Customer Reviews: Comeblack
Automotive Deals HPCC Amazon Fashion Learn more Discover it Pink Floyd Fire TV Stick Sun Care Handmade school supplies Shop-by-Room Amazon Cash Back Offer angrybirds angrybirds angrybirds  Amazon Echo  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Echo Dot  Amazon Tap  Amazon Echo Introducing new colors All-New Kindle Oasis AutoRip in CDs & Vinyl Water Sports

Format: Audio CD|Change
Price:$8.67+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on January 24, 2012
Between the newly released 3D concert blu-ray and this new compilation record, it's great to see the Scorpions providing a plethora of high-quality content during their farewell tour. Sting in the Tail was a fantastic final record with a great blend of hard-hitting tracks and powerful ballads. It appeared the Scorpions were done there, but a final trip to the studio has given the fans an added treat.

Comeblack is essentially the encore to Sting in the Tail, and while it lacks original tracks, the new takes on classic tracks are killer. The re-recorded Scorpions tracks are original enough to warrant a listen thanks to incredible production values. Meine's vocals are absolutely stunning and the instrumentals follow suit with Kottak's brutal drums and expert guitar work from Schenker, Jabs, and Maciwoda. In regards to the covers of songs from other bands, some may be turned off by inclusions like Ruby Tuesday and Tainted Love, but I fully support their tributes to the songs that influenced them. It's really cool to see a hard rock band like the Scorpions covering Beatles and Rolling Stones songs, not to mention that the tracks all fitting covers that do justice to the source material.

In what is likely to be the last Scorpions release, Comeblack is a fantastic send-off for the Scorpions' phenomenal 40+ year career.
0Comment| 18 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 29, 2012
Is it possible to fall in love all over again with the same ol' songs that are played all the time at show after show and we hear time and time again on classic radio? That's a resounding HELL YEAH!!

First, let me say it was nice to hear Klaus Meine sing the entirety of the songs. Usually in a LIVE show, he has the audience help quite a bit. This is okay, because that's what the fans love to do and what Klaus loves to hear. But, it was refreshing hearing his voice throughout the whole CD. Second, let me say, the man with the bionic voice has never sounded better. He is in rare form and I love hearing these classics in his current voice, which barely sounds any different than his golden years. It's a superb feeling, hearing that incredible signature primal snarl once again on the rockers and then to turn around and hear that soft velvet voice, such as on Still Loving You, almost like he's whispering in your ear. It's like silk on skin. Hey, remember guys, I am a woman and call it like I hear it.

One thing I did ask myself at one point while listening to No One Like You was; is it LIVE or is it Memorex? For those too young to remember the commercial; it was an ad about a Memorex cassette tape being played up against the real singer and they asked in the ad, "is it LIVE or is it Memorex?" Okay, well, that is what I asked at first. Some of the guitar parts, especially the solos, were so exact, that I really wondered for a minute if the original guitar parts had literally been dubbed into the current song or did these guys actually channel their early years and remained so true to the originals that I really couldn't tell. However, I can assure you with certainty, that these songs have been redone, no dubbing included. Just listen and you can hear the difference between the new songs and the classic songs; there's a maturity, a more polished and refined sound, if you will. I also love the heavier sound they put to them; Rhythm of Love for instance. That really rocks. I am, to say the least, very impressed and am excited as hell over this CD. I still can't get over how Klaus sounds, and how Matthias attacks the Lead and James adding a fresh beat to the mix. I love the dual guitars, as usual the seamless mix of Schenker's and Jabs' guitar playing that is so cultured after all these years, gives it such a fine balance. I also want to say that I don't believe for a minute that Matthias or Rudolf would stand for dubbing the old guitars onto their new CD. They are proud of their abilities and so therefore, I am convinced that they are redoing these songs. Additionally, even though James and Pawel weren't members at the time of these classics, I have to say they hold their own. For the seasoned diehard Scorps fan, they can hear the difference in James' style compared to Herman's. And yet, James has added his own character, along with Pawel's bottom bass to make them new sounding. And they sound gooood! And I will always love Rudolf's rhythm guitar and his leads of course. He's so accomplished.

