Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
16 of 17 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
A well-kept secret of Taoist wisdom., April 29, 1999
By A Customer
This book, unlike the more well known works by Lao-Tse and Chuang-Tse, is mostly made up of stories, and is very well suited to children. I read my library's copy, and I wish I could buy a copy to keep for myself, and for my children someday. It is an immensely comforting and wise text we owe to Lieh-Tse, a Taoist master who lived about two centuries after Lao-Tse.
|
|
|
7 of 7 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great material, but --, December 7, 2004
Lao Tzu, the first author of Taoism, described abstruse, metaphorical scenes in abstruse language. Chuang Tzu uses prosaic descriptions, but still described philosophical ideal rather than gritty facts. Lieh Tzu came later. He used prosaic words to describe prosaic, everyday scenes, and to find enlightenment in them.
Many ring true for me. The "yellow mare" reminded me of a technician who was finely attuned to the circuits we used. He was always wrong in his diagnosis onf the problems he showed me. That never mattered. He was always right in pointing out that there was a problem, often based on small clues that I might have missed.
Lieh discusses honesty and friendship, poverty and happiness, great riches and death. Still, the language is always modern and clear, and a good supplement to Chuang and Lao.
My problem, though, is that this isn't a translation. It's Wong's interpretation. She says, early on, "Instead of a straight translation of the sematics of the text, I have decided to present the 'voice' of Lieh Tzu." As much as I like Wong's text, it troubles me. Translation is never exact, but there are degrees of inexactness. I am concerned about how much Lieh's text has suffered.
This is good anyway, and I'll probably come back to it eve if I find a more scholarly Lieh Tzu. This is readable and thought-provoking, no matter what it's authenticity.
//wiredweird
|
|
|
6 of 6 people found the following review helpful:
5.0 out of 5 stars
Great, July 16, 2004
The Lieh Tzu is truly one of the most magnificent works of all time. I enjoyed it just as much as the Taoist centerpiece text the Tao Te Ching, and much more than than the Chuang Tzu, another widely ready Taoist classic.
Keep in mind that this edition of the Lieh Tzu is not a direct translation; rather, it is Eva Wong's version that is a generally a very loose translation and interpretation.
I actually prefer this edition slightly more than other more literal translations (by AC Graham [entire text], Lionel Giles [roughly 1/3 of the text], and Anton Forke [Yang Chu chapter].
The Lieh Tzu is for the most part a series of philosophical tales and essays. Though it is categorized as Taoist, it most likely incorporates material from a fairly wide variety of sources.
Overall the text is very interesting, and truly a must read not just for fans of Taoism, but for virtually anybody else.
Also see my review of AC Graham's translation.
Rodney Ohebsion
|
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|