80 of 92 people found the following review helpful
Fun game. Not an RPG,
This review is from: Paper Mario: Sticker Star (Video Game)
In honesty I haven't played a Paper Mario game since the first one on the 64, and a little bit of Thousand Year Door. I Did watch the one on the Wii get played but I never played it myself.
To sum it up, PM3DS is NOT an RPG in the sense that All the other paper Mario games are. If your looking for Exp and levels and stats this is not the game for you. It's more like... like Zelda than an RPG. You have a certain amount of HP that can be increased by finding heart containers (+5 HP Per) that's it. your attacks are based on the Stickers you find and they are all one use attacks. Once you use them you can't use it again ever unless you find the sticker again. Now this may seem horrible but actually it creates a really fun strategy game in a way.
You get X amount of pages of stickers, on average you can fit about 15 per page, some stickers are bigger and take up 4-8 slots on a page so you have to be careful. But these big ones are the strongest attacks in the game and are fun to watch. They are like summons from the Final Fantasy series. I say X amount of pages because you gain more of those as the game goes on.
Now as for the stickers themselves, there are 96 combat stickers and 64 "Thing" stickers (These are the Big stickers, i like to call them Summons). Once you find a summon sticker you can buy it again and use it, however you can only have one of the same summon at a time. But they have more than just uses inside of battle, these stickers can (and some times HAVE to) be used outside of battle to open up pathways or to clear a sandstorm etc... and this is where I think the game gets fun. It doesn't hold your hand at all you have to figure out which stickers to use, where they are hidden and if you chose the wrong sticker you do lose it. It's where the Metroid/Zelda feeling hits me that I like it. Problem solving has always been a plus for me in these kinds of games, and having to backtrack a bit to find a lost item i missed is entertaining... mostly. I think Metroid takes it a level TOO far but that's OK.
As for the combat since this is a Paper Mario game. I find combat to be a lot of fun. As I said you use your stickers to fight and there are plenty to choose from. It's a matter of choosing which stickers can kill your opponents in one shot or not. But it's not a simple one click and watch fight (well the summons are) you have to hit the action button at the right time to perform a timed attack just like in the old Mario RPG game, and all the RPG Mario games since. The boss battles are a bit more ridiculous and even involve a bit of problem solving. Each boss tends to have a weakness, usually one of the summon stickers. For instance one will become much weaker if you use the bat on it. Sadly I never had those stickers for those fights and i end up using a lot of my battle stickers to win, but I found it to be a lot of fun. Lastly, the main point of the game is not only to collect stickers, but coins as well. With coins you can buy more stickers and summon stickers, and it gives you access to the battle spinner in combat. The battle spinner gives you a chance to use more than one sticker in a turn letting you combo certain ones together. It's expensive but a lot of fun. I ended up spending all my money to kill a boss cause I messed up big time. But I killed him!
All in all I think it's a fun game, the humor is silly and all paper themed, but in a good way. I like that they are aware that they are paper and don't really question it. If you are however looking for a good RPG... this isn't it. In fact I wouldn't even call it an RPG same as I wouldn't call Zelda an RPG. It's more of an... Action Platformer. A great addition to the 3DS library all in all and it's even available on the e-shop.
Things I Like:
+Figuring out which stickers to bring and managing them is fun to me
+The levels are silly but fun, as is the humor
+Plenty of stickers to collect and use
+Summon stickers are fun to watch
+Rewarding when solving a puzzle as the game has 0 hand holding
Things I thought were meh
:Not an actual RPG. I would have liked at least an Attack or Defense stat, as it stands I have to remember the damage of every item
:I'm slightly worried about game length, it doesn't appear to be that long a game though I may be wrong
:Sometimes the Dialogue can go on for a bit longer than needed, though not often
Things I don't like
-The loss of a battle companion is sad, i liked having a sidekick
-The bosses can be unfair at times and if you didn't bring the right summon sticker than it's going to be a LOT harder, though still possible
-You find out what sticker to use on the boss... after you kill it or during the fight where it's already too late
-Selling Stickers takes a long time sometimes.
as it stands I give the game an 8/10. it's not GOTY, but it's fun.
Tracked by 1 customer
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-10 of 19 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Nov 12, 2012 6:05:23 PM PST
This game is still in fact an RPG. The experience and stats are not the only factors in what make an RPG an RPG.
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 13, 2012 4:32:05 AM PST
Oh I know that, but it's about as much RPG as Zelda is. Both are RPGs but when MOST people hear the term RPG they think stats, and damage and equipment etc... not a card-like based combat system. There are a lot of people disappointed that this game isn't as RPG as the previous in the series and it's an understandable dislike. I merely put forth that this game is fun in it's own right, and not really because of the RPG mechanics.
Posted on Nov 13, 2012 7:38:22 AM PST
Alex Harker says:
No need to worry about length, the game is quite long. I've played almost 15 hours now and I'm still not through the first three worlds. Once you get the boat, you can see that there are three more worlds beyond that. I'm estimating that it will take me 35 to 40 hours to complete and that's not counting any additional time I might spend finishing my collection in the sticker museum or any additional worlds that might exist but that I haven't seen yet.
Posted on Nov 14, 2012 9:27:19 AM PST
Amazon Customer says:
You have the most and detailed awesome review of the game I did ever read.You need to be a gamer writer you are a PRO! I enjoy reading this review and this will help greatly. The game doesn't sound to bad but Im am an old schooler myself.Happu Holidays and Happy Thanksgiving!
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 14, 2012 10:25:29 AM PST
Thank you very much for the compliment, and Have a Great holiday Yourself :3
Posted on Nov 15, 2012 5:14:56 AM PST
Michael Gammell says:
That's a huge letdown that it's not an rpg. I was really looking forward to this. My wife got me a 3ds and this is one of the only games I was excited about. Oh well... Maybe I'll bust out the Gamecube version again.
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 15, 2012 6:14:49 AM PST
I was let down a bit by that too...
But the game grew on my fast. It is a great game to play while watching TV or a movie.
Posted on Nov 18, 2012 11:28:06 AM PST
L. Pagan says:
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 18, 2012 12:02:57 PM PST
True, but As I said. When people think RPG in terms of video games, a great number of us think of Stats and levels and growing stronger etc...
I don't consider Zelda an RPG, but that doesn't ruin my enjoyment of it.
In reply to an earlier post on Nov 20, 2012 1:30:00 PM PST
Amazon Customer says:
No, Zelda games aren't RPGs in term of the video game genre.
They are fantasy action adventure.