Customer Review

210 of 210 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Best Mid-Range Camcorder - Excellent for Low Light, November 4, 2011
This review is from: Canon VIXIA HF M40 Full HD Camcorder with HD CMOS Pro and 16GB Internal Flash Memory (Electronics)
Well, stating that this is the best mid-range camcorder is quite a claim, but to be fair, it's not my assertion - that award was just bestowed on the M40 this week by CamcorderInfo.com ...and by mid-range, they mean video cameras priced between $500 and $1000. What makes this camera an even better deal is that you can get all three versions (M400, M40, and M41) for under $500.

Keep in mind that most reviewers of camcorders look at specs and then make a subjective judgment about the quality of the video. The CamcorderInfo.com folks (with whom I am not affiliated) do extensive lab-based testing to measure, for example, color accuracy, noise, and low-light performance in controlled and consistent conditions. The fact that they rate this camera so highly is high praise indeed. They also have a great 11 page review on the M40 if you are interested.

So why did they like this camera so much? Put simply, its sensor. This camera's sensor is larger and more optimized for HD video than the competition. Most of those other cameras use a quarter inch sensor, while this camera has one that is one-third of an inch size. When you calculate sensor area, that is a heck of a difference. Canon has also optimized the hardware and software to focus this sensor on HD resolution...so it does it well. Many other cameras not only have a smaller sensor, they integrate it so it can record HD *and* higher than HD resolution still pictures. Canon did not do so here. Yes, you can take still photos with the camera, but at full HD resolution only (1920×1080) - not larger. Canon appears to have decided to not sacrifice video quality to get a higher megapixel rating for still pictures. Hey, you are buying a *video* camera...right? :)

So what are they then doing with such a large sensor? Grabbing more light, suppressing visual noise, and getting better color accuracy. Even more impressive is that this camera has the exact same sensor as CamcorderInfo's "price be darned" consumer camcorder of the year - Canon Vixia HF G10 ($1499). Yes, buy an M400, M40, or M41 and you will get a sensor that is in the best consumer video camera of the year.

So what do you sacrifice? Primarily, 60p. This camera shoots at 60i...with modes for 30p and 24p. Some other mid-range cameras shoot at 60p. Does that make them better? Well, that depends on your usage. If filming indoors is important to you (e.g., birthday parties, school plays, indoor sports), then 60p of dark video isn't all that useful...and bright 60i video with accurate colors cannot be beat. Personally, I have filmed my daughter's gymnastics in a moderately dark gym and even with the fast movement, the video was jaw-dropping.

You also give up the aforementioned high-resolution still pictures, but frankly, I think that's a gimmick. The zoom is also limited to 10x...which is another concession Canon made to otherwise bring you a top notch video camera at this price. For me, 10x is overkill even from the cheap seats at my daughter's events, but your mileage my vary.

Frankly, I think that this camera is getting discounted because many consumers purchase either based on price alone or by looking at specs. Specs like 60p jump off the page. The fact that this camera's sensor is so superior to much of the competition is a far more subtle advantage...that perhaps may hurt the sales of this line. Well, hey, that's good news for you. When I first started looking at the M41, it was $799. I just picked it up for $499...and an M40 for $449. Awesome stuff. Get a camera that beats the rest of the mid-range and its price is below the mid-range. :)

...

So what's not to like?

1) The software. You get two packages - a video transfer utility and a video browser/editor that also includes a transfer capability. You can only choose to install one. I opted for the video browser/editor, which installed fine on Windows 7 Pro 64bit, but then would not work....and I am apparently not the lone ranger. Thus, I uninstalled and just installed the transfer utility...which just moves the files. It's also not very configurable. Of course, you can also just connect the camera to your PC and drag the files off yourself, but that's a bit more work...and the transfer utility does a good job of keeping track of what you have already copied off.

This software issue really disappointed me, but to be frank, the software included with most cameras is pretty bad. Sony sells a fantastic video editor - Sony Vegas (multiple editions), but does not bundle it with the Sony cameras that I considered. In fact, the software that they do bundle is apparently also not compatible with 64 bit OSes...so factor in that you will probably need to buy editing software if you want to play around with the video. Actually, the M400/40/41 line allows you to cut videos, introduce fades, and add titles in the camera, but I'd prefer to do it on my PC with more capable software. No worries, you have your choice of a wide range of very capable video editing packages for well under 100 beans...and most of them trump anything that would ever be bundled with a camera.

2) The battery...which is very small. In fact, it is significantly physically smaller than the recessed cavity into which it fits. I smell Canon's marketing and sales departments at work with this decision. Oh well, the included battery works well for my use (i.e., 60 to 90 mins of filming), but I could easily see how someone else may feel compelled to get a second larger capacity battery.

