rigorously applied, which served to exclude them. This study is of crucial importance not only for an understanding of the development of medieval Christianity but also for the material it brings to contemporary debate on the ordination of women." --Alistair Minnis, Yale University
"The Hidden History provides a revelatory synthesis of the evidence for women's ordination in the late antique and early medieval church in addition to tracing the process of its occlusion in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries. With admirable clarity and compelling detail, Macy reveals fundamental changes in western understandings of ordination and suggestively explores their ecclesiological implications. This book is essential reading for medieval ecclesiastical historians, illuminating a profound transformation in the western church and its clergy." --Maureen C. Miller, author of The Bishop's Palace: Architecture and Authority in Medieval Italy
"In a clear narrative, supported by massive scholarly evidence, Macy had revealed a lost component of first millennium Christianity that should serve as an inspiration for the churches of the third millennium." --Jo Ann Kay McNamara, author of Sisters in Arms
"This is an important book that brings together and makes sense of a series of recent findings about the history of women's ordination. ...The book is beautifully produced and will change how we teach and think about the medieval church." --Church History


Product Description
The Roman Catholic leadership still refuses to ordain women officially or even to recognize that women are capable of ordination. But is the widely held assumption that women have always been excluded from such roles historically accurate?
In the early centuries of Christianity, ordination was the process and the ceremony by which one moved to any new ministry (ordo) in the community. By this definition, women were in fact ordained into several ministries. A radical change in the definition of ordination during the eleventh and twelfth centuries not only removed women from the ordained ministry, but also attempted to eradicate any memory of women's ordination in the past. The debate that accompanied this change has left its mark in the literature of the time. However, the triumph of a new definition of ordination as the bestowal of power, particularly the power to confect the Eucharist, so thoroughly dominated western thought and practice by the thirteenth century that the earlier concept of ordination was almost completely erased. The ordination of women, either in the present or in the past, became unthinkable.
References to the ordination of women exist in papal, episcopal and theological documents of the time, and the rites for these ordinations have survived. Yet, many scholars still hold that women, particularly in the western church, were never "really" ordained. A survey of the literature reveals that most scholars use a definition of ordination that would have been unknown in the early middle ages. Thus, the modern determination that women were never ordained, Macy argues, is a premise based on false terms.
Not a work of advocacy, this important book applies indispensable historical background for the ongoing debate about women's ordination.

See all Editorial Reviews

Key Phrases - Statistically Improbable Phrases (SIPs): (learn more)
true sacramental ordination, true ordination, ordained women, called deaconesses, ordination rites, valid ordination Key Phrases - Capitalized Phrases (CAPs): (learn more)
Middle Ages, Lord's Prayer, Western Christianity, Council of Benevento, Roman Church, Roman Catholic Church, Pope Gregory, School of Laon, Sentences of Peter the Lombard, Holy Spirit, Gregory the Great, Pope Leo, First Letter, Sicard of Cremona, Gregory of Tours, Apostolic Constitutions, Yves Congar, Eastern Church, Pope Zachary, Sidonius Apollinaris, Raymond of Peñafort, John Beleth, Philip of Harvengt, Alexander of Hales, Pope Urban Browse Sample Pages:
Front Cover | Table of Contents | First Pages | Index | Surprise Me!

Search Inside This Book:

If you are a publisher or author and hold the digital rights to a book, you can sell a digital version of it in our Kindle Store. Learn more

