3 of 5 people found the following review helpful
IDEAS HAVE CONSEQUENCES,
Verified Purchase(What's this?)
This review is from: Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide (Paperback)
I read this book in researching a paper on euthanasia; the author seemed, as a Christian clergyman and former gastroenterologist, to have a unique perspective.
Surprisingly, given this background, Father Manning gives a date in the "BCE" and
"CE" (as opposed to BC and AD) terminology,favored by those who have a negative attitude towards Christianity. More disturbing than this is the author's support for passive euthanasia - the withholding of nutrition and fluids from patients, especially those with decreased levels of consciousness (he mentions he does not like the designation of passive euthanasia - euphemisms are preferred today).
Mentioned parenthetically,on page 20, is the determination that the denial of adequate medical care to noviates is ethical. Forty years ago my wife was a noviate nun (SND) in Chardon, Ohio; she had a pulmonary exposure at the time - not adequately treated - which has resulted in progressive and inoperable bronchiectasis, a potentially fatal lung condition. I am not sure how canon law would analyze this. Maybe we could try Luke 14 or Matthew 25:41-45.