The other half of the CD is covers. Who ever thought they would do several covers on their album? Yeah sure, they have done covers before, but not to this extent.

I love Tainted Love. The way Klaus and the boys made it their own without losing the originality of the song, was most inspiring. Most of the time, when a band records covers, they make it so much their own, they screw up the song. Not so with Scorps. They probably realized how many times THEIR songs were covered and screwed up, so didn't want to make the same mistake. The lead solo by Matthias using that tremolo is a fantastic composition. And James' drums are hard driving fantastic!

Children of the Revolution is one heavy riffed song and it's one to really get into. It's heavier than what Scorpions have done in quite some time. Even though it was a cover, I was glad to hear Klaus' ability to still sing with that much strength. James is slamming out that beat that is so his form. And do we even have to mention the guitars? LOVE that heavy metal sound. But, guess what you hear at the end; that unmistakable signature sound of Matthias Jabs. If you were to listen to the original by T. Rex, you would find that there is no comparison. Scorpions killed this one and put the original to shame! I would love to see them add this to their final 2012-13 tour!

The choice of Across the Universe was a surprise to me as I have so many others in mind from The Beatles they could have done. But that's not my call. Listen, I'm not really complaining it's just not one of my favorite Beatle songs. Klaus, as usual, does it justice though, with that caressing smoothness of his voice, making the song so very much his own.

Tin Soldier starts out sort of poppy, but then suddenly it gets very "Scorpionized". It's almost like THEY wrote and did this song already. I liked it because of that familiar feeling of Golden Days Scorps. Actually, I'm really liking this song a lot.

All Day and All of the Night is fun for me because it's one I have loved since way back when. And for my favorite band to redo it is a double treat. What I find consistent in these covers is that they don't change it up so drastically that it loses the original sound. And yet Scorps still make it their own by adding to the songs, such things as, Matthias' distinguished lead guitar sound that put him in the annals of one of the best guitar players in the 80's, and what gave Scorpions their unique sound, and the inimitable, distinct raucous voice of the one and only Klaus Meine are still there. Of course there is James giving his own flavor along with Rudolf and Pawel. Other than that, the songs remain the same.

I like how they begin Ruby Tuesday. I couldn't quite put my finger on the guitar intro and why it sounded so familiar until I went and replayed both The Best Is Yet to Come and The Good Die Young intros. Yep, there it was that feeling of the two sort of mixed together for the Ruby Tuesday intro. I agree with a friend of mine who said the boys do this far better than the great Rolling Stones. Scorpions do this song such justice, Stones should be proud. Matthias does quick little licks that are so characteristic; it's such a pleasure to hear this little bit of Scorps in an infamous cover song.

I highly recommend this excellently done CD. It's a wonderful trip into a classical rock tour; from their originals to covers that they excelled at in their execution. By the way, I put this on my MP3 player because I love listening to these splendid works in my ear while making people wonder why I have such a silly grin on my face.
I want to end with this; I may have given Klaus and Matthias many kudos, but without the entire team, the stability of the Scorps machine with Klaus, Rudolf, Matthias, James, and Pawel, this would not have sounded as good. And even though there are new members that did not do these songs back in the day, it still turned out first-rate. So I say kudos to all of them.

