7 of 9 people found the following review helpful
There is a Vermeer book for less money that will be better for most readers,
This review is from: Vermeer and the Art of Painting (Hardcover)
My low rating is not intended to suggest that this is a BAD book. It is just that most persons who would benefit from reading this volume would benefit much more by instead reading the more comprehensive and less expensive "Johannes Vermeer" (hardcover ISBN 0300065582, softcover ISBN 0894682199, with 'The Geographer' on the cover), the book that accompanied the 1995-96 Vermeer exhibition at the National Gallery of Art (NGA).
If one wants perspective on 17th-century Delft and the art of that era which influenced Vermeer, and on Vermeer's chronology (to the extent it's known), the NGA book presents this much better in it's initial series of essays by experts than does "Vermeer and the Art of Painting". If one wants large, high-quality color plates of all 36 of Vermeer's attributed paintings with analysis of each, the NGA book is far superior (with detailed, multi-page analysis of each of the 23 paintings that were in the exhibit, and lesser discussion in the essays of the 13 that weren't). By comparison, "Art of Painting" covers only 16 of his works in detail (but does show all 36 in black and white, without discussion, in its catalogue at the end).
The title of this book (".. and the Art of Painting") suggests that this book gets more into the technical aspects of Vermeer's style and method, of interest to more serious students of Vermeer. And, in fact, for the 16 paintings covered in detail in this book, the discussion of Vermeer's style and method does get a bit more technical than in the corresponding detailed multi-page write-ups in the NGA book (although the NGA book by no means ignores these technical issues).
In summary, if you want to establish an exhaustive library on Vermeer, this book will offer some incremental additional technical information on SOME of his paintings, beyond what is in the NGA volume. However, for readers who are looking for the single best definitive volume on Vermeer at reasonable cost, the comprehensive NGA book is the best choice, hands down. In no case would the "Art of Painting" be a suitable SUBSTITUTE for the NGA volume.
Tracked by 1 customer
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: Jan 19, 2011 4:18:42 PM PST
Last edited by the author on Jan 19, 2011 4:20:25 PM PST
Marie A. Jenkins says:
You don't seem to understand the purpose of this book wasn't to provide a comprehensive resource on Vermeer but to cover the technical arts of his painting.
Or rather, you do seem to acknowlege that this was the purpose of this book, but then you go on to rate it as if it were a cultural reference! You can't rate all books based on your own little window of interest.
In reply to an earlier post on Jul 6, 2012 4:33:32 PM PDT
I have to disagree with Marie. I'm a painter and Vermeer is my favorite painter. This book does a lousy job of covering his painting techniques. Too bad, it could have been great.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›