11 of 14 people found the following review helpful
Good read, but not airborne,
This review is from: China Airborne (Hardcover)
Fallows certainly can write an entertaining book. He starts by taking the Chinese aerospace industry as a metaphor for China. And he comes up with amusing and interesting anecdotes from his travels in China. Furthermore he also helped me to understand more about the aerospace industry as such, its commercial logic, challenges and risks. I enjoyed the fast read, the 'easy listening' style of the authors writing.
Yet overall the book disappoints. By taking this particular industry as a metaphor for China he move too fast away from aerospace into general political and economic territory. Thus there is little to be learned about the Chinese airlines, how they are being operated, how did they come into being, why there are so many and how they are competing. This would have been just one topic of interest among many others relating to aerospace.
The other territory, general politics, economic development of China etc. has also been sufficiently covered too many other books and here Fallows adds little new to the gigantic mountain of literature. Furthermore, he obviously had to rely completely on intermediaries (interpreters, foreigners living in China). There are even newspapers in China dedicated to the aerospace industry. How valuable can reporting be if the reporter is not even able to use this basic sources of information?
Three stars because the writing is good, but not more, as the content does not live up to expectations.