Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
4 of 4 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
*Captain Kirk and the Kitchen Sink*, March 19, 2002
"Spectre" is an excellent read. Book one of William Shatner's Mirror Universe Trilogy has nearly everything for the Star Trek fan. An exciting story line; practically everyone's favorite characters; non-stop action; events predictable and totally unpredictable. This book has everything. And of course, since it's written by Shatner, the protagonist is Captain Kirk.This novel takes the reader back to one of the ten greatest episodes in the entire Star Trek television history, "Mirror, Mirror". The author weaves a story of what occurred after Kirk's appearance there influences the Mirror Universe Spock. Fast forward that event through more than 100 years of history, and bring the Mirror Universe characters into our universe for action and revenge, and you'll get the gist of the story. Sounds like your basic Star Trek episode, but it really comes across as more than that. This novel is the best Star Trek novel I have read and I have read quite a few. Just when you think you've seen the last character that can be squeezed in that allows the book to retain continuity, and BANG, here is another surprise that fits right in. Or is it a Mirror Universe duplicate of that character? Read the book and find out for yourself. I rate this book at a very enjoyable 4.70 out of 5.00 stars, rounded up to 5.00. If this is your kind of book, you won't want to put it down. I'd tell you more but that would ruin the surprises. Perfect for several hours of get your mind off life and serious stuff reading. It is also a good jumping on point to check out Shatner's Kirk based stories. No one understands Kirk better than Shatner. The author proves what a terrific fan he is of the Star Trek history too.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
3 of 3 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Shatner or Kirk, who is this character?, October 1, 1999
Another Trek novel. Yes, I just can't get enough of these. They are kind of like the Bud Lite of SF, they go down easy and after you have read about five of them you don't notice the bad taste they sometimes leave in their wake. Well, I am a Star Trek fan and after reading Shatner's Get A Life book I do find myself with a bit of affection for the potbellied former Captain of the Enterprise. Unfortunately while this book has good pacing and has a bevy of interesting characters, I often didn't feel like I was seeing Kirk portrayed properly. It feels like Shatner is exploring his own feelings about age and love more and more with the Kirk character. There are endless scenes in the book where we find Kirk mooning over his love for Teilani, the exotic Klingon, Romulan hybrid that Kirk fell in love with in past books. In fact much of what motivates Kirk in the book is his endless love for this woman. That's all fine and dandy, but really, that isn't the Kirk that we have known up till now. In the The Return and Avenger, Kirk wasn't this dreamy eyed, (granted in one of those he was the brainwashed pawn) this book takes this to a whole new level. That said and done it was probably the main thing that irked me about the book, that and the ending. The beginning of the novel finds Kirk trying to settle down with Teilani, but she convinces him that he needs to go out and explore some more and find out whether he really wants to settle down with her or not. Of course, Kirk agrees to this and goes off to a few Starfleet functions to shoot the breeze with his old comrades in arms. While he is attending said functions he is kidnapped by mysterious forces. Cut to the Enterprise-E where Picard seems to have found the Voyager, the ship thought lost in the Delta Quadrant, or is it? The story gets a bit twisted and convoluted from there. It brings back the Mirror Universe plot-line which was first explored in the original Star Trek television show. Later the idea was further explored on episodes of Deep Space Nine and in other books including Dark Mirror by Diane Duane. While the ideas are a rehash, the plot is engaging and fast moving. Picard and his crew seem thrown in and aren't used very effectively, but then again what would you expect when Shatner writes a Star Trek novel? Of course Kirk gets top billing. There are quite a few characters that make a return in this novel including Spock, Scotty and Mccoy. Talk about the geriatric patrol. Amazingly, through luck, good breeding or just plain stubbornness they have all been able to survive into the time of the Next Generation. While the plot moves along there are a lot of melodramatic moments from Kirk either reminiscing about how good it is to be back with his crew or about his love for Teilani. The book is fast paced with a lot of action, it did keep me turning the pages, but the Kirk melodrama and some cookie cutter characters (read Next Generation) thrown into the mix bring the book down a few notches. Also just an FYI the ending is a "to be continued" one. So if you were thinking about picking this up in paperback, you might want to wait until the sequel Dark Victory is out so you can get the whole story. 3 out of 5 Bias: +1 if you are a rabid Star Trek fan. -1 if you hate Kirk or Shatner.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Interesting Story - Ultimately Nothing Really New, September 26, 2004
"Spectre" is, in my opinion, one of those books that the dedicated follower of the Star Trek mythos will probably get the most out of. Why? Because like the first trilogy by this same set of authors, much reliance is put on the exact timing of various events from the past - meaning, as a reader, you get the most enjoyment out of these, I think, if you can relate the events happening in the story with events that happened in the various Star Trek series. This is the scaffold upon which these authors like to build.
One problem for me is that these authors (from what I have seen in their books) can never quite seem to get the dates exactly right. Normally that would be a non-issue for me but since the authors so clearly predicate so much of their books on what I call "the fandom effect", this seems a curious oversight. That said, this story either takes place in 2374 or 2375, but definitely after the events of the movie "Star Trek: First Contact". (Careful fans, with an eye for details, will note that "Spectre", combined with the second book in the series, "Dark Victory", gets the dates a bit mangled. There are many references to events strewn in the novels and if you take them all together, they eventually start to slightly contradict. Nitpicking? Yes, but again bear in mind these authors like to really "get into" the Star Trek mythos thus when discrepancies appear in the dates, it is a bit distracting particularly since they give so many references to events in the series that it practically compels the careful reader into checking into the veracity of the dates. When all is said and done it is clear the authors want this story set in 2374.)
This novel takes one of the episodes from the Original Series ("Mirror, Mirror") and another episode from Deep Space 9 ("Crossover") and then runs from there, showing one possible sequence of events that force the two crews of the Original Series and the Next Generation to team up and figure out why the so-called "Mirror Universe" is threatening the Federation.
This is the first of a tightly correlated set of three books. So you might want to prepare for that if you decide to start in on this book. Also note that while not strictly necessary to understand the current story, it probably helps if you have read the previous trilogy by the authors (composed of "The Ashes of Eden", "The Return", and "Avenger") as this all explains why Kirk is still around even after the events of "Star Trek: Generations" and who Teilani is and why she is so important to Kirk. But, again, this book, the start of its own series, does stand on its own.
What I liked about the book was that, all in all, it was a good story that was quite fast-paced and that seemed to generally fit in the overall structure of Star Trek stories, with regard to characters and plotting and offered some intriguing unanswered questions to keep the reader motivated. What I ultimately disliked about the book is that it did not explore the concepts of the "Mirror Universe" at all. This universe is meant to be a mirror reflection (in a loose sense) of the universe our heroes occupy. As such, while there is some interesting side dialogue about just how alike the counterparts are, there is no real implications to any of this. The characters do not really fundamentally change as a result of the dealings with their counterparts. The "Mirror Universe" exists solely to propel what, in the end, is a fairly basic plot: Kirk and Picard teaming up to save the Federation. There are also the ambiguities that could have been explored about the Prime Directive and how that applies to another universe and what kind of help can or should be given in the situation the novel presents. This is all alluded to - but generally only as a means to dismiss it from further consideration in the plot. Finally, the juggling of action between the various characters (Kirk's crew, Picard's crew, the mirror universe counterparts) gets a little unwieldy in my opinion although it is held together by the pace of the action.
In the end I gave the book three stars. This is because the authors did provide an entertaining read that kept me wondering where the authors were going to take the plot but the book provided nothing very challenging or innovative about the Star Trek mythos for me.
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews
Was this review helpful to you?
|
|
|
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|