5 Reviews 5 star:  (4) 4 star:  (1) 3 star:    (0) 2 star:    (0) 1 star:    (0)           Average Customer Review 4.8 out of 5 stars (5 customer reviews)		Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
Most Helpful Customer Reviews   8 of 9 people found the following review helpful: 5.0 out of 5 stars Groundbreaking History, March 13, 2008 By  K. Kunster - See all my reviews (REAL NAME)    This is a must read for anyone on either side of the contentious issue of the ordination of women. This is an extremely well-written and well-documented story of the ordination of women in the Catholic Church into the 13th Century -- and it's an easy read as well. Macy separates the historical issues from the theological issues and then does a marvelous job of revealing that the definition of "ordination" used in the early church was different from the definition of "ordination" used since the 13th Century. Additionally, he pinpoints the 100 years in which the definition of "ordination" changed, and presents some convincing evidence to show why the definition changed, as well as the devastating effect it had on not only the diaconate and priestly ministry of women, but also other minsitries of women. Don't miss it. Comment Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)   3 of 3 people found the following review helpful: 4.0 out of 5 stars The light of the Dark Ages , March 28, 2009 By  Ashtar Command "Functional atheist, philosoph... (Stockholm, Sweden) - See all my reviews Those who read the New Testament carefully, will notice that some texts are more women-friendly than others. For instance, the apostle Paul mentions female prophets, travels together with a deaconess, greets a woman overseer and even mentions a female apostle (yes, really). It's also obvious that these office holders aren't celibate. From this, I draw the conclusion that primitive Christianity, while certainly not "feminist" in the modern sense, nevertheless had more gender equality than the later Church. I also draw the conclusion that the much maligned Paul was actually one of the proponents of this gender equality. But when did the Church became patriarchal? Most would argue that it happened around AD 100, with the emergence of a monarchic episcopate. Only men could become bishops. And, of course, all popes were men! The author of this book, Gary Macy, gives a more surprising answer. In his opinion, women weren't excluded from church offices until the High Middle Ages. The decisive change took place during the 11th, 12th and 13th centuries, with the Fourth Lateran Council (1215) as the end point of the transformation. If Macy is right, the "dark" Early Middle Ages were actually a better period for women than the High Middle Ages, a period that has been rehabilitated by many historians as a forerunner to the Renaissance. Or, at least, it was a better period for those women influential or fortunate enough to become part of the structures of the Church. Macy admits that the question of "women's ordination" is a tricky one. The definition of what constitutes a valid ordination has changed several times. So have ideas about who is to decide whether an ordination is valid or not. By modern Catholic definitions, for instance, women were (probably) never validly ordained in the past. But how old is this definition? Macy argues that it emerged during the High Middle Ages, and in some forms is no older than the 17th century. Also, the Church was more decentralized during the Early Middle Ages than during the High Middle Ages. Early medieval popes did disapprove of some women ordinations, but how much authority did these popes really have? An even trickier issue is the power and influence of the various orders. Somebody might argue that the ordained women were more lower-ranking than male priests and bishops. Macy draws the conclusion that the definition of "ordination" was much broader during the Early Middle Ages than later. "Ordination" simply meant appointment to a certain office, neither more nor less. In this sense, even kings and queens were considered "ordained". So were minor officers, such as doorkeeper and acolyte. Also, the ordination was often made by the community the office holders was supposed to serve, or by a temporal ruler. Of course, bishops could also ordain. The number of orders was quite large, and most of them were open to both men and women. Indeed, in some regions, *all* of the orders were open to women, at least occasionally. The rituals for ordaining women were often similar to those ordaining men. (The cover of the book shows the Virgin Mary dressed in something akin to priestly robes! Apparently, those were the vestments of a deaconess.) Historians have managed to find five references to female bishops. The most famous was a woman called "Theodora episcopa", who turns out to have been the mother of a 9th century pope. Saint Brigid of Ireland was even described as having undergone a successful episcopal ordination, but with a curious twist. Brigid's hagiographer claimed that the priest who ordained her didn't know what he was doing, since he was "intoxicated by the grace of God"! There are also numerous references to female priests, known as presbyterae, who served at the altar together with the male priests, even to the point of distributing the Eucharist. These presbyterae were legally ordained by bishops, but several popes voiced strong disapproval of the practice. Abbesses were also ordained, and often had as