Buy this now!!!
33 comments| 14 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on February 16, 2012
This new Scorpions release is a mix of 7 re recordings of songs from their classic 1980-1991 period and 6 cover songs. While the Scorpions have more than earned the right to do whatever they want, I find this release to be ok but unessential. First the issue of Re Recording. As the re recordings are of classic songs with nothing really new revealed in them, I say what's the point of redoing a classic? Take any of the first 7 songs, why would we want to hear them redone? The originals are all classics in their own right.
Secondly, the issue of the cover tunes. While Children of the Revolution and All Day and All of the Night really do rock hard and sound great, I don't feel like any new ground is really broken. The covers of Across the Universe or Tainted Love really didn't do it for me.
In summary, I am not sure what listener this is aimed at. If you are fairly new to the Scorpions and want some or all of these classic hits, buy one of the greatest hits that are available by the band not this. At least you will have the originals and you probably won't care about hearing some cover tunes by the band. If you are a fan of the "classic period" of the Scorpions (The Mercury Records Years), and want something by the band, Pick up their 2007 release Humanity Hour One and if you are unfamiliar with any of the studio albums prior to 1978's Tokyo Tapes definitely seek those out. If you are a hardcore fan that picks up everything the band releases, then you probably own this already! I personally don't find anything new here that is essential. This will be one that will probably go on the shelf and probably not come out often.
11 comment| 10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on April 1, 2013
My music tastes were built around 80's Hard Rock and Metal Music. Judas Priest, Iron Maiden, Accept, etc. The Scorpions were always a favorite of mine. I saw this CD and decided to buy it. I love their music, but I almost regret buying this. Their classic songs on this CD are not re-masters, but re-done with a new perspective. The originals are much better, and it seems as if the band did these remakes in two hours. The rest of the album is covers of other songs, and they are good, and probably save me from rating this album lower than 3 Stars. Here's hoping the Scorps aren't done making new music, because I don't want to remember them with this one.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 30, 2013
We went to Scorpions concert The last sting so after that I wanted to get a CD. I thought CD would be the same as concert. Most of the songs they sing during concert are on this CD but also some remakes I'm not too crazy about, but overall I'm happy with purchase.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on July 6, 2013
This is a great CD for's well put together for any long-time fan and worth the purchase. It's not forced and offers up some new mixes on old favs. but also some new covers by the Scorpions themselves that I had not heard before! Would recommend!
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on May 3, 2013
If your a huge scorpions fan i would say if their is any chance you might enjoy a track or 2 on here you might want to pick it up. Overall its impressive(for remake cd) i like a few of the remakes and redone songs alot certainly not all of them but enough to make me like it. So if your a huge scorpions fan then id say this is a must have to complete your collection if your not listen to the demos before purchasing is the best advice i can give.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on January 28, 2012
I love the Scorpions, and Humanity Hour One will always be one of my favorite CDs. The remakes of their original material are pretty good, especially the vocals. The lyrics are much easier to understand, which makes most the songs better. Interesting choices for the extra songs. Some work, like Ruby Tuesday and Children of the Revolution. The others are mediocre at best. Their take on Tin Soldier is horrible. This is easily one of the worst remakes of any song in history. It starts out fine, but the main chorus, I have no idea what they were thinking. If you want a remake of that song, look to Lou Gramm, he did it right.

Overall, I am glad I bought this CD, Ill record it to MP3, and cut out Tin Soldier. Buy it for the a more modern vibe on their material, not for the other remakes.

And someone force the Scorps to make Hour 2 of Humanity.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on March 22, 2015
Can't really rate a rehash of old songs 5 stars, but this is really great music. Somehow, the new productions sound "bigger" than the old original recordings. Perhaps more robust. Not sure if it's all in production, or modern instruments and recording facilities. Klaus still sounds great, and the guitars are still awesome.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Like all good arena rocking veterans, The Scorpions are taking their sweet time with the whole retirement thing. Their farewell tour seems to be a multi-year event, and their "final" album Sting in the Tail has now been followed-up by Comeblack, an unusual collection of material that is sure to surprise most Scorpions fans.

Comeblack is a mixed bag. The first seven songs are rerecordings of classic Scorpions songs like "Rock You Like a Hurricane" and "Rhythm of Love." For the most part they're not bad, but they're not remotely necessary either. The songs weren't broke the first time, and don't need fixing here.

It's the second half of the album where Comeblack really shines. Here the Scorpions serve up six very interesting and very unexpected covers, including songs by The Kinks, The Small Faces and The Beatles. Now, I'm sure exactly no one ever thought about the Scorpions covering "Tainted Love," but it actually works pretty well. Their versions of "Ruby Tuesday" and "Children of the Revolution" are real highlights, but the album's best song is Klause Meine's heartfelt rendition of the Beatles' "Across the Universe," which is just chilling.

In the end, Comeblack probably deserves a 3.5-star rating. The re-recordings are pretty useless, but the covers are terrific. A full covers album would have been much better, but there's enough quality material here that most Scorpions fans should find something to enjoy.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.