3) The lens...which maxes at 10x, but some folks claim suffers from vignetting at greater than 5x when the aperture is wide open. It's also not very wide. You can address some of these issues with an aftermarket wide angle lens (bulky) and by playing with F stops in manual mode when you are shooting against a monochromatic background, but Canon could have done better. That said, these issues don't really bother me and the camera's low-light capabilities are perfect for me...so I am in a forgiving mood. ;)

4) The LCD screen...which is resistive (not capacitive), so it takes either a firm push or you must use a fingernail. On the positive side, you can use it while wearing gloves. Also a plus - it's bright. Brighter than the LCD on the more expensive G10, albeit with fewer pixels.

5) The Menus...which are not very intuitive. I had to read the manual cover to cover to see what the camera could do...and now that I know, I'll plod through menus looking for what I need. Amazing, because the menus on my Canon 40D are awesome.

...

So, if I didn't scare you away...and low-light is a big deal to you...which model should you get?

That depends. If you have plenty of high-speed SD cards, the M400 may be the ticket. It has no internal memory. Instead, it has two SD card slots and supports relay recording between the cards. Actually, all three models have two such slots...and support relay recording. The M40 adds 16 GB of internal memory and the M41 ups that to 32 GB and gives you a viewfinder, which is nice for sunny days.

I originally bought the M40 since I didn't want to find myself in the stands and realize that I didn't have an SD card in the camera, but then returned it and picked up the M41 since my wife seemed to miss having a viewfinder. That said, I hear many folks who have the viewfinder still end up using the LCD most of the time. Whatever you choose, you essentially get the same camera otherwise...with the awesome sensor from the HF G10.

On the other hand, if you shoot almost exclusively fast moving action in decent lighting conditions, you may be better served by a camera that supports 60p and/or suffers less from vignetting...but check the CamcorderInfo web site to see how each camera does shooting video rather than relying on specs alone.

So why 5 stars with these warts? Because I just don't see any other option anywhere near this price that will give you such a fantastic low-light sensor and the resultant high-quality video. It's the current mid-range low-light king...and I feel that it's only fair to rate it based on the current competition in the price range. If low-light capabilities are not a priority for you, then I would drop the rating to 4 stars. If you were familiar with the term vignetting before this review and look for it in the corners of your pictures and videos, you probably would rate lower.

...

BTW, if you *do* decide to buy either an M400, M40, or M41, do yourself a favor and switch the camera off AUTO mode. AUTO mode is locked to 1440x1080 at 7 Mbps...and this baby can do 1920x1080 at all the way up to 24 Mbps...but not in AUTO mode. Many other useful menu items are hidden in AUTO mode...like the one that changes the powered IS from "push and hold" to "toggle on/off".

cheers,
Scuba
Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 
Was this review helpful to you? Yes No

[Add comment]
Post a comment
To insert a product link use the format: [[ASIN:ASIN product-title]] (What's this?)
Amazon will display this name with all your submissions, including reviews and discussion posts. (Learn more)
Name:
Badge:
This badge will be assigned to you and will appear along with your name.
There was an error. Please try again.
Please see the full guidelines here.

Official Comment

As a representative of this product you can post one Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
The following name and badge will be shown with this comment:
 (edit name)
After clicking the Post button you will be asked to create your public name, which will be shown with all your contributions.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.  Learn more
Otherwise, you can still post a regular comment on this review.

Is this your product?

If you are the author, artist, manufacturer or an official representative of this product, you can post an Official Comment on this review. It will appear immediately below the review wherever it is displayed.   Learn more
 
System timed out

We were unable to verify whether you represent the product. Please try again later, or retry now. Otherwise you can post a regular comment.

Since you previously posted an Official Comment, this comment will appear in the comment section below. You also have the option to edit your Official Comment.   Learn more
The maximum number of Official Comments have been posted. This comment will appear in the comment section below.   Learn more
Prompts for sign-in
 

Comments

Tracked by 6 customers

Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 16 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Nov 10, 2011 9:46:03 PM PST
P. Johnson says:
Nice revue. I bought one @$725, plus extra 819 bat and charger. Saw it for $499, bought another one. Next day it was down to $449....Must have been AMZs last gasp, now it is available from "others" for $480..I wanted two, one for the house and one for the glove box.

Posted on Nov 10, 2011 9:49:45 PM PST
P. Johnson says:
Nice revue. I bought one, HF 41, @$725, plus extra 819 bat and charger. Saw it for $499, bought another one. Next day it was down to $449....Must have been AMZs last gasp, now it is available from "others" for $480..I wanted two, one for the house and one for the glove box.