much power in their own jurisdictions as had bishops. Abbesses heard confessions from their nuns, prescribed penances and could decree excommunications. My personal favourite in Macy's book is the Irish abbess St. Bertila, who heard confession from the entire area surrounding her convent, presumably from laborers working the convent's lands. This included men! Thus, we have a Catholic nun hearing the confessions of male sinners. Dark ages, indeed. Once, St. Bertila heard the confessions of a male murderer, who was apparently very recalcitrant, since he refused to do penance. (He relented eventually, as well he might. People did believe in Hell back then.) There seems to have been one function that was never performed by females, namely the actual consecration of the bread and wine during the Eucharist. However, even here Macy has found tantalizing examples of possible exceptions, once again from convents, where masses and communions may have been occasionally held without male priests present. But even when women didn't consecrate the host and the wine, they were allowed to do almost everything else. Thus, there are examples of women handing over the bread and the wine to the consecrating priest, handling the consecrated elements afterwards and distributing them to the congregation, and (admittedly in a saintly vision) breaking the bread into the chalice, but without consecrating it. In later centuries, this would all become strictly prohibited. With obvious sympathies for the women, Macy describes how the definition of ordination changed during the High Middle Ages, how this was connected to a deepening chasm between clergy and laity, and the frankly misogynist propaganda accompanying the changes. Another favourite of mine is Peter Abelard, one of the few high medieval churchmen who defended women's ordinations, perhaps under the influence of Heloise (who Macy constantly refers to as Abelard's "wife"). What I lack in this book is an even broader historical outlook. For instance, it's obvious that the influence of women in the early medieval Church was connected to the decentralized character of the Church during this period, which in turn was connected to feudalism and the demands of the Germanic rulers to exclusive jurisdiction over the Church in their respective territories. Also, the early medieval popes were often dependent on the Frankish rulers, and de facto subordinate to them. After all, it was the Franks who had saved the Roman papacy from another Germanic intruder, the Lombards, making the papal states subservient to the Frankish kingdoms. This raises the interesting question whether the stronger role of women was a new phenomenon after the fall of the Roman Empire, or whether women had a strong role already during that empire? The writings of people like Augustine would suggest that they didn't. And what about the role of women in the Eastern church, where a centralized empire still existed? Macy points out that there were deaconesses in the Eastern church, but says little else about this. But this is a minor point. Overall, I find the book to be well-written, interesting, and honest. Together with this book, you might want to buy "Ordained women in the early Church. A documentary history". It contains translations of many of the primary sources mentioned in Macy's book. Women, it seems, were the lights of the Dark Ages. Comment Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this)   5 of 7 people found the following review helpful: 5.0 out of 5 stars An Important, Highly Readable Book!, March 16, 2008 By  Martha Barnette "info@marthabarnette.com" (California) - See all my reviews In this important volume, Gary Macy makes a clear, compelling case for the long and hidden history of women's ordination. How refreshing to find a book that's at once scholarly, meticulously researched, convincingly argued AND highly readable. And how fortunate for all of us that Macy presents this history in a way that is accessible to lay persons as well as academics. Reading this book is like taking a course with your favorite, most engaging history teacher ever. Highly recommended! Comment Comment | Permalink | Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report this) Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review › See all 5 customer reviews...		Ad feedback   Most Recent Customer Reviews 5.0 out of 5 stars An Important Theological Book for Our time In this time of radical transition more than forty years after Vatican II, nothing could be more salutary for the Church than Gary Macy's judicious historical study of women's... Read more Published 14 months ago by Frederick J. Parrella 5.0 out of 5 stars What to know how woman got to where they are read this book As a non-clergy or professor, I found this book to be a revealing history of woman not only in the church by in society in the twenty first century. Read more Published 15 months ago by Lee T. Mace Search Customer Reviews Only search this product's reviews › See all 5 customer reviews...

• Books > History > Europe
• Books > History > World > Medieval
• Books > History > World > Women in History
• Books > New & Used Textbooks > Humanities > History
• Books > New & Used Textbooks > Humanities > Religious Studies > Religious History
• Books > Religion & Spirituality > Christianity > Christian Living > Leadership
• Books > Religion & Spirituality > Christianity > Church History
• Books > Religion & Spirituality > Religious Studies > History