Posted on Nov 19, 2011 9:53:11 AM PST
MB says:
Great review. We bought this camera a week ago from our local camera shop with an over the counter rebate for $499. I was alittle hesitant, as our old Sony trv720 handycam does a great job, especially since we use only 8mm data tapes. I read all the reviews. What I did learn from your review, was I have been shooting at 7mps in auto mode, and we were still blown away. When I'm done here I will try it at the higher resolutions. Like all reviews I'm not wild about the touch screen thing and I thought something was wrong with the view finder. Found out there is a slide switch alongside of it that puts everything in focus. ( Just skimed over the maunal) it's my guy thing, who needs to look at a manual. Now I want to make dvd's or in the future blueray disks. Open to some advice on software. By the way just found out my buddie and his wife just bought the cannon hf-m41 after seeing ours, at only 7mps at that.
One great camera in the $500 bracket, very happy, thanks Bob B

Posted on Nov 27, 2011 12:14:36 PM PST
Bernhar4 says:
I noticed you mentioned Sony Vegas editing software. I recently purchased Sony Vegas 11 and I was curious if you can simply drag your video files from the camera and edit them right away in Sony Vegas without having to do any type of converting for the file type. Thanks for any info you can provide :)

Posted on Dec 3, 2011 7:39:47 PM PST
T. Marshall says:
There is a "hidden menu" which allows you to change the gamma, saturation, brightness, and sharpening to your custom requirements. Most people miss it, but to me it is the greatest feature Canon has built into these cameras (starting at the HF100). Access it via the "Image Effects" menu. I set the brightness to -2 (to prevent over-exposure), saturation to -1 and gamma to -2 (they call it "contrast"). This gives reliable video capture which can be edited with Sony Vegas (or any other pro editor) into top-notch A-roll.

In reply to an earlier post on Dec 11, 2011 7:11:27 AM PST
J. Tessier says:
I use SV 11 - connect to PC via usb and drag mts files directly. No problems editing directly with my configuration.

Posted on Dec 22, 2011 2:56:02 PM PST
T. Ijaz says:
You say in your review that "AUTO mode is locked to 1440x1080 at 7 Mbps...and this baby can do 1920x1080 at all the way up to 24 Mbps...but not in AUTO mode". This is incorrect. Yes, the default setting with AUTO is at SP, which is 7Mbps. But you can change that in Manual mode. Once changed, switching back to Auto mode will retain the bit rate setting you chose. Mine is currently set at MXP, the highest level and it stays in that mode when I switch to AUTO as well.

In reply to an earlier post on Dec 23, 2011 9:19:29 AM PST
new user says:
Could you tell me if the place of origin has anything to do with whether or not Canon will honor the warranty? I was told by a vendor that if a canon camcorder was a "Japanese" model, Canon would not honor the warranty, and that if it was a US camcorder, they would. Is that true and how can you tell if the camcorder you buy is one or the other? I bought the HF M41 from a vendor here on Amazon a couple of days ago and am waiting for it to come. But I'm concerned about the Canon warranty.

In reply to an earlier post on Dec 23, 2011 11:21:44 AM PST
T. Ijaz says:
The North America model is called Vixia and the Japanese model is called iVis. I doubt you ordered the Japanese model as those are considerably more expensive in the U.S. (gray market).

In reply to an earlier post on Dec 23, 2011 12:44:43 PM PST
new user says:
Ok..thanks. I'll check to see if the camcorder says Vixia when it comes. While I was originally searching for the camera, it was discounted by canon and things went a little crazy with everyone scrambling around to buy and sell them. I found it on Ebay from a company called Focus Camera and called the company directly to order it. The sales rep there told me what a great deal it was, the price was going up after my order was placed..blahblahblah. He placed the order for $399 and then called back to tell me that they were all sold out because of the Ebay auction..but he said that I wouldn't have wanted that model anyway bcuz it was a Japanese camera and that Canon wouldn't honor the warranty. Went back on Ebay and sure enough, there was the camera, for $649 from their store..so I guess they didn't really sell out and were just wanting to make a couple hundred more dollars by telling me it wasn't available. Anyway, I started my search all over and found it from a seller on Amazon. I don't believe he is an "authorized distributor" as it states in the Canon Warranty information on Canon's website, so I wondered what would happen should I have a problem with the camera in the next year. The website mentioned a sales receipt from an authorized dealer and registration, etc. I have submitted a msg to Amazon to ask about this, too. Needless to say, I'm a bit skeptical about buying anything like that online after that happened. Unfortunately, none of the stores in my area carried them and the ones that did are sold out.
‹ Previous 1 2 Next ›

Review Details

Item

Reviewer


Location: Reston, VA, USA

Top Reviewer Ranking